New BRIBEline Report Provides First In-Depth Look at Demand-Side Bribery in India
* Reuters is not responsible for the content in this press release.
New BRIBEline Report Provides First In-Depth Look at Demand-Side Bribery in India NEW DELHI, India, Jan. 12 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- TRACE International, Inc. today announced results from its first 16 months of collecting and analyzing reports of bribery demands in India. These reports represent the first look at the demand-side of bribery in India as reported directly by those being solicited for bribes. "The vast majority of the reports in India are of extortionate demands for the purpose of avoiding some harm or disadvantage," said TRACE President Alexandra Wrage. "It is interesting to note that 30% of these reports describe bribes demanded by the police. BRIBEline can uncover key trends for international companies to consider when crafting their risk mitigation tools so companies can address the real issues that their employees face on the ground in India." Ninety-six anonymous reports about bribery demands in India were filed between July 1, 2007 and October 30, 2008 on TRACE's Business Registry for International Bribery and Extortion (BRIBEline), a secure, multilingual, online tool for reporting bribe demands worldwide. Of the bribe demands reported, 91% were requested by a government official, including 33% from national-level government officials, 30% from the police, 16% from state/provincial officials and employees, 10% from city officials, and 2% from ruling party representatives. Of the total reported bribe demands at the national level, 13% were from the national office of Customs and 9% each were from the national offices of Taxation and Water. Seventy-seven percent of the reports described extortionate demands - payments for avoiding a harm or disadvantage rather than for gaining an advantage. Of those, more than half (51%) were for the timely delivery of services to which the individual was already entitled, such as clearing customs or having a telephone line installed. Only 12% of the reported bribe demands were for gaining an advantage, including exercising influence with or over another government official, receiving inappropriate favorable treatment, or winning new business. The remaining 11% of reporters characterized the bribe demand as falling in some other, unspecified category of purpose. Nearly half of the individuals who reported a demand for a bribe said they had been asked for bribes more than once. Of those, 9% reported that they had been solicited more than 100 times. Sixty percent of those who reported multiple demands reported that they had been solicited five times or fewer. Ninety-two percent of all reported bribe demands were for cash or a cash equivalent. The next most common demand reported, at 5%, was a "gift," including requests for company products, jewelry and similar items. Much less commonly reported, at approximately 1% each, were requests for hospitality or entertainment; travel for other than business purposes; and other assistance, such as help with a visa, medical care or scholarships. The values of the reported bribe demands ranged from less than US$20 (29%) to more than US$500,000 (approximately 1%). Most of the reported bribe demands were for relatively small amounts of money. "Although most reports of bribe demands in India are for low dollar amounts, a significant number of individuals reported being asked for a bribe more than 100 times. Those repeated demands for relatively small amounts of cash can be difficult for companies to track and they can add up over time to significant totals. Our findings in the India BRIBEline Report reinforce the importance of having strong internal controls to encourage commercial transparency at all levels," said Wrage. Wrage also noted, "One of the most useful aspects of BRIBEline reports is the detail they provide about specific, local trends. This data should be useful to multinational companies as they develop tailored compliance training programs for each country in which they do business. In India, for example, it would be prudent to prepare employees to respond to a high number of low level cash demands, especially from the police and customs officials. In China, by comparison, we saw that companies need to prepare their employees to respond to demands for large value items, including hospitality and gifts in excess of US$10,000." A complete description of BRIBEline's methodology, as well as the full India and China reports, are available online at www.TRACEinternational.org/news/BRIBElineData.asp. TRACE is a non-profit membership association that pools resources to provide practical and cost-effective anti-bribery compliance solutions for multinational companies and their commercial intermediaries (sales agents and representatives, consultants, distributors, suppliers, etc.). TRACE provides several core services and products, including: due diligence reports on commercial intermediaries; model compliance policies; an online Resource Center with foreign local law summaries, including guidelines on gifts and hospitality; in-person and online anti-bribery training; and research on corporate best practices. For more information, please visit www.TRACEinternational.org. SOURCE TRACE International, Inc. Maureen Dempsey, +1-212-300-1806, mdempsey@apcoworldwide.com, for TRACE International, Inc.
Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.



Follow Reuters