Americans confused about healthcare reform: poll

CHICAGO Mon Aug 23, 2010 5:20pm EDT

Related Topics

CHICAGO (Reuters) - Julia Wood, a 51-year-old mother of 12 from Chicago's East side, has some health insurance through a state program -- but is so worried she may lose it she asks not to give her real name.

Wood's husband, a plumbing contractor, watched his business dry up in 2008 with the mortgage crisis.

"The economy hit us," said Wood in an interview at the not-for-profit Chicago Family Health Center.

Like millions of Americans, she is waiting for healthcare reform legislation signed into law by President Barack Obama in March to take effect. But like millions of Americans, she is not sure what it will do for her.

A Thomson Reuters poll of consumer confidence released on Monday shows Americans' confidence in their ability to pay for and access healthcare has fallen by 5 percent since December 2009.

The Thomson Reuters Consumer Healthcare Sentiment Index, based on a monthly survey of 3,000 consumers, asks if they have had trouble paying for or had to postpone care in the three months prior. And it asks if they expect to in the coming three months.

On every survey question, responses were more pessimistic in July than they were in December.

"That's a cause for concern to healthcare providers and policymakers," Gary Pickens, chief research officer at Thomson Reuters, parent company of Reuters, said in a statement.

Pickens has seen a gradual eroding of confidence since December, despite a few notable peaks, such as in April, the month after Congress passed the Affordable Care Act.

"I doubt the average person really knows what has been implemented," he said. "They just know there is a lot of talk and there has been a lot of negative publicity."

LETDOWN

David Kendall, a senior fellow for health and fiscal policy at ThirdWay, a centrist think tank, said dissatisfaction with the current health system likely reflects a letdown after the reform debate subsided.

"The healthcare debate raised people's expectations and there is now disappointment as a result that the problem isn't solved," Kendall said.

He said growing dissatisfaction with healthcare may help Democrats who supported health reform a little. But it may also be polarizing.

In the Thomson Reuters poll, Republicans tend to have slightly higher confidence about access to healthcare, which may be linked to employment, Pickens said.

"Clearly, at the top of the pile, the most important factor is having insurance coverage," Pickens said in a telephone interview. "It's related to your employment status and, obviously, so many people in the country are out of work."

Republican National Committee Chairman Michael Steele said in a statement on Friday that the White House has failed to win widespread support for health reform.

"For months, the White House promised wavering Democrats that the bill would become more popular once it became law. The White House was wrong," he said.

Kendall, however, thinks concerns about the economy will overshadow any concerns about health reform in the midterm elections.

"What matters more to people right now is their concern about the deficit and the economy and their own jobs," he said.

Stephanie Washington, a 50-year-old clerk for the Chicago Public Schools, said she hopes healthcare does become an election issue.

"We are in a recession. Anybody who thinks because the president is trying to reform healthcare and they don't think one day it's going to benefit you as well as the next person can go and vote Republican," she said.

(Editing by Maggie Fox and Mohammad Zargham)

FILED UNDER:
We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (46)
trevorh wrote:
Is it a typo in the article??
“a 51-year-old mother of 12″
of 12?? (Twelve??)

I don’t want to be condescending here, but seriously if someone wants to have 12 kids and indeed has 12 kids, they need to have their head checked out.

These people are guaranteed to have problems and hardship in their lives with this kind of irresponsibility.

Doesn’t matter who’s in power (D or R), nothing can fix this sort of problems. Stop asking the government to solve a problem you create!!

Government and politicians don’t help people. If they indeed help you, it just means they took something from somebody somewhere sometime somehow and gave it to you. And when they do that, they keep a lot of the things they took for themselves. That’s what career politicians are all about!!

Don’t be a sheep and grow up! Be responsible for your action.

Aug 23, 2010 1:30am EDT  --  Report as abuse
barefoot76 wrote:
This article assumes that we are CONFUSED? No…We are now better informed at just how bad for the country this bill is!!

All this thing does is create more bureaucracy; increase the size of the IRS and other departments, and limits the healthcare we have now!!

After now studying the bill I realized that we don’t have the capability of paying for it! It puts the care I receive into the hands of bureaucrats and non medical personnel, letting someone other than a doctor make decisions about our well being!

So to put this article in perspective, the author is the one that is uninformed about what the polls mean! It simply means that we reject this piece of legislation, and WILL vote for leaders that vote to repeal it!

Oh and BTW? The real numbers when it comes to the dissatisfaction with this bill is more like 78% of Americans AGAINST! But our out of touch legislators voted to enact it anyway! Guess how many will be fired over it!

Aug 23, 2010 3:41am EDT  --  Report as abuse
barefoot76 wrote:
This article assumes that we are CONFUSED? No…We are now better informed at just how bad for the country this bill is!!

All this thing does is create more bureaucracy; increase the size of the IRS and other departments, and limits the healthcare we have now!!

After now studying the bill I realized that we don’t have the capability of paying for it! It puts the care I receive into the hands of bureaucrats and non medical personnel, letting someone other than a doctor make decisions about our well being!

So to put this article in perspective, the author is the one that is uninformed about what the polls mean! It simply means that we reject this piece of legislation, and WILL vote for leaders that vote to repeal it!

Oh and BTW? The real numbers when it comes to the dissatisfaction with this bill is more like 78% of Americans AGAINST! But our out of touch legislators voted to enact it anyway! Guess how many will be fired over it!

Aug 23, 2010 3:41am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

Pictures