UPDATE 3-Vivendi stake sale in NBCU hinges on price, timing
* GE, Vivendi under $1 bln apart on NBCU stake valuation
* Vivendi values NBC stake at $6.1 bln
* Disagreement holds up Comcast-GE NBCU joint venture (Recasts, adds financial details, adds LONDON to dateline pvs NEW YORK/PARIS)
By Jui Chakravorty and Quentin Webb
NEW YORK/LONDON, Nov 20 (Reuters) - General Electric Co (GE.N) and Vivendi SA (VIV.PA) disagree on a valuation for the French company's 20 percent stake in NBC Universal, and a further drag on the deal is that Vivendi wants the payment upfront, while GE prefers to wait until its deal with Comcast Corp closes, sources familiar with the matter told Reuters.
GE and Vivendi are less than $1 billion apart in valuing Vivendi's stake, the sources said. Vivendi values its stake at $6.1 billion, one of the sources said.
GE, which owns the remaining 80 percent stake in NBC
Universal, has been in talks with Comcast (CMCSA.O) to sell it
a 51 percent stake in a proposed joint venture. Comcast would
contribute its cable networks and $4 billion to $6 billion in
cash to the venture.
The two parties have agreed to value NBC Universal at about $30 billion, sources previously told Reuters.
But for that GE-Comcast deal to happen, GE has to buy out Vivendi's stake first. The two have been in talks as Vivendi has been trying to negotiate the best deal for itself.
The talks have been going slow, sources said, dampening hopes of GE and Comcast announcing a deal before Thanksgiving.
NBC declined to comment while Vivendi did not return calls seeking comment.
PUT OPTION
Every year between November and December, Vivendi has to decide whether to exercise its "put" option to sell its stake. It could also demand an initial public offering for NBC Universal instead, putting it in a strong bargaining position if GE and Comcast are in a hurry to get the deal done.
This year, Vivendi is eager to dispose of its stake, which it acquired as part of a 2004 deal to create NBC Universal, sources have said.
Vivendi, which owns the world's biggest recorded music company, Universal Music Group, as well as telecoms assets, acquired Brazilian telecoms group GVT GVTT3.SA in a $4.8 billion deal last week.
"Following the GVT deal, we believe Vivendi will ultimately sell its stake in NBCU, but not at any price ... Similarly, GE needs Vivendi's stake for Comcast for the tie up to go through and we see a compromise as likely," UBS wrote in a note.
Although Vivendi has said it will tap available credit lines of 6 billion euros ($8.9 billion) for the acquisition and does not need to sell the NBCU stake, it has also said it hopes to grow in the telecoms sector in emerging markets. It could use the cash for further acquisitions.
"There seems a good deal of posturing on all sides," Citi analysts wrote in a note on Friday, adding they valued Vivendi's stake at $5.9 billion.
"Vivendi's liquidity rights (right to force an IPO at some point) may well be unappealing to Comcast as a potential majority owner of NBCU over time. As such, we think that Vivendi's leverage in negotiations will be reasonably strong," the analysts wrote.
NEW COMPANY
GE and Comcast have ironed out all their issues and are now waiting for GE and Vivendi to reach a resolution, sources said. Neither side is expected to walk away, the sources said, but the hold-up makes the timing of a deal unclear.
The proposed joint venture is expected to be able generate cash to pay down $9 billion in debt that would be added to its books as part of the deal. It would use that debt to buy the rest of the company from GE.
GE has negotiated a redemption option that would give it the right to redeem all or part of its stake in the new company in exchange for cash at the three-and-a-half year mark and at a seven-year mark, sources have said.
The terms of the deal allow Comcast's cash payment to be determined partly by NBC Universal's financial performance. If the unit's performance worsens between the signing of the deal and the closing, Comcast could end up paying less, sources previously told Reuters. (Additional reporting by Anupreeta Das in New York, Dominique Vidalon in Paris and Georgina Prodhan in London, Editing by Sitaraman Shankar and Matthew Lewis)
- Tweet this
- Link this
- Share this
- Digg this
- Reprints
Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.



Follow Reuters