SPECIAL REPORT

Arizona appeals immigrant law ruling amid protests

Related Topics

1 of 39. A protestor holds a sign during a demonstration in support of Arizona's immigration law in downtown Manhattan, July 29, 2010.

Credit: Reuters/Mike Segar

PHOENIX | Thu Jul 29, 2010 10:09pm EDT

PHOENIX (Reuters) - Arizona on Thursday appealed a judge's decision to block key parts of the state's crackdown on illegal immigrants and police in Phoenix arrested scores of activists protesting the remaining measures in the law.

Lawyers for Governor Jan Brewer and Arizona asked the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco to lift an injunction blocking the most intrusive parts of the law, known as SB 1070, and asked for the appeal to be handled quickly.

Tensions over the law have inflamed a national debate over immigration, which has festered for decades and promises to play into the elections in November, when President Barack Obama's Democrats are fighting to retain control of Congress.

U.S. District Court judge Susan Bolton on Wednesday blocked the law's most controversial elements, arguing that immigration matters are the federal government's responsibility.

The law had drawn wide popular support in this state bordering Mexico and across the United States as a whole, but was opposed by President Barack Obama and human rights groups.

The U.S. Marshals Service said Bolton had received hate mail following the ruling. Additionally, aides to a U.S. Congressman opposed to the crackdown reported finding a shattered window and a bullet at a district office in Arizona.

Brewer issued a statement saying she had filed the appeal, asking that the suspended provisions "go into effect pending a decision on the merits of this case." The case was widely expected to go all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court.

The Republican-controlled state legislature passed the law three months ago to try to drive nearly half a million illegal immigrants out of Arizona, and stem the flow of human and drug smugglers over the border from Mexico.

Several hundred Hispanic and labor activists, delighted by Wednesday's last-minute ruling, pushed ahead with rallies in central Phoenix, chanting and banging drums in protest at parts of the law that came into effect on Thursday.

ARRESTED AT PROTEST

Police arrested at least 48 protesters after they blocked streets near a sheriff's office in the city center and the entrance to a jail.

A Reuters witness saw police dressed in riot gear arrest demonstrators, including an elderly female church minister. The protesters offered no resistance and police led them away in plastic handcuffs.

"We welcome the fact that the judge blocked some of the provisions in SB 1070 but ... we are continuing action to overturn the rest of the law, " said Pablo Alvarado, executive director of the National Day Laborer Organizing Network.

"Today is going to be worse that yesterday because there will be more laws on the books, more tools for cops," he said.

The fierce debate over illegal immigration stirs up strong passions in the United States, where 11 million illegal immigrants work in mostly low-paid jobs in the shadow economy.

The U.S. Marshals Service in Phoenix said Judge Bolton received hate mail at her court office after making her ruling. Bolton is an appointee of former President Bill Clinton, a Democrat, and some commentators have slammed her as an "activist judge" out of step with the country.

U.S. Rep. Raul Grijalva, an Arizona Democrat and staunch opponent of the law, meanwhile, closed a district office in Yuma after staff found a shattered window and a bullet inside. Police investigated the incident, but had no "potential motive," his office said in a statement.

Among blocked provisions of the law was one requiring a police officer to check the immigration status of anyone stopped or detained if the officer believed they were not in the country legally.

Immigrants would also have been required to carry their documents at all times and undocumented workers would have been forbidden to solicit work in public.

Measures not subject to the stay, and which went into effect on Thursday, included offenses making it illegal for drivers to pick up day laborers from the street and to transport or harbor an illegal immigrant.

COPYCAT LAWS

The law triggered interest in copycat measures in as many as 20 other states around the country. But analysts said Bolton's ruling on Wednesday would "at least hit the pause button" for some Republicans mulling their own measures.

"If the Supreme Court upholds the injunction that will most likely put a real damper on any potential legislation," said Mark Jones, a political scientist at Rice University in Texas.

The law is popular with a majority of Americans and 65 percent of Arizona voters, although opponents charge it is unconstitutional and would lead to discrimination against Latinos, and Latino-looking Americans.

Scores of day laborers set out to seek work at informal day labor sites in Phoenix, despite the new provisions.

"We're not criminals, we're not hurting anyone ... We wish people would know that," said Franco Escamilla, an undocumented laborer from Mexico, as he waited outside a Home Depot store in Phoenix.

A sheriff known for his tough approach to illegal immigrants in the Phoenix area, pushed ahead with a crime and immigration sweep in as planned on Thursday, arresting four people. It was not immediately clear if they were illegal immigrants.

"Nothing is going to deter the sheriff and my office, including rulings of a federal judge," Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio said. "It's business as normal."

About 10 protesters were arrested in Los Angeles after they chained themselves together in the middle of a busy intersection during a demonstration over the Arizona law that drew about 200 people.

