Humane Society finds abuse by U.S. egg producers
*Investigation finds abuse of hens in egg industry
* Birds found injured, trapped, with broken bones
* Consumers, businesses moving toward cage-free eggs
WASHINGTON, April 7 (Reuters) - An undercover investigation by the Humane Society of the United States of major U.S. egg producers showed "rampant abuse" of hens, which the animal rights group said on Wednesday could prompt more consumers to embrace "cage-free" methods of production.
Footage collected in February and March by the group showed birds stuck in cages unable to reach food or water; dead hens, some of them rotting, amongst live birds; and manure pits that in at least one case had not been cleaned for two years.
"I don't think anyone can see this footage and feel good about this production system," Wayne Pacelle, president of the Humane Society of the United States, told reporters.
He urged Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack to take a "serious look at our footage." The U.S. Agriculture Department could not be reached for comment.
The Humane Society has played an increasingly active role in pressuring industry in several states to end livestock practices it considers cruel.
In 2008, the group won wide media play with video showing workers at a California plant forcing sick and injured cattle into a slaughterhouse. The plant later recalled 143 million pounds of meat, the largest U.S. meat recall ever.
The case was instrumental in moving USDA to implement a rule banning all cattle too sick or injured to walk from entering U.S. slaughterhouses.
In the egg production probe, the group sent an investigator to facilities in Iowa owned by Rose Acre Farms and Rembrandt Enterprises, the nation's second- and third-largest egg producers. There were about 10 million birds at the facilities that were investigated.
In most cases, the birds were housed in cages much smaller than a size of standard paper, which is common in the industry, according to the group. About 95 percent of egg-laying hens are housed in confined cages.
Rose Acre executive vice president Tony Wesner said in an interview his firm takes "animal welfare very seriously" and has all employees, including the Humane Society worker, sign an agreement requiring them to report signs of animal abuse.
"Unfortunately that didn't happen," he said, referring to the Humane Society employee. "We'll just have to take this and look at it some more and deal with it."
Efforts by the Humane Society and others to shift toward cage-free production are gaining traction with several states, including California, passing restrictions on egg production.
National restaurant chains, most recently Subway, have committed to using cage-free eggs and retail giant Wal-Mart (WMT.N) confirmed earlier this year eggs sold under its private label are cage-free.
The animal rights group debunked producers who have been reluctant to publicly embrace cage-free production methods.
"These same producers are producing cage-free eggs by the millions to account for the growing demand for these products," said Pacelle. "We're not talking about a pie-in-the-sky alternative."
To see the video, please go to: www.humanesociety.org/ (Editing by Marguerita Choy)
- Tweet this
- Link this
- Share this
- Digg this
- Reprints
If I sent 4 people following police officers around with undercover cameras for two months, I’ll bet I could get anyone who wasn’t familiar with cars to think from 2 mins of video that they were the biggest death traps one had ever seen. Can you imagine what awful gruesome footage you would likely get? Perhpaps we should ban all cars. Free range people!
I’ll bet you could find some pretty nasty cases of people abusing people too, doesn’t mean it’s happening in every house.
Certainly HSUS reported this abuse immediately to the farm owner right? Oh wait the farm owner didn’t know this video was coming out until yesterday. Hmm, hard to imagine why this “investigator” who cares so much for animals could stand by and just video and not help those animals.
Comparing car accidents or domestic violence to a food system that is inherently cruel to these animals (and often abusive as we see in the video) is comparing apples and oranges. We both know this.
Michigan, California and the EU have banned battery cages. Hundreds of national chains, local restaurants and universities have made the switch to cage-free eggs — and new investigations like this one show us that more governments and businesses to get on board.


Follow Reuters