Glad`s Response to Automotive Repair Suit

* Reuters is not responsible for the content in this press release.

Tue Jun 30, 2009 8:33pm EDT

DANVILLE, Calif.--(Business Wire)--
Midas franchisee Mike Glad will aggressively defend against the civil complaint
filed in Alameda County. According to Bill Gagen, an attorney for the Glad
organization: "This lawsuit rehashes the same causes of action that have been
the subject of administrative proceedings in Sacramento for the last year. The
prosecutors` action stems from the same investigation by the Bureau of
Automotive Repair. Midas franchisee Mike Glad and his 22 shops in northern
California are victims of an inconsistent and destructive enforcement process
undertaken by the BAR to take advantage of hard working mechanics in repair
shops." 

In 1989 Mr. Glad and his businesses were parties to an agreement with the Bureau
of Automotive Repair which led to the creation of a strong working relationship
between the BAR and his shops. Mr. Glad became one of the organizing members of
the California Midas Dealers Association which was established to work
cooperatively and constructively with the BAR. Not once in 20 years did the BAR
bring to the attention of Mr. Glad any violation of the terms of the 1989
settlement. In the late 1990`s the BAR dismantled the centralized program for
handling consumer complaints. The BAR eliminated the Notice of Violation process
which alerted auto repair businesses to violations discovered. As time went on,
Gagen commented, "The BAR abandoned its statutory mandate to protect the
consumers of California and substituted it with clandestine enforcement
mechanisms." 

According to Gagen, "Mr. Glad now knows that from March of 2005, and thereafter
for nearly three years, the BAR resorted to a "gotcha" enforcement technique
designed to deceive auto mechanics. This pattern of deception included BAR
investigators lying to mechanics about symptoms consistent with excessive brake
wear. The BAR spent thousands of dollars to cosmetically age rotors and grind
down brake pads to 1/32 of an inch, a dangerously inadequate level. There is no
evidence that any consumer would cosmetically alter his brake rotor, grind down
his brake pad, and then lie to a mechanic about the response of the car to the
application of brake pressure. The BAR allowed this conduct to continue unabated
for over 2 1/2 years before filing the Accusation last year." 

While the Bureau claims that unnecessary repairs were made on 28 cars, in fact,
24 of those cars were altered undercover vehicles. 

"The Midas braking system advertising was not misleading," said Gagen. "In the
ad that is a subject of the complaint was transmitted to the BAR in October,
2004, at which time it was deemed to comply with price advertisement
regulations. Five months later, the BAR launched its deceptive undercover
operation." Gagen posed the question, "Why, if the BAR felt that a Glad mechanic
in 2005 was violating consumer protection laws, did the regulatory agency take
absolutely no action for over 2 1/2 years to prevent similar conduct?" 

The 22 Glad shops serve a total of 100,000 customers yearly, averaging fewer
than two customer complaints per store. Mr. Glad and his representatives will
vigorously fight to maintain the reputation of the organization and its 130
loyal employees. 

In the investigation leading to this case, Gagen claims, "The BAR has proven
itself to be driven by deception and game-playing, not public protection. In the
zeal to ensnare otherwise honest and conscientious business people, the BAR has
completely undercut its mission of consumer protection. Over the 2 1/2 year
investigation of Mike Glad`s Midas stores, BAR agents tricked employees,
artificially modifying decoy cars that were expertly engineered to fool the most
experienced mechanic. Simply stated, this was a setup." 





Law Offices of Gagen McCoy
William E. Gagen, Jr., 925-837-0585 



Copyright Business Wire 2009

Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.