Israel: No Iran bomb before 2015

JERUSALEM Fri Jan 7, 2011 4:42am EST

Related Topics

JERUSALEM (Reuters) - Israel believes Iran will not be able to produce a nuclear bomb before 2015 and a top Israeli official has counseled against pre-emptive military strikes, intelligence assessments published on Friday said.

Given in a briefing by Mossad director Meir Dagan upon his retirement on Thursday, the assessments pointed to new Israeli confidence in U.S.-led sanctions and covert action designed to discourage or delay Tehran's uranium enrichment program.

They were also in line with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's public circumspection -- echoing louder misgivings voiced by the Obama administration -- about resorting to force against Iran, which denies seeking nuclear arms and has vowed to retaliate against Israel and U.S. interests for any such attack.

"Iran will not achieve a nuclear bomb before 2015, if that," Dagan said, according to a transcript obtained by Reuters.

Dagan, who in June 2009 told Israeli lawmakers that Iran could have its first nuclear warhead by 2014, attributed his valedictory timeline to a variety of factors including domestic ferment in Iran and the bite of international sanctions.

Iran's enrichment drive has also suffered technical setbacks, possibly a sign of foreign sabotage in incidents such as the apparent corruption of some Iranian nuclear machinery by the Stuxnet computer worm.


Western intelligence agencies similarly say Iran could make a bomb by the middle of the decade, should it choose to enrich uranium to higher levels and master weaponization technologies.

Iran says it is refining uranium only to the lower level of fissile purity suitable for electricity and medical isotopes.

Dagan, a former general whose eight-year tenure as spymaster was widely seen as having escalated Mossad shadow wars, said any Israeli military action against Iran should be last-ditch only.

Such attacks could spur Iran to pull out of the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty and pursue its program entirely free of U.N. inspections, he said. Iran's past secrecy over some of its projects stirred suspicions of undeclared military designs.

"Israel should not hasten to attack Iran, doing so only when the sword is upon its neck," Dagan said. His briefing was reported on prominently by Israeli newspapers and broadcasters.

Israel is widely assumed to have the Middle East's only atomic arsenal but many analysts say its air force is too small to take on Iran's distant, dispersed and fortified sites alone.

Israel is mindful of the risk of retaliation from Iran or its allies in Syria and Lebanese and Palestinian guerrilla groups. Washington has said it does not want a new regional war, though, like Israel, it has not ruled out force against Iran.

Israeli Defence Minister Ehud Barak said on Tuesday that "no options should be removed from the table" but that "the time is still one of diplomacy" for resolving the face-off with Iran.

"What is required is much harsher sanctions than today's," he said in a speech. "Only such paralyzing sanctions have a chance of putting the Iranian will to the test."

(Writing by Dan Williams; editing by Mark Heinrich)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (1)
McBob08 wrote:
….or, Iran might not be developing nuclear weapons at all, and Israel is just feeding fear to the people of Israel and America in order to keep getting nuclear weapons and massive funding from America; all the better for them to keep oppressing Palestinians, and then pointing at the tiny radical minority that throws metaphorical dirt-clods at their bristling tanks and ludicrously over-armed IDF?

Even if we were to believe this fantasy story that the Israelis and American War Profiteers keep trying to sell us, we still have nothing to fear. Iran has *NO FIRST STRIKES* enshrined in its constitution. It *cannot* pre-emptively attack Israel or America without immediately proving itself to be a rogue nation, and bringing the wrath of the entire world down on itself. If we were to believe this fairy tale about nuclear weapons in Iran, then the world is perfectly safe, unless Israel does something stupid, like attacking them first.

They’ve even done it in the past; Israel has pre-emptively bombed Iran, giving Iran the perfect excuse to attack back, but they showed the restraint and maturity that Israel failed to show and didn’t retaliate back aggressively.

Israel is the nuclear power in the Middle East that we really need to fear, not Iran.

Jan 07, 2011 4:29am EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.