Haitians recall 2010 quake "hell" as death toll raised

PORT-AU-PRINCE Wed Jan 12, 2011 4:11pm EST

1 of 15. Haitians attend ceremonies to commemorate the one-year anniversary of the 2010 earthquake in Port-au-Prince January 12, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Eduardo Munoz

Related Video

PORT-AU-PRINCE (Reuters) - Haiti mourned more than 300,000 victims of its devastating 2010 earthquake on Wednesday in a somber one-year anniversary clouded by pessimism over slow reconstruction and political uncertainty.

Revising upwards previous death toll estimates from the January 12 quake of around 250,000, Prime Minister Jean-Max Bellerive said the recovery of additional bodies over the year put the total figure at "over 316,000 people killed".

He spoke at a news conference with former U.S. President and U.N. Special Envoy to Haiti Bill Clinton after thousands of Haitians, many wearing white in mourning, attended poignant memorial services around the battered Caribbean country.

At one ceremony at the ruins of the National Cathedral in the wrecked capital Port-au-Prince conducted by the Papal envoy to Haiti, many local mourners stretched out their arms, calling aloud the names of dead loved ones and imploring God's help.

Other religious leaders, government officials and foreign dignitaries attended the service.

But in one sign of popular frustration over the sluggish pace of internationally backed recovery efforts, some 60 demonstrators at one point displayed banners in the city center criticizing U.N. peacekeepers and aid NGOs.

One banner condemned the "occupation" of Haiti, while others read "NGOs are wasting money".

But in general the mood was quietly somber in the ravaged coastal city, which is still filled with rubble from the massive quake that struck the poor Caribbean nation at 4:53 p.m. a year ago, killing around a quarter of a million people.

Despite an outpouring of solidarity for Haiti from around the world, billions of dollars of aid pledges and a huge ongoing humanitarian operation, ordinary Haitians say they are still waiting to see a positive impact in the Western Hemisphere's poorest state.

"If the reconstruction were serious, the mass would be happening inside the rebuilt church," Carla Fleuriven, a 19-year-old mother of three dressed in a white skirt and blouse, told Reuters outside the Cathedral.

On January 12 last year, she saw the Cathedral collapse, along with her home, and she now lives in a makeshift shelter, one of more than 800,000 homeless quake survivors who are still camped out in tents and tarpaulins 12 months after the disaster.

One of the world's poorest countries, Haiti was already in bad shape before the quake. But promises from the international community to "build Haiti back better" now ring hollow to many of Haiti's most vulnerable.

"We wake up every morning in the dust ... We need people who can understand the country, who can change the country," Fleuriven said.

Reconstruction work has barely begun, profiteering by Haiti's tiny and notoriously corrupt elite has reached epic proportions, and a national cholera epidemic has added to the misery of the quake-crippled country.

A political impasse since a disputed presidential election on November 28 has fueled further instability.

"God made the earthquake, but it's our leaders who are selling our misery," said Sephonese Louis, 58, one of the protesters in the Champs de Mars, Port-au-Prince's central plaza where thousands of families made homeless by the quake live in a sweltering tent city,


Haiti's normally voluble radio stations played solemn music and shops, businesses, banks, schools and government offices were closed in a day of national remembrance declared by President Rene Preval's government.

At the site of the country's main tax office which was leveled in the quake, Preval laid the first stone of what will be a memorial to the victims.

But Champs de Mars camp residents said the ceremonies and renewed pledges of aid and progress for Haiti from foreign officials were like something taking place in another world.

"I hear about aid on TV but us in Champs Mars, we've never seen it. We have no way to get out," said 55-year-old Ginelle Pierre Louis.

"The diplomats pass through in the air, in helicopters, but they never come through here on the ground," said Hyacinthe Mintha, 56, a resident of Champs Mars, which overlooks the heavily damaged presidential palace.


Mintha's daughter, Hyacinthe Benita, 39, lives in a metal and wood shack with a frayed tarp roof and a thin pallet as the only bed for herself and her four children.

"We are still here in misery," she said. "I hope this year brings serious change because 2010 was hell for us."

Clinton acknowledged disappointment with the commission's work. "Nobody's been more frustrated than I am that we haven't done more," he told reporters on Tuesday.

Denis O'Brien, a supporter of Clinton and chairman of the Irish-owned cell phone company Digicel that is Haiti's biggest foreign investor, told Reuters that most members of Haiti's ruling elite families have done little to help.

"They're making massive profits on the importation of goods, products, services, everything ... Profiteering at a major scale is going on here," O'Brien added.

Jimmy Jean-Louis, a Haitian-born actor who now lives in Los Angeles but was visiting his homeland, said not much had changed since the disaster. "Everything went down on January 12th," he added. "It might stay down for years to come."

(Additional reporting by Joseph Guyler Delva; Editing by Pascal Fletcher and Cynthia Osterman)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (4)
russdward357 wrote:
Don’t act surprised that the elite and ruling class are sucking the aid channels dry. Why do you think that the country was so screwed up to begin with? Sad as it is, you were a sucker if you jumped on that Haitian relief charity bandwagon last year. It was all just a feel-good and thoughtless fad, one that apparently done little except to fuel the evil in this world. Fad charity always seems to end up that way.

Jan 12, 2011 6:31am EST  --  Report as abuse
PeterMelzer wrote:
Haiti presents so many challenges that any own initiative that improves the situation should be considered for support. At least the newly-built wooden huts on concrete slabs are less vulnerable to earth quakes and less lethal than the old shoddily-constructed concrete buildings.

Leaving the Palace as it is may help remind the national leadership that plenty is left to be done. So many fundamental needs have not been met in the year past.

In addition to sanitation and reconstruction, constructing safe buildings ought to be a focus. The next quake is sure to come. Simple, affordable means of quake alert must be found. Every second advance warning may save many lives.

Read more here:

Jan 12, 2011 8:03am EST  --  Report as abuse
frankelean wrote:
how can people in their right mind see all th disaster in Haiti and still take they for a ride. although, the donations are not beholding on the donors but it would have been more honourable not to pledge at all
, than to pledge and not fulfill the pledge. the live of those orphaned children and displaced persons have come to depend on those pledges…it will be a shame to allow them to keep wallowing in miseray considering the other disaters that visited them. their leaders too should be tried at icc

Jan 12, 2011 11:48am EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.