Arizona police officer challenges migrant law

TUCSON, Arizona Sat Jun 5, 2010 10:07am EDT

Demonstrators protest against Arizona's controversial immigration law before marching to the State Capitol in Phoenix May 29, 2010. REUTERS/Joshua Lott

Demonstrators protest against Arizona's controversial immigration law before marching to the State Capitol in Phoenix May 29, 2010.

Credit: Reuters/Joshua Lott

Related Topics

TUCSON, Arizona (Reuters) - Tucson police officer Martin Escobar has worked to build relationships of trust in the working class Mexican-American neighborhood he patrols.

But after Arizona passed a state law in April cracking down on illegal immigrants, some residents stopped coming forward to report crimes like robberies and domestic violence, for fear of being arrested.

"Ask any officer ... You would not believe how many incidents go unreported ... even though the law has not gone into effect," said Escobar, 45, who has worked as a police officer in the city for 15 years.

The Arizona law requires state and local police, after making lawful contact, to determine the immigration status of any person they suspect is in the country illegally.

Escobar is one of two police officers in the desert state who have filed lawsuits in federal court to challenge the law, which takes effect on July 29.

The state law is backed by a majority of Americans, and by the two largest police unions in Arizona, a main corridor for drug and human smuggling over the border from Mexico.

In Tucson's gritty south side that Escobar patrols, more than half of residents are Hispanic. They include third- and fourth-generation Mexican-Americans, as well as immigrants.

In his suit filed in April, Escobar argues there is no "race-neutral criteria" to identify illegal immigrants. He says officers would inevitably apply the law "based on how a person talks or what they look like."

Escobar also argues that Tucson police have no authority to carry out federal immigration duties, and says the law would seriously impede investigations in the community he patrols.

"These are the people that are calling in something going on," said Escobar, a naturalized U.S. citizen who moved to Tucson with his Mexican family at age 5.

"And these are the same citizens who are not going to want to call, because the fact is they are going to want to avoid all contact whatsoever," he added.

'SERVE AND PROTECT'

Escobar's doubts about the state law are shared by several U.S. police chiefs and President Barack Obama's administration, which may file its own suit over the law.

Last week, a group of eight police chiefs from cities including Los Angeles and Tucson told U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder the state law would sap limited law enforcement resources and could lead to an increase in crime.

"When you enact legislation that makes any subset of that community feel like they are being targeted specifically or have concerns about coming forward and talking to police, that damages our capability to obtain information to solve the crimes," Tucson Police Chief Roberto Villasenor.

No hearing has been set for Escobar's lawsuit. In the meantime, his relations with fellow officers have been strained.

"Some officers don't speak to me any longer (and) I lost several friends because of the stand I took," Escobar said.

But he said he has no regrets: "I've always tried to do the right thing. ... Our motto is to 'serve and protect,' and that includes everyone."

(Editing by Doina Chiacu)

FILED UNDER:
We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (131)
CCHUCK wrote:
You report that “the law is backed by a majority of Americans”, but have NO proof of that. If you have relied on polls, which may only be the opinion of a minority of Americans, this is no proof. Let us remember, Arizona’s law is aimed at Mexican-Americans only. This is racial profiling.

Jun 05, 2010 10:34am EDT  --  Report as abuse
finneganG wrote:
Escobar has a hidden agenda that, based on his last name, isn’t that secret.

Jun 05, 2010 10:37am EDT  --  Report as abuse
CommonDude wrote:
Dear Mr. Escobar,

Just do your job and ask everyone you stop “after making lawful contact” if they’re an illegal alien and the problem resolves itself.

Some of the officers don’t wanna talk to you, because you have an agenda and ARN’T doing your job sir. Your 15 min are so gonna be short lived.

Your getting beat, but you can’t call the cops because your an illegal alien. Just another reason you should probably just get your damn green card! lol don’t call the cops… that’s funny.

Jun 05, 2010 10:38am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

Pictures