Egyptians have reservations about ElBaradei

Related Topics

CAIRO | Mon Jan 31, 2011 5:48am EST

CAIRO (Reuters) - Egyptians on the streets of Cairo said on Monday they had reservations about opposition leader Mohamed ElBaradei, who has offered to act as transitional leader to prepare Egypt for democratic elections.

ElBaradei, former head of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), returned to Egypt on the eve of the protests which swept the country on Friday, when tens of thousands of people called for the overthrow of President Hosni Mubarak.

Awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for his work with the IAEA, ElBaradei and the powerful Muslim Brotherhood said on Sunday he had a mandate from opposition groups to make contact with the army and negotiate a government of national unity.

At least one opposition party, the Arab nationalist Karama Party of Hamdin Sabahi, has rejected ElBaradei outright as a transitional figure, saying he was trying to jump on the bandwagon of the popular uprising.

ElBaradei joined protesters at the hub of anti-Mubarak protests in central Cairo on Sunday.

ElBaradei, 68, began overt opposition to Mubarak on his return to Egypt in February 2010 and won a widespread following among the young and the middle classes.

But the Egyptian authorities harassed his supporters and ElBaradei lost much credibility through his long absences abroad. The official media tried to ridicule him, saying he knew nothing about Egypt and had no political experience.

Some elements of the government's campaign appear to have stuck. "ElBaradei won't do. He doesn't have the experience here and he's a little weak," said Khaled Ezzat, 34, an information technology engineer who had joined the evening vigil in Tahrir Square.

"NOT NEUTRAL" ON IRAN

Omar Mahdi, a sales manager, said: "I'm not convinced by ElBaradei, even as a transitional figure, he hasn't really been present in the country."

Some of the protesters objected to ElBaradei on the grounds that he was too close to the United States, despite the frictions between him and the U.S. administration over the Iranian and Israeli nuclear programs when he was head of the U.N. nuclear watchdog body.

"ElBaradei's positions toward other Arab countries, and toward Iran and North Korea, were not neutral... So I don't find him very acceptable," said Walid Abdel-Mit'aal, 36, who works for a public sector company.

"He would follow Mubarak in the same policies and would take U.S. aid," he added, reflecting an anti-American strand which was largely absent in the first four days of protests.

ElBaradei's cosmopolitanism -- he lived abroad for years and speaks fluent English -- may be an advantage among some Egyptians but it is also a source of suspicion among others.

The protesters in Tahrir Square suggested several alternatives to ElBaradei as transitional leader, including Arab League Secretary General Amr Moussa, a popular former foreign minister, the president of the constitutional court or the president of the supreme administrative court.

Others said they were open-minded and what mattered was changing the constitution to ensure that no one man clings to power as long as Mubarak, who took office in 1981.

"ElBaradei is a very acceptable option because he will not stay," said Islam Ashraf, 24, a quality operations coordinator. "But we're not really interested in faces. What matters to us is having another system," he said.

(Editing by Janet Lawrence)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (17)
jmbreland wrote:
ElBaradei is an equal opportunity opportunist who will do/say/turn a blind eye to anything so long as it advances his career. Witness his duplicity in Iraq and Iran. I mean, come on, would you actually trust a guy who wins the Nobel Peace Prize these days?

Jan 31, 2011 8:16am EST  --  Report as abuse
BeanerECMO wrote:
Repression??!! We will see suppression the likes of which we have not seen since the Ayatollah and the Taliban took over in Iran and Afghanistan, respectively. There will be no inside the country move toward democracy in North Africa or the Middle East. The only reforms that will happen in Egypt will be those imposed by the Muslim Brotherhood. El Baradei is either foolish or naive or both. The Muslim Brotherhood will use him for their purposes to get the people behind the movement even more and then they will replace (execute) him much like what happened in Iran after the Shah. Remember what happened in Yugoslavia after Tito died. The same will happen all over North Africa. All the princes in the Saudi peninsula are shaking in their boots because they know they are next. The whole region; i.e., North Africa and the Middle East; will be turned into an even more radical and proactive Muslim fundamentalist region, fostered by Iran and the rising Taliban, where we have no sway. And, then we will see the rise of unrest even more in the Far East around Indonesia. When people keep contending that thi9s is not a religious war, they are so terribly wrong. The world leaders are so uneducated and stupid to believe the reforms they want are the same reforms the Muslim Brotherhood wants. And, our current administration has no way forward except to have their collective heads in the sand. Why do you think there was such bowing and scraping on BHO’s trips to North Africa and the Middle East? He takes umbrage with how Mubarak was running Egypt, by fiat, when it is exactly how he is (was) trying to run the US – aided and abetted (at one time) by a sheeple congress.

Jan 31, 2011 9:42am EST  --  Report as abuse
Truecolours wrote:
ElBaradei is very articulate, respected and probably the most trustworthy/fair/centrist person to act as transition leader. The last thing the Egyptian people need is a “strong man” with ideological agenda. The “strong man” is always the classic mistake! Good luck to the Egyptian people! I hope they finally have freedom from religious zealots and tyrannical dictators.

Jan 31, 2011 9:50am EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.