SCENARIOS - Greece keeps market guessing on bond sale
By Alex Chambers
LONDON, Feb 26 (Reuters) - A three-way stand-off prevails between Greece, the European Union and the debt market over Greece's plan to issue a 10-year syndicated bond.
Athens, which has said its funding needs are met until mid-March, has held off on offering the bond, apparently hoping market jitters will ease, letting it borrow at lower yields. It has urged the EU to help calm markets by making a stronger, more concrete statement of support for Greece. [ID:nLDE61K05L]
But the EU wants to keep pressure on Greece to reform its finances, and is keen to avoid setting a precedent by taking responsibility for debts of weak southern states. At the same time, it wants to avoid a market meltdown that could undermine market confidence in the entire euro zone. [ID:nLDE61O20P]
In the absence of a bond sale, the market is worrying about Greece's ability to fund itself; the 10-year Greek bond spread to German Bunds rose as high as 370 basis points this week, near January's peak of 405 bps. But while a chance of EU aid exists, the market is reluctant to drive Greek yields much higher.
Based on conversations with government officials, bankers, traders and analysts, here are four scenarios for how the situation may develop in the next two weeks, with implications for financial markets:
GREECE ISSUES BOND IN CURRENT MARKET CONDITIONS
SCENARIO: Bankers and analysts estimate that in current market conditions, Greece would be able to sell the bond but at a substantial new-issue premium; pricing might come in somewhere between 375 and 400 basis points over Bunds. The market is expecting an issue of 3 to 8 billion euros.
PROBABILITY: Significant -- bankers say much of the recent widening of Greek bond spreads is due to the uncertainty over its access to liquidity. Paying in the region of 7 percent for 10-year money would be very expensive for Greece, but could benefit further fund-raising exercises in coming months.
However, the 10-year bond plan was announced in late January by the then-director general of the Public Debt Management Agency, Spyros Papanicolaou, who was appointed by the previous conservative government; he was replaced last week by prominent commercial banker Petros Christodoulou, who may be less willing to accept market terms he considers exorbitant. [ID:nLDE61H2JZ]
MARKET IMPLICATIONS: Greek bonds GR10YT=RR and banking stocks, as well as the euro EUR=, could rise in relief. But the rally would probably be brief since more funding challenges would loom; 8.2 billion euros of five-year government bonds mature on April 20, 1.92 billion euros of 13-week Treasury bills on April 23, and 8.5 billion euros of 10-year bonds on May 19. Also, investors will remember the poor performance of the secondary market after a Greek five-year bond sale in January. [ID:nLDE61F1VJ]
GREECE ISSUES BOND AFTER STRONGER EU PLEDGE OF SUPPORT
SCENARIO: EU governments make a more concrete pledge of support for Greece, indicating specific steps they might take to prevent any default, though a lack of political consensus means they remain unlikely to announce any final decision. A wide range of steps could be considered, from having state-owned financial institutions buy Greek debt to accelerating disbursement of routine economic aid to Greece, giving Greece a debt guarantee, or establishing a bailout fund. [ID:nLDE6190HW]
PROBABILITY: This may be the single most likely outcome. It
would likely be accompanied by a Greek pledge of fresh austerity
measures, which might be made to EU Monetary and Economic
Affairs Commissioner Olli Rehn when he visits Athens next week
to discuss this week's EU inspection of Greece. [ID:nLDE61O1ED]
Deutsche Bank (DBKGn.DE) CEO Josef Ackermann met Greek Prime
Minister George Papandreou and Finance Minister George
Papaconstantinou in Athens on Friday; this could help facilitate
an understanding between Greece and the EU. [ID:nLDE61P1JN]
Papandreou will visit Berlin on March 5 at the invitation of Chancellor Angela Merkel; a deal between Greece and Germany on aid might conceivably be sealed then. [ID:nLDE61P15A] Merkel said this week the euro was for the first time in a difficult position because of the Greek crisis, which may have been an effort to prepare German public opinion, strongly against helping Greece, for aid. [ID:nLDE61N2QF]
MARKET IMPLICATIONS: The 10-year Greek bond spread could narrow back below 300 bps and Greek banking stocks would jump. However, the euro might not rally and Bunds could actually suffer moderately, as markets worried that a precedent had been set for rich EU states to fund reckless spending by poor ones.
GREECE RESORTS TO OTHER FUNDING OPTIONS
SCENARIO: Judging a 10-year bond issue in the next two weeks is too expensive, Greece chooses other options instead, perhaps a large issue of T-bills, which would have shorter maturities and thus be easier to sell. It might also arrange to sell some bonds through a private placement.
PROBABILITY: Low. From the points of view of both Greece and the market, this option would not resolve uncertainty but merely prolong it; since it is unlikely that all of Greece's funding needs this year can be met through T-bills and private placements, the market would continue wondering whether Greece could retain access to the long-term debt market.
MARKET IMPLICATIONS: The 10-year Greek bond spread could stay at high levels above 300 bps.
GREECE REFRAINS FROM SELLING DEBT
SCENARIO: Greece does not issue debt in the next two weeks.
PROBABILITY: Very low. It is not clear that Greece would actually start to run out of money at mid-March, but investors might interpret a decision not to issue debt by then as a sign that Greece was not confident it retained access to the market.
MARKET IMPLICATIONS: This could ignite a fresh round of speculation against Greek and euro zone assets in general, pushing the 10-year Greek bond spread to a fresh high above 405 bps. (Additional reporting by George Matlock; Editing by Andrew Torchia)
- Tweet this
- Link this
- Share this
- Digg this
- Reprints
Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.


Follow Reuters