(Writing by Tim Gaynor; Additional reporting by David Schwartz in Phoenix, Dan Whitcomb in Los Angeles and Jeremy Pelofsky in Washington; Editing by David Storey and Eric Walsh)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (35)
pdecio wrote:
I do not feel we are hostile to our own people. We are tried of illegal immigrants coming here and taking our jobs, applying and getting government benefits that the U.S. citizens have trouble getting and then expecting us to learn their language. If we went to live in their country we would have to learn their language there to communicate but they expect us to learn it on our own soil. I believe if they want to stay in the U.S. then they need to become full U.S. citizens, work jobs to pay taxes, learn full English to communicate with Americans, and not expect to be treated special because they are foreigners because once you become a U.S. citizen you are no longer a foreigner and should not act like one or expect special treatment. When my ancestors came to this country there were certain rules they had to follow and guidelines to become a citizen, learning to speak the same language was a big prerequisite for becoming a citizen and being allowed to stay. If the rules and guidelines were not completed in a certain length of time they were sent back to their own country. That is exactly how it should be done here, learn the language, pay taxes, and do what others Americans are expected to do for a set length of time and then you can become citizens, if you do not like the rules then don’t stay. I do NOT like calling a help desk and I have to push “1″ for English, this should be automatic because we are an English speaking country. My North American Indian ancestors had to learn to speak English to communicate with the white man in this same country, but now you are allowing immigrants from other countries to come over here and tell us what language to speak, commit murders just because and then expect us to say oh that is okay we do not mind, if you come to our country illegally and commit a crime you should be shipped back to your own country and commit them there.

Jul 29, 2010 9:36pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
anotherview wrote:
Illegal aliens have no right to live and work in America. The central government has failed to enforce existing federal immigration law to stop illegal immigration and to remove the illegal aliens. A simple remedy exists. The central government could immediately mandate nationwide that all employers use the E-Verify program to screen all job applicants for a right to work. Meanwhile, local communities and businesses may also adopt the E-Verify program. With no job, the illegal aliens will self-deport, at their own expense — no national roundup necessary. Minus the lure of a job, the foreign nationals will not illegally migrate to this country. All concerned would adjust. Employers would have to offer higher pay to attract citizens to do the jobs illegal aliens now do for coolie wages. Jobs would open for citizens. Crime would drop. With smaller or no illegal alien communities, the criminal aliens and the fugitive aliens would find less opportunity to take sanctuary and hide. Law enforcement officers could then more easily detect and detain these undesirables for their due deportation. American already has enough criminals. Let us take back our dear nation from the illegal aliens, the criminal aliens, and the fugitive aliens. America can get along without them, and will prosper all the more.

Jul 29, 2010 9:45pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
AZNATIVE wrote:
Being politically correct has gotten us where we are today.A laughing stock that the entire world loves to HATE.A Nation that does not stand together.
It is time to open your eyes and POINT at the elephant in the room.

It is Illegal aliens we will thank for prompting our Federal government to use an Orwellian National ID program, a database of all Americans that are and have been here LEGALLY. We will no longer be unique but, will be required by law to have proper identification to cross state lines on our vacations.

It is Illegal Aliens that have forced our government to chip away at our constitutional rights piece by piece, so that WE can build their own personal
pedestal to stand on.

Today half of Americans do not want to admit that the illegal alien problem that the United States is being forced to deal with are not Canadian, German, Indonesian, Russian, Brazilian, French, Italian, Irish, Chinese, African or Pakistani.

The illegals that we have in Arizona and all over the United States for that matter are not working hard to change their lives and the lives of their family’s for the better, they are not keeping their heads down and pushing at the wheel for progress.

The Illegals we are talking about
here are being shielded by other groups of Americans that are more proud of their race than they are proud of being a true free American or, teaching illegals how to successfully use the hard working path to legal status.

The illegals here are using an American system and its resources for personal gain, they use everything they can, while they can and, they have been doing it for too long.

The United States was founded by immigrants but, alas those Illegals were different too. Those immigrants bet their LIVES on finding the American dream not stumbling upon a soapbox to stand on and proclaiming that they deserve it.

The illegal aliens that are causing all the ripples in our justice system and who have divided our country are not to be our heroes or role models.

The immigration issue has never been more clear than it is today. Illegal is not a race or a color. Illegal is not a political movement. Illegal is tearing the fabric
of our country. Illegal is the issue at hand. Blaming a race is nonsensical. Closing the path that proliferates Illegal behavior is a responsibility.

A responsibility of EVERY American red, white, blue or brown. We don’t need to be afraid to stand up and point at the elephant in the room because, until Americans have enough fortitude to do the pointing, or even agree that Arizona’s open borders are at the heart of our immigration problem then, America has failed it’s own people.

Arizona is a known mecca for illegal border crossing, the gateway from the southern hemisphere and a illegal border crosser’s Avalon.

Until the county’s of Arizona are inhospitable to the illegal immigrant they will continue to come seeking the easy life. Illegal immigrants are injecting our US dollars into their home country’s economy and, America and its people will continue to stand divided and weak.

Mexican boarder crossers are the elephant we are pointing at. If America does not stand together and shout ELEPHANT then we are a nation of cowards and charlatans.

Jul 29, 2010 9:59pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.