Obama dominates the room at healthcare summit

WASHINGTON Thu Feb 25, 2010 6:32pm EST

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - It was a unique insight into President Barack Obama's management style.

Obama dominated the debate during Thursday's nearly seven hour cross-party summit on healthcare, always in command not only of the room but also of the most intricate policy details, as he personally rebutted every point he disagreed with.

His tone was at times professorial, occasionally combative and at one point even dismissive of his 2008 rival for the presidency, Republican Senator John McCain.

"Let me just make this point, John, because we're not campaigning anymore," he told McCain. "The election's over."

"Well, I'm reminded of that every day," McCain replied.

It remains to be seen if the American public was more convinced by Obama's detailed exposition of policy or the Republicans' more visceral argument against an expansion of Washington's powers.

What is certain is that there was little progress toward

generating a greater bipartisan consensus around a reform of the mammoth healthcare industry.

"There are some fundamental differences between us that we cannot paper over," Jon Kyl, the No. 2 Senate Republican, told Obama. "We do not agree about the fundamental question of who should be in charge."

Perhaps it was no surprise that there was little progress on Thursday. Democrats said there had already been more than 100 bipartisan meetings on healthcare since Obama came to power a year ago, yet the two sides seem to have drifted further apart than ever.

Arguably the event was more about trying to win popular support for Obama's healthcare plan -- and shoring up his own Democratic base -- than it was about bridging the ever widening gulf between America's two main parties over healthcare.

Convening nearly 40 lawmakers around a cramped square table in the Blair House guest quarters across from the White House, Obama was at his most schoolmasterly as he warned participants against turning the event into "political theater" or an exercise in pointscoring.

He was almost scornful of Republican Congressman Eric Cantor for sitting behind a copy of the 2,700-page Democratic legislation the Republicans say is overly complex and beholden to special interests.

"We don't care for this bill," Cantor said.

Obama accused him of using the pile of papers as "a prop".

"The truth of the matter," he added, "is that healthcare is very complicated."

Nevertheless, Obama's fellow Democrats were as guilty of playing to the gallery, as they recounted tales of constituents denied healthcare coverage for pre-existing medical conditions or struggling to cope with rising premium costs.

Congresswoman Louise Slaughter told of one constituent who had to wear the false teeth of her dead sister because she couldn't afford dental care.

And fellow Democrat George Miller offered himself as an example of someone who could be denied coverage for pre-existing health conditions, with a list of ailments including two artificial hips, arthritis and a kidney stone.

Obama himself tried to tug at America's heartstrings with tales of family scares, when his daughter Malia had to be rushed to the emergency room with asthma and the time his other daughter Sasha came down with meningitis as a baby.

"In each of those instances I remember thinking while sitting in the emergency room what would have happened if I didn't have reliable health care," the president said.

The marathon event was inspired by a showdown Obama had with Republican members of the House of Representatives last month at their annual retreat in Baltimore.

The White House felt Obama won the debate in Baltimore, successfully portraying himself as above the partisan fray.

While it had its moments of drama, the Blair House summit had less back-and-forth than Baltimore, with participants resorting to the kind of lengthy statements typical of Capitol Hill hearings.

Obama took notes occasionally, at times resting his head on his hand. He smiled rarely. His most common expression was one of serious contemplation and thoughtful consideration of the opposing arguments.

Only a handful of aides attended the event, in a room barely big enough for those crowded around the table in wooden chairs.

Beneath a crystal chandelier, and between marbled walls, the room echoed and magnified the sounds of people shuffling paper or getting up from their seats for a break.

Several times, Obama reminded them of the need to be more disciplined about keeping their remarks shorter, although he acknowledged he had gone over his allotted time too.

Afterwards, Kyl complained Obama had talked too much.

"I just don't think the president was listening."

(Writing by Caren Bohan and Simon Denyer; editing by Anthony Boadle)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (15)
cjjn wrote:
That was the whole point of Obama’s healthcare summit. To manipulate people again silly. With little to no real work and no sweat or blood for this country to show during his presidency it’s time for an all talk forum.

Remember during the economic collapse in 2008, John McCain wanted to postpone an upcoming presidential debate so he and Obama, two sitting U.S. senators, could go back to Washington to do their jobs as senators and “bring” people together and stop ruling democrats Pelosi, Franks and Reid from putting whatever they wanted into the rescue bill they were creating?

Obama refused to go back to Washington to do his job and instead held up a forum where he could present all talk to manipulate people into giving him what he wanted.

Obama wouldn’t go back and do his job as a U.S. senator, holding one crucial vote of only 99 votes when the economy collapsed during that time because he knew his little to no work and lack of accomplishments as a senator wouldn’t get him what he wanted (elected).

So here we go again. Same behavior. Same Pattern. He can’t get your support based on the little to no work that he has actually performed as president and the absolutely NO real sweat or blood that he has shed for this country, so now it’s time for an all talk manipulation forum.

At the forum, McCain confronted Obama about Obama’s lies to the American people when he said he would originally make the healthcare debate bi-partisan and open the process to C-span. Which never happened as it was vvery partisan, all democrat, no republican or idenependent, fully corrupt and fraught with bribes and kickbacks using taxpayer money. Obama implied those were talking points. McCain should have told Obama, “NO, Those are the words of the American people.” But at least John McCain had the courage to bring the concerns and disgust of the American people into that meeting so people who are disgusted with Obamna’s lies can have a voice and be heard.

Obama went on to say the election is over. Who doesn’t know that? What does that mean? It means it’s time for Obama to start twisting people’s attention spans away from his lies and failures. He wants you to leave those at the door. Don’t dare bring those to him. The promises of C-span cameras, transparency, bi-partisan negotations promises that he made and then never followed through with was a campaign tactic. Ha! The campaign is over so you shouldn’t expect what he said on the campaign trail. No kidding, I can’t even count the lies from Obama on my two hands.

Feb 25, 2010 7:20pm EST  --  Report as abuse
AlexMiddle wrote:
Sadly the American people lose out. Nothing gets done. Republicans want President Obama to fail. Republicans get back into power. Democrats block everything causing the republican president to fail, and the cycle continues. There was a solution to the Health Care overall. Republicans are to be blamed for casting a public option as takeover of the health care industry. Democrats to blame for being dismissive of sensible Republican input. People are without heath care. At the end of the day it was all about politics and power, and not about the American people. The media says the bill is rejected by the people, but they themselves (the media) have not read it (Hannity for e.g.)

Feb 25, 2010 9:25pm EST  --  Report as abuse
Aurora322 wrote:
Wow, cjjn could not be more wrong.

They had the economic summit. Both McCain and Obama attended. The difference? After his stunt, McCain had nothing to say. My source? Republican appointee Ben Bernanke.

I guess if you don’t like the facts, you can just make up new ones.

Feb 25, 2010 9:59pm EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.