U.S. keeps "boot on neck" of BP over spill

GALLIANO, Louisiana Mon May 24, 2010 7:32pm EDT

1 of 30. Oil reach the marshlands on the NE pass of the Mississippi Delta May 23, 2010.

Credit: Reuters/Daniel Beltra/Greenpeace/Handout

Related Video

GALLIANO, Louisiana (Reuters) - The government piled pressure on BP Plc on Monday to clean up a "massive environmental mess" in the Gulf of Mexico, and a top official said fines would definitely be imposed on the energy giant for the spreading oil spill.

The company insisted it was doing all it could to try to seal a blown-out oil well spewing hundreds of thousands of gallons (liters) of oil into the Gulf every day, a disaster that threatens to become the worst U.S. oil spill in history.

BP said it would make another attempt to plug the five-week-old leak on Wednesday, but gave it only a 60-70 percent chance of success.

BP's shares fell nearly 3 percent in London as investors waited to see whether BP's latest attempt would work. The company has now lost about 25 percent of its market value -- almost $50 billion -- since the spill began.

The head of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Lisa Jackson, said the government would "absolutely" levy fines on BP over the spill.

"There are certainly going to be opportunities for fines and penalties," she told reporters.

With heavy oil already washing into fragile marshlands and wildlife refuges in Louisiana and threatening the livelihoods of Gulf coast residents, the U.S. government is pushing BP to try to contain or seal the leak as soon as possible.

But, there appeared to be some signs of disagreement among U.S. officials about just how aggressively the administration should be pressing BP over what President Barack Obama has called an unprecedented environmental catastrophe for the United States.

The administration's response chief for the disaster, Coast Guard Admiral Thad Allen, seemed to take issue with Interior Secretary Ken Salazar's threat a day earlier to push BP "out of the way" if it did not do enough to stop the leak.

"To push BP out of the way would raise the question of 'replace them with what?'" Allen said at a White House news conference.

BP was "exhausting every technical means possible" to meet its legal responsibility to cap the well and contain the spreading oil, he said.


The company was on the defensive on Monday against the harsh criticism from the Obama administration.

"I don't know of anything else we could do, but if the government felt there were other things to do it is clearly within their power to do that," BP Chief Operations Officer Doug Suttles told reporters.

The oil spill is a political hot potato for the Obama administration ahead of a November election that is widely expected to erode Democrats' control of the U.S. Congress. Analysts warn that voters may punish Democrats regardless of who is ultimately deemed responsible for the mess.

The latest CNN/Opinion Research Corporation poll found that 51 percent of Americans were unhappy with Obama's handling of the spill that was sparked by an explosion on April 20. The poll was based on telephone interviews with just over 1,000 people between May 21-23.

The White House has repeatedly said it is the British energy giant's responsibility to clean up the spill, but with public anger over BP's handling of the crisis intensifying, there have been calls for the Obama administration to take charge.

Louisiana Governor Bobby Jindal, who has been critical of the federal government's response, again called for more equipment, especially booms, to help stop the oil from making landfall. He said 70 miles of his state's coastline had been affected by the oil spill.

Louisiana's marshes are nurseries for shrimp, oysters, crabs and fish that make the state the top commercial seafood producer in the continental United States. Fishing is now banned in a large swath of the Gulf because of the spill.

During a tour of affected areas of the Gulf coast, Salazar assured residents the government would hold BP accountable for the economic hardship the spill had imposed on them.

"We will keep our boot on their neck until the job gets done," Salazar told reporters. "This is a BP mess, it is a horrible mess and it is a massive environmental mess."

Salazar said an ongoing investigation by U.S. authorities would hold the company accountable "both civilly and in whatever way is necessary," appearing to leave open the possibility of a criminal inquiry.

Asked about the possibility of a criminal investigation, BP CEO Tony Hayward said: "There will be all sorts of investigations following this. Rightly, and we will deal with them as they come."


