Bet Tzedek and O`Melveny & Myers Prevail in Landmark Civil Human Trafficking Trial

Tue Nov 3, 2009 11:35am EST

* Reuters is not responsible for the content in this press release.

Jury Returns Verdict Exceeding $750,000 to Enslaved Domestic Worker; First Civil
Case Prosecuted Under California Trafficking Victims Protection Act
LOS ANGELES--(Business Wire)--
A jury in Los Angeles Superior Court awarded $768,000, including $500,000 in
punitive damages, to a domestic worker who brought suit against her former
employers under California`s civil human trafficking statute, it was announced
today by poverty law firm Bet Tzedek Legal Services, which prosecuted the case
alongside pro bono counsel from O`Melveny & Myers LLP. The verdict is believed
to be the first case adjudicated under Civil Code 52.5, the California
Trafficking Victims Protection Act. 

In early 2006, an Indonesian businessman brought plaintiff Suminarti Sayuti
Yusuf to Los Angeles, where his son and daughter-in-law, defendants Andrew Tjia
and his wife, Sycamore Choi, put Yusuf to work. According to Yusuf and the
evidence presented at trial, Tjia and Choi confiscated Yusuf`s passport,
withheld all pay, required her to work 16-hour days, seven days a week, and
never permitted her to leave the house to pray at a mosque or visit the
Indonesian consulate. They subjected Yusuf to verbal abuse, psychological
coercion and instructed Yusuf to lie and say she was a family member if law
enforcement ever visited the Tjia residence. 

Ultimately, Yusuf was able to contact an acquaintance in another state of her
circumstances who, in turn, notified authorities. The authorities prosecuted the
Tjias criminally. Tjia and Choi subsequently pleaded guilty to criminal human
trafficking and false imprisonment charges setting the way for the civil action
in which Yusuf prevailed at trial on all nine causes of action in the complaint,
including the anti-trafficking statute. (The jury was not informed of these
convictions at the civil trial.) 

"This jury`s decision resoundingly shows that the law worked and justice was
delivered for the most poor, vulnerable and voiceless client," said Kevin Kish,
director of Bet Tzedek`s Employment Rights Project, who tried the case. "The
award sends the clearest possible message that Ms. Yusuf was, pure and simple,
the victim of slavery, and human trafficking in any form is unacceptable and
will not be tolerated." 

O`Melveny Partner Paul McNamara, trial co-counsel, stated: "The verdict sets a
new standard for enforcement of this law and establishes precedent under a
never-before litigated measure. It is a clear indication that similar action
will not be tolerated and that firms such as O`Melveny & Myers will bring their
full resources to bear to attain justice for the downtrodden. On behalf of both
the firm-which again finds itself at the forefront of the law-and my colleagues,
who worked tirelessly on this case, we are enormously proud of the outcome and
that Bet Tzedek sought our involvement in this important matter." 

"This outcome is enormously gratifying and reflects a seamless collaboration
between Bet Tzedek and the unflagging commitment and support brought to bear by
O`Melveny," said Mitchell A. Kamin, Bet Tzedek president and CEO. "We cannot
adequately express our appreciation to the O`Melveny team of Paul McNamara, as
well as his colleagues Bob Nicksin, Timothy Caballero, Jennifer Cheng and
Angelina Stone. Kevin Kish distinguished himself again through his trial
advocacy and by upholding the very best ideals of Bet Tzedek." 

Jurors rejected out-of-hand the defense`s claims that Yusuf came to the U.S.
voluntarily, was a guest in the Tjia residence and fabricated the enslavement
story in order to obtain a T-Visa (reserved by the federal government for
victims of trafficking and among the hardest immigration categories to qualify).
Following her emancipation from the household by law enforcement, Yusuf was
granted a T-Visa with the assistance of the Coalition to Abolish Slavery and
Trafficking (CAST), which then referred the matter to Bet Tzedek for the civil

About O`Melveny & Myers LLP

With approximately 1,000 lawyers in 14 offices worldwide, O`Melveny & Myers LLP
helps industry leaders across a broad array of sectors manage the complex
challenges of succeeding in the global economy. We are a values-driven law firm,
guided by the principles of excellence, leadership, and citizenship. Our
commitment to these values is reflected in our dedication to improving access to
justice through pro bono work and championing initiatives that increase the
diversity of the legal profession. For more information, please visit 

About Bet Tzedek

Founded in 1974, Bet Tzedek`s mission is to ensure "equal justice for all." One
of the nation`s premier public interest law firms, Bet Tzedek, "The House of
Justice" in Hebrew, provides free legal services in matters involving consumer
rights, elder law, housing, public benefits and workers` rights to low-income,
disabled and elderly people of all racial and religious backgrounds. Each year,
Bet Tzedek and its staff of approximately 60 serve nearly 12,000 clients in the
Los Angeles area, augmented by 600 attorneys and paralegals who donate about
40,000 hours in time. Bet Tzedek is renowned as one of a handful of agencies in
the world to offer free legal help to Holocaust survivors on a wide range of
issues, including reparations, pensions, and benefits offered by Germany and
other European countries.

Bet Tzedek Legal Services
Mitch Kamin, 323-549-5812
O`Melveny & Myers LLP
Sonja Steptoe, 213-430-6384
FoleyFreisleben LLC
Jerry Freisleben, 818-788-0010 

Copyright Business Wire 2009