Commentary

Demonstrators protest against Arizona's controversial immigration law outside the State Capitol in Phoenix May 29, 2010. Angered by Arizona's crackdown on illegal immigrants, several thousand protesters descended on a park in central Phoenix early on Saturday, urging Washington to block the new state law they call racist. REUTERS/Joshua Lott

George W. Obama and immigration fantasies

The tone of the immigration debate is even more rancorous now than it was during George W. Bush's presidency and it features the same arguments, including the illusion that you can fully control the frontier between the U.S. and Mexico.  Commentary 

Mexico demands answers about shooting by U.S. agent

Related Topics

1 of 7. Jesus Librado Hernandez mourns for his son Sergio in Ciudad Juarez June 9, 2010.

Credit: Reuters/Alejandro Bringas

CIUDAD JUAREZ, Mexico | Wed Jun 9, 2010 6:18pm EDT

CIUDAD JUAREZ, Mexico (Reuters) - Mexico is demanding answers from Washington over the fatal shooting of a teenager by a U.S. border patrol agent and has sent a formal complaint over the incident, Mexico's foreign minister said.

At a wake on Wednesday, grieving relatives wept over the body of Sergio Hernandez, shot on the Mexican side of the border in the frontier city of Ciudad Juarez as he and other youths were running from U.S. border patrol agents.

The death of the teenager has sparked outrage in Mexico, where many already bristle at the way Mexican immigrants doing menial jobs are treated in the United States.

"We have sent diplomatic letters of complaint to the U.S. federal government insisting on an exhaustive investigation," Foreign Minister Patricia Espinosa told a news conference.

"We are using all the resources available to us."

The U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation has opened an investigation into the shooting, which State Department spokesman P.J. Crowley called a "tragic incident." The border agent has been put on leave.

At the same time, Crowley suggested the shooting might have been justified. The FBI said Hernandez was in a group of illegal immigrants trying to sneak into the United States and when two of them were detained, the teen and another individual began throwing rocks at the border patrol agents.

"I would just caution on this particular incident ... Any law enforcement officer has the right of self-defense if people are taking up arms or (throwing) rocks against them," Crowley told reporters in Washington.

Espinosa said it was not clear if the youths, who were under a bridge border crossing a few meters into Mexican territory, had attacked the agents.

Tensions between the major trading partners have been fanned by the state of Arizona's decision to crack down on illegal immigrants.

Mexico has slammed the Arizona law and human rights groups are using Hernandez's death as a platform to talk about the dangers faced by migrants who cross the border each year.

"This shooting across the border appears to have been a grossly disproportionate response and flies in the face of international standards, which compel police to use firearms only as a last resort," Susan Lee, Americas director at Amnesty International, said in a statement.

Amnesty said that in recent days a Mexican immigrant who was being deported died after a U.S. border patrol agent used a stun gun on him.

Hernandez's father said high-tech security at the border, including security cameras, should help U.S. authorities solve the case.

"They saw what happened. They have the video. They have the proof," Jose Hernandez said at the wake, where the youth's body lay in a white coffin, dressed in a blue soccer outfit. "With the technology they use to detect people (crossing), they can see who is guilty."

(Additional reporting by Mica Rosenberg in Mexico City and Mohammed Arshad in Washington; Editing by Catherine Bremer)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (49)
hadenough2 wrote:
@erchess

Already being done. The US is becoming more of a state, that Hitler would’ve loved, everyday. Just read the Bill Of Rights and see if you can think of any laws that have been passed that usurp it. If you can’t read or understand the document, have someone near you read and explain it to you. Don’t fret though, your God is waiting to see just how well you obeyed his Commandments, especially the one “love thy neighbor…”.

Jun 09, 2010 6:29am EDT  --  Report as abuse
Ashau wrote:
erches’s post (Jun 09, 2010 4:19am EDT) is “over the top.”

However, hadenough2’s post (Jun 09, 2010 6:29am EDT) is totally off the wall, spouting liberal/lestist drivel. I think the US is actually becomong more of a state that Marx or Lenin would have loved. I’ve read the Bill of Rights (and have shed blood for it).

Know what? I couldn’t find in it any reference to anyone having the right to illegally sneak into this country. I challenge you, hadenough2, to show me where it specifically allows that right.

And talk about what God does or doesn’t do. Do you even know? No one sneaks illegally into Heaven. Each and every soul must stand before him to be judged prior to entry into paradise. So….if you want to throw God into the mix, know what you’re talking about first.

Jun 09, 2010 6:56am EDT  --  Report as abuse
Ashau wrote:
hadenough2 sez: “Don’t fret though, your God is waiting to see just how well you obeyed his Commandments, especially the one “love thy neighbor…”.

That is a commandment. However, “loving thy neighbor” does not require one to sit by and allow “your neighbor” to break into your house.

As I said in my previous post, before banging on your keybord, it might be beneficial for you to know what you’re talking about.

Jun 09, 2010 7:01am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.