TiVo wins ruling in EchoStar case, shares soar

SAN FRANCISCO Thu Mar 4, 2010 2:50pm EST

A screen shows Internet services available through an broadband-connected TiVo digital video recorder at the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas, Nevada January 5, 2006 file photo. REUTERS/Steve Marcus

A screen shows Internet services available through an broadband-connected TiVo digital video recorder at the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas, Nevada January 5, 2006 file photo.

Credit: Reuters/Steve Marcus

SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - A federal appeals court affirmed on Thursday a contempt finding against Dish Network Corp and EchoStar Corp in their long-running patent case against digital video recorder maker TiVo Inc, sending TiVo shares soaring 52 percent.

The U.S. District Court for Eastern Texas had previously imposed contempt sanctions against sister companies Dish and EchoStar for violating a court-ordered permanent injunction to stop making and selling DVRs.

TiVo had sued EchoStar back in 2004, and a jury found that its DVR technology infringed TiVo patents.

Analysts hailed the ruling as a huge win for TiVo, one that potentially opens up major new market and licensing opportunities.

TiVo's options volume heated up to 14 times the norm in afternoon trading. In all, about 191,000 calls and 75,000 puts had traded, according to option analytics firm Trade Alert.

Janney Montgomery Scott analyst Tony Wible recommended that clients "buy the stock aggressively up to $15."

"Today's overwhelming victory significantly improves TiVo's ability to win new business and the rates it can demand for its technology from future deals, while also improving penetration of its DVR advertising platform," he wrote in a research note.

He said the ruling should also help TiVo in its litigation against AT&T Inc, Verizon Communications Inc, and Microsoft Corp.

TiVo said it was pleased with the appeals court ruling, and said it paves the way for the company to receive $300 million in damages and contempt sanctions awarded to it for EchoStar's infringement through July 1, 2009.

TiVo said it plans to seek further damages and contempt sanctions for infringement after July 1.


Bernstein Research analyst Craig Moffett said the court decision could lead to the complete disablement of as many as 8 million Dish DVRs, and said the company now has little leverage in any settlement negotiations with TiVo.

"The ruling opens the door for TiVo to now negotiate a commercial settlement with Dish with the proverbial gun to the head," he wrote in a research note.

Moffett said he expects a much higher settlement on DVR licensing fees than the historical precedent of $1 to $2.25 per unit a month.

Dish was spun out of EchoStar in 2008. Dish and EchoStar claimed they had modified some components of the DVRs Dish continued to sell so that they would no longer infringe TiVo's patents.

In a statement, the companies expressed disappointment with the appeals court ruling, made by a three-judge panel, and said they will seek a review by the full court.

Dish and EchoStar said their DVR customers are not affected by the ruling, and said they will propose "new design-around" DVR technology to the district court for approval.

Shares of Alviso, California-based TiVo were up 52 percent at $15.52 in afternoon trading on the Nasdaq. Shares of Dish Network were down 4.4 percent at $20.75.

The case is TiVo Inc vs Echostar Corporation, Case No. 2009-1374, United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.

(Reporting by Gabriel Madway; additional reporting by Doris Frankel; Editing by Gerald E. McCormick and Robert MacMillan)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (3)
jscott418 wrote:
Well I am so glade I quit Dish Network when I did. What a waste of a company.
You would have thought they could get the hint that their not going to win this.

Mar 04, 2010 9:06pm EST  --  Report as abuse
mahalowahini wrote:
Too bad for Dish. I am a customer, but thanks to other technology I am using with my computer – technology that fully bypasses all digital protection and everything else they throw at broadcast signals, I am able to record, store, burn DVD’s and do whatever I wish with my Dish programming from all channels.

Maybe others should do the same and stick it right up TiVo’s proverbial you know what.

Mar 04, 2010 10:02pm EST  --  Report as abuse
williamd wrote:
Another elementary patent issued, and upheld. Go innovation. Seriously, how come it is so easy for companies to get these nowadays? I thought of this very idea when I was 12 so how novel is that? So now we have a company that has struggled for years, and has to enforce an elementary patent to insure profitability? Not one I will invest in. It is only a matter of time, before they tank.

Mar 05, 2010 10:53am EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.