Israeli troops kill wrong man in Hamas raid

Related Topics

Medics carry the body of Amr Qawasme, who was killed by Israeli soldiers in his home, out of an ambulance in Hebron, in this still image taken from video January 7, 2011. REUTERS/Reuters TV

Medics carry the body of Amr Qawasme, who was killed by Israeli soldiers in his home, out of an ambulance in Hebron, in this still image taken from video January 7, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Reuters TV

HEBRON, West Bank | Fri Jan 7, 2011 8:58am EST

HEBRON, West Bank (Reuters) - Israeli soldiers killed a 65-year-old Palestinian in his bedroom Friday during a pre-dawn raid to seize a Hamas suspect who lived in the same building, in what the army admitted was a mistake.

The man was shot as troops swooped on houses in the occupied West Bank to re-arrest five members of the Islamist Hamas group who had been freed from Palestinian jails just the day before.

The U.S.-backed administration of Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, which often coordinates West Bank security with Israel, rejected Hamas charges of responsibility for Amr Qawasme's death and said the blame was exclusively Israel's.

Soldiers broke into Qawasme's home, one floor above a Hamas militant, and stormed into his bedroom, his wife Sobheye said. She heard shots and found Qawasme lying in a pool of blood.

"I was praying when they entered. I do not know how they opened the door. They put their hand to my mouth and a rifle to my head," she told Reuters.

"I was shocked. They did not allow me to talk. I asked them, 'What did you do?' They asked me to shut up."

Reuters Television video showed Qawasme had been shot in the head and body. Bullet casings were scattered on the floor of his room, his pillow and mattress left soaked with blood.

The Israeli army expressed regret that soldiers who went to arrest Wael Mahmoud Said Bitar -- who it said had helped plan a 2008 suicide bomb attack in which an Israeli woman was killed -- had killed a man in the house during the raid.

"Unfortunately, during this operation a man uninvolved in terror got killed in Hebron," Brigadier General Nitsan Alon told reporters. "We're investigating this case and we'll inform you when we have more information."

DEADLY WEEK

Violence in the occupied West Bank has largely tapered off in the past few years as a result of security measures by Israel and Abbas's bolstered and foreign-trained Palestinian police.

But tension has resurged in the past week, coinciding with a deepening deadlock in Israeli-Palestinian peace efforts.

Last Friday, a Palestinian woman died following a protest against an Israeli barrier built across the West Bank. A local medic said the woman died after inhaling tear gas.

Sunday, an Israeli soldier shot dead a Palestinian who approached a West Bank checkpoint holding a glass bottle.

General Alon said there was no link between the incidents and no concern that rules of engagement were being violated. The army was in touch with Palestinian officials and would show that tear gas did not cause the woman's death, he said.

Israel and Abbas's self-rule administration have a common foe in Hamas, which rejects co-existence with the Jewish state and controls the Gaza Strip, another Palestinian territory.

Several hundred Hamas followers have been rounded up by Abbas' forces since the Palestinian split in 2007. Hamas in Gaza has similarly cracked down on members of Abbas's Fatah movement.

The Israelis sometimes chafe at Abbas's handling of the group. They were clearly irked by the Palestinian Authority's decision to release the Hamas militants Thursday. Israeli reports said the militants, who had been on hunger strike, were freed at the request of the emir of Qatar.

Abbas spokesman Nabil Abu Rdainah said the Hamas men were freed to foster intra-Palestinian reconciliation, and Hamas had been "warned that they may be arrested by occupation forces."

But a Hamas spokesman in Gaza nevertheless said the movement "holds the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank responsible with the (Israeli) occupation for the crime."

Abbas adviser Saeb Erekat said a complaint had been filed with the United States and European Union over the incident.

"We strongly condemn this cold-blooded killing and the arrest of brothers from Hamas. The Israeli government shoulders responsibility for the lives of those arrested," he said.

(Additional reporting by Nidal al-Mughrabi in Gaza and Douglas Hamilton in the West Bank; Writing by Dan Williams and Douglas Hamilton; editing by Mark Heinrich)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (9)
anonym0us wrote:
Errare humanum est. People make mistakes. When a waiter makes a mistake it results in spilled soup. When oil rig operators make a mistake it results in spilled oil. When soldiers make mistakes it results in spilled blood. Drivers on the road also make mistakes resulting in dead bodies, and much more often, but it makes the news only when it’s something extraordinarily horrible. But some reporters, and particularly certain al-Mughrabi, never miss an opportunity to make noise about Israelis. As long as Reuters employs such reporters the very objectivity and impartiality of Reuters reporting becomes questionable to say the least.
Israel is fighting a war, that was started by Arabs on the day the state of Israel was declared, and never ended. War means collateral damage. One should be surprised not by the fact that it happens, but rather by it happening orders of magnitude less frequently than it could.

Jan 07, 2011 12:18pm EST  --  Report as abuse
drmorocco wrote:
So the next time a suicide bomber kills thirty or forty Israeli’s it should be viewed as a mistake or collateral damage?

Jan 07, 2011 1:11pm EST  --  Report as abuse
USAalltheway wrote:
A similar event happened in Atlanta a while back when the police raided the house of an elderly lady by mistake and killed her. It did not make international headlines. Mistakes like this happen all around the world.

Jan 07, 2011 1:30pm EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.