Candidate's daughter to voters: "Don't vote for my dad"

Related Topics

OKLAHOMA CITY, Oklahoma | Tue Jul 27, 2010 1:29pm EDT

OKLAHOMA CITY, Oklahoma (Reuters Life!) - Jan Schill has a message for voters in Oklahoma choosing a district judge in elections on Tuesday -- do not vote for my dad.

She and her husband have taken out newspaper ads urging voters not to vote for John Mantooth, who they believe had a lousy record as a judge and does not deserve the job.

Mantooth has told reporters his daughter, 31, launched her campaign because of lingering resentment over her parents' 1981 divorce. He also said one of his rivals for the post who formerly worked with his son-in-law may have played a role.

But Schill and her husband Andrew, a lawyer, said those are not the reasons at all.

"It's not the (strained) relationship that prompted this. She worked in the district attorney's office in that district. I worked in the legal community and we just felt like we had to say something. It's his record. This father-daughter thing is interesting, but that's not the story," Andrew Schill said.

The Durango, Colorado, couple's ads cost them $900 and ran last Thursday and Friday in the Purcell (Oklahoma) Register and the Norman Transcript.

They tried to get the newspapers to run a story about Mantooth, but were turned down, so they ran the quarter-page ads and launched a website: www.donotvoteformydad.com.

"I've never seen anything like this in American politics," commented University Of Oklahoma political science professor Keith Gaddie. "This is a new one."

Mantooth, in a three-way race for a post that will judge cases in three Oklahoma counties, did not help matters by running campaign ads showing himself as a family man and a father of three daughters with grandchildren, Andrew Schill said.

"He has a relationship with none of them," Schill said.

(Additional reporting and writing by Andrew Stern; Editing by Greg McCune and Jerry Norton)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (18)
evanlabbe wrote:
Good for her! This makes a strong message to voters in that area. If she feels something isn’t right, she has done the right thing by speaking out.
Perhaps this is the effect of a lingering divorce. I dont think it matters much. I wouldn’t necessarily want a judge overseeing my case when he may have a past of not handling sensitive situations properly.
A person’s home life is not that seperate from their job life, not as much as everyone seems to think. If he’s a jerk to his family, he’s going to be a jerk out in the world too. (i’m only guessing he’s a jerk, I could be wrong. But his divorce didn’t seem to go well, and his children wont let him have a relationship with his grandkids. sounds jerk-ish to me)

Jul 28, 2010 11:05am EDT  --  Report as abuse
spoiled wrote:
daughter was so wrong for this. she needs to get a life . it sound to me like her father has went on with his and she is bitter for that. her mother is probably happy and she needs to let go. if she was wanting to hurt him i am sure she did. what will she do next? sounds like she is a miserable person and wants everyone else to be!! and her husband is crazy for letting her use him in this. he needs to think what will she do to me if she decides to get angry?

Jul 28, 2010 2:33pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
caf wrote:
It can’t have been easy for the daughter to go public like this, whatever their family tensions. I applaud her for sharing her behind-the-scenes knowledge with voters. As someone else commented above, if he’s a jerk in his private life, then he’s likely to be a jerk in his public rulings. Certainly, the voters have a right to know that his family disagrees with his “family man” campaign image. I wish more people would have the courage to speak out and alert the public of information that they’re privately privy to. Kudos to her for her courage.

Jul 28, 2010 3:20pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.