U.S. Army Captain Michael Kelvington, commander of the Battle company, 1-508 Parachute Infantry battalion, 4th Brigade Combat Team, 82nd Airborne Division, bows next to remains of Gulam Dostager, a member of Afghan Local Police who was killed in the blast of an Improvised Explosive Device (IED) during the joint Tor Janda (Black Flag in Pashtu) operation, in Zahri district of Kandahar province, southern Afghanistan May 25, 2012.  REUTERS/Shamil Zhumatov  (AFGHANISTAN - Tags: MILITARY CIVIL UNREST CONFLICT TPX IMAGES OF THE DAY)

Reuters Photojournalism

Our day's top images, in-depth photo essays and offbeat slices of life. See the best of Reuters photography.  See more | Photo caption 

Members of the U.S. Navy Blue Angels fly over the World Trade Center in lower Manhattan as part of the 25th annual Fleet Week celebration in New York, May 23, 2012.  REUTERS/Eduardo Munoz (UNITED STATES - Tags: MILITARY ANNIVERSARY TPX IMAGES OF THE DAY)

Fleet Week

The U.S. Navy takes Manhattan for a week.  Slideshow 

Photo

The SpaceX mission

A privately owned unmanned rocket blasts off on a mission to be the first commercial flight to the International Space Station.  Slideshow 

FACTBOX: Nokia's three major legal fights

Fri Dec 11, 2009 11:45am EST

(Reuters) - Apple Inc countersued Nokia Oyj on Friday in a response to the Finnish group's legal attack on the iPhone maker in October.

Since Motorola Inc launched a similar attack on Nokia in 1989, the Finnish firm has built one of the mobile industry's widest patent portfolios. Only Ericsson and Qualcomm Inc have comparable portfolios.

The following are key facts about three major legal battles in Nokia's history:

MOTOROLA VS NOKIA

In the 1980s Nokia rose to became one of the world's top cellphone manufacturers, surprising established players.

Industry reaction: one April morning in 1989 a large box with more than 16 kilograms of documents, charging the firm with infringing nine Motorola patents, landed in the lobby of Nokia's Salo plant in southern Finland.

"In April 1989 Motorola declared a war on Nokia, and I had to receive the declaration," Anne-Liisa Palmu-Joronen, a lawyer at Nokia's phone unit at the time, wrote in her memoirs.

Motorola took Nokia to the International Trade Commission and a court in Chicago and Nokia agreed in November to pay more than $10 million to settle the case.

Palmu-Joronen says Nokia learned from the 1989 Motorola case the role of immaterial rights in the battle for market share.

"The immaterial and invisible part of the battle on the global market would in the future be a significant part of the competitiveness for the company like Nokia," she writes.

QUALCOMM VS NOKIA

In mid-2008 Nokia and Qualcomm settled a 3-year, three-continent legal battle over patent licenses and royalties for 15 years. The battle alone cost the companies tens of millions of dollars in legal fees and worried investors on both sides of the Atlantic.

In April 1992, the two firms had signed a licensing agreement, giving Nokia access to Qualcomm's CDMA patents. Over 15 years, Nokia says it paid $1 billion for Qualcomm's "early patents," giving it a fully-paid, royalty-free license to those. But when the smoke cleared, Nokia still agreed to a hefty one-time payment of 1.7 billion euros, a deal that also opened the door for Nokia to use Qualcomm chips in its phones.

NOKIA VS APPLE

A legal battle between Apple and Nokia over patent infringement is likely to last for more than a year, said Bill Merritt, the head of mobile licensing firm InterDigital.

Nokia filed suit in the United States in October, saying Apple had infringed 10 patents in technologies including wireless data transfer, a key factor in the success of iPhone. The suit accused Apple of trying to hitch a "free ride" on Nokia's technology investment.

Apple, which entered the industry in mid-2007, overtook Nokia last quarter as the cellphone maker generating the highest total operating profit.

Apple filed a countersuit on December 11 claiming that Nokia is infringing 13 Apple patents.

"Other companies must compete with us by inventing their own technologies, not just by stealing ours," Bruce Sewell, Apple's General Counsel, said in a statement.

(Compiling by Tarmo Virki; editing by Simon Jessop)

Related Quotes and News

Company
Price
Related News
Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.