Toshiba trains its sights on NAND crown

TOKYO Fri May 23, 2008 4:45am EDT

Toshiba's Corporate Senior Vice President Shozo Saito smiles as he waits for his presentation at the Reuters Global Technology, Media and Telecoms Summit in Tokyo May 22, 2008. REUTERS/Kiyoshi Ota

Toshiba's Corporate Senior Vice President Shozo Saito smiles as he waits for his presentation at the Reuters Global Technology, Media and Telecoms Summit in Tokyo May 22, 2008.

Credit: Reuters/Kiyoshi Ota

TOKYO (Reuters) - Japan's Toshiba Corp (6502.T), fresh off a losing format battle for high-definition DVDs, is now training its sights on the NAND memory chip sector, targeting the No. 1 spot in the potentially lucrative market for new laptops which will increasingly use storage based on flash memory.

The timing is opportune, since the current leader in NAND and the world's biggest maker of memory chips, Samsung Electronics Co (005930.KS), is busy pouring resources into wiping out the opposition in the dynamic random access memory (DRAM) market.

Toshiba, the world's No. 2 NAND maker, is also in a good position to make its bid for the top as third-ranked Hynix Semiconductor Inc (000660.KS) has cut output, and as an Intel-Micron (INTC.O) MU.N joint venture in Singapore has run into a six-month delay before it can start production.

Toshiba, with partner SanDisk Corp (SNDK.O), has long coveted the NAND crown, which would give it early access to, and even some control over, new product launches by major NAND buyers.

Solid state drives (SSDs), which use NAND, are seen as the next replacement to hard drives. SSDs consume less power, generate less heat, boot up faster, and have longer battery life than existing hard drives, and have been used in a new crop of sleek laptops, such as Apple Inc's (AAPL.O) MacBook Air and Lenovo's (0992.HK) X300.

"It's not a matter of waiting for demand for NAND to double. We will make demand double by offering SSDs at a more attractive price than Samsung or Hynix," Toshiba Corporate Senior Vice President Shozo Saito told the Reuters Global Technology, Media and Telecoms Summit.

Toshiba plans to build two NAND flash memory factories in 2010, aiming to catapult production capacity to a potential 810,000 wafers a month, more than triple current capacity.

But analysts warn this strategy might cause Samsung to aggressively defend its No. 1 position, which may result in a supply glut for the rest of the year.

RAMP UP

Samsung, which does not unveil its NAND capacity, has said it will be "careful" with the NAND market in the absence of a clear killer applications.

Instead, the South Korean company is concentrating its efforts on cementing its leadership in the DRAM market by churning out chips at a much higher rate than the industry average and starving out cash-poor rivals.

For Toshiba, a victory in SSDs would make its defeat to Sony Corp's (6758.T) Blu-ray camp for home videos easier to swallow. Once people start watching movies via downloads, storing them in flash chips, it would by-pass the need for a DVD player altogether, Toshiba President Atsutoshi Nishida has argued.

"Solid state drives will replace optical discs as storage for data, movies, and music. It's just a matter of time," Saito said.

Flash memory would also make PCs faster and lighter while saving power, but they currently cost ten times more than conventional hard drives. NAND's use is still mainly limited to flash-storage cards, MP3 players and USB (universal serial bus) flash drives.

"The important thing is to be prepared to ramp up quickly. The timing in which we actually install the equipment to begin production will depend on market conditions," Saito said. "We're not crazy, you know."

Research firm iSuppli estimates average prices of NAND chips fell by 36 percent in January-March. It expects another 13 percent decline in April-June, with price falls possibly slowing in the summer.

But any war of attrition between Toshiba and Samsung could derail that recovery.

Major NAND buyers Apple and SanDisk forecast growth to slow this year, even as capital spending on NAND production is expected to grow by more than 20 percent this year.

Apple's iPod music player sales have slowed, although some hope a new version of the iPhone, seen launching in June, could lift the market.

According to iSuppli, Samsung had 42.1 percent of the global NAND market in 2007, while Toshiba and Hynix had 27.9 percent and 17.1 percent, respectively.

Toshiba's share might be able to rise to a percentage in the high 30s, taking market share from Hynix, but Samsung would probably look to keep least 40 percent of the market, said Kim Young-June, an analyst at Kyobo Securities in Seoul.

"If (Samsung) slows down on investment, Toshiba will catch up. And it is a market with such a growth potential, Samsung can't afford to miss the boat."

(For summit blog: summitnotebook.reuters.com/)

(Editing by Louise Heavens, Lincoln Feast and Marie-France Han)

Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.