A report on the disaster that will influence whether the Interior Department resumes issuing offshore drilling permits will be sent to Obama on Thursday, the White House said.

BP said the spill, triggered by an explosion that sank the Deepwater Horizon rig and killed 11 workers, had cost it $760 million so far. It also pledged up to $500 million on Monday toward studying the impact of the spill.

In its latest attempt to plug the leak, BP plans to inject heavy fluids and then cement into the seabed well to block oil flow in a so-called "top kill" operation on Wednesday.

BP executives have warned there is "no certainty" that the containment efforts will be successful, because they have never been attempted at the depths -- a mile down -- where the well is located.

The company has estimated that about 5,000 barrels (210,000 gallons/795,000 liters) have been leaking every day, although some scientists have given much higher numbers for the size of the leak -- up to 70,000 and even 100,000 barrels (4.2 million gallons/15.9 million liters) per day.

Suttles said if the "top kill" operation did not work, the company would attempt to put a "top hat" containment device over the larger leak to try to capture most of the oil and pipe it up to a tanker on the surface.

(Additional reporting by Sarah Young in London, Susan Heavey, Alister Bull, Steve Holland and Matt Spetalnick in Washington; Pascal Fletcher in Miami, Tom Bergin and Chris Baltimore in Houston; Writing by Pascal Fletcher and Ross Colvin; Editing by Sandra Maler)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (56)
fubp wrote:
Once PB’s grouse negligence is brought out, they would never be allowed to drill that reservoir. So they keep it leaking to justify drilling “ relief wells” because that reservoir will pay for the clean up. They are not about to loose $10,000,000,000 dollars over the life of the reservoir and pay the clean up cost, unless the Government makes them. BP keeps taking wks between actions but they started drilling two wells right away. Bp should have a second pipe lowered and ready on stand by, they should have tried the hole shot wks ago and the mud fill wks ago. If the mud does not work then they will put a new Blow out preventer over the old one (let me guess they don’t have the new one sitting on the bottom next to the well to try 10 minutes after the mud fails) If BP would come out $10,000,000,000 ahead by stopping the leak in 10 days they would have don it, but the clean up cost would have been about the same with no money from the “relief wells”. IT’S ALWAYS ABOUT THE MONEY. Believe me BP DID THE MATH

May 23, 2010 8:41pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
fubp wrote:
FAIL CLOSED VALVES must be mandated on Blow Out Preventers for all offshore rigs. In many cases valves are “fail close” for safety. Fail closed simply means that they are designed so that they need to be activated to remain open, or in the absence of a signal to an activator forcing them open they close. FAIL CLOSED VALVES are mandated in many situations for safety and fire prevention. FAIL CLOSED VALVES must be mandated on Blow Out Preventers for all offshore rigs. The industry will lobby agents FAIL CLOSED VALVES (there excuses will be lies) so we the people must be diligent in demanding it, without loop holes. Please copy this and post it every where you can.

May 23, 2010 8:49pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
policywhiz wrote:
The government, our President, were absent for far too long in doing anything about the oil spill. The accident, yes it was an accident, was and is a disaster that must not be repeated and one that BP must continue to address. I have seen and heard more concern from BP than I have our President. The government has a big role to play in clean up, control and coordination but all I have really heard from the President is blame and shame. The shame is in the way the President has not stepped up when it comes to protecting our borders in AZ or the water ways of the gulf. He is so busy siding with countries other than our own that he has forgotten, if he ever really knew, that his first job is not the forever campaigning but actually protecting our country. His job is not to plunge us into the mire of debt but to help companies and businesses to find ways to hire the unemployed…to create jobs not tax us to death. The water ways of the gulf employee thousands of people but I did not see the kind of action from our President that would indicate he really cared. His words ring hollow to the ears of many, we are tired of his words and we are tired of the hopeless policies he has placed on our country, our waterways and our borders.

May 23, 2010 8:49pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.