Raw milk debate simmers as states, FDA mull rules

GILL, Massachusetts Wed Feb 23, 2011 5:25pm EST

A bottle of milk in a refrigerator bears a label showing that it is from cows not treated with artificial growth hormones, in Washington in this November 9, 2009 file photo. REUTERS/Jim Bourg

A bottle of milk in a refrigerator bears a label showing that it is from cows not treated with artificial growth hormones, in Washington in this November 9, 2009 file photo.

Credit: Reuters/Jim Bourg

GILL, Massachusetts (Reuters) - Clifford Hatch cares for about 20 cows at his family-run farm, producing fresh raw milk that is at the center of controversy over its sale and safety.

Hatch sells raw, or unpasteurized, milk products from a retail shop at his dairy farm, which state regulations allow him to do because the business is located on the same property where his Ayrshire cattle are milked.

He said he might sell 40 to 50 gallons a day at his Upinngill Farm, which started producing raw milk and cheese years ago when local residents began seeking an alternative to dairy from big, industrialized producers whose use of artificial bovine growth hormones was widespread then.

"The system is pretty sensible and reasonably well-enforced," Hatch said.

But debate is swirling over raw milk in many U.S. states, and the thought of tighter federal rules on its production and sale makes independent producers such as Hatch uneasy.

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention both strongly warn the public against drinking raw milk. They see potential health risks from pathogens like E. coli bacteria, which in some instances can get into milk from an animal's manure.

But raw dairy advocates say unpasteurized milk is at least as safe as the "superheated" varieties because of the dedication small-batch farmers have to maintaining hygienic facilities.

Some people prefer raw milk, saying it is sweeter and has more vitamins and minerals, "healthy" bacteria and digestive enzymes. They say pasteurizing milk, or heating it to above 160 degrees Fahrenheit, destroys most of those features.

Part of the debate centers on cheese, which is legal under federal law if it is aged at least 60 days to kill bacteria such as E. coli.

But the FDA is mulling extending the aging requirement past 60 days which could, in effect, outlaw some popular raw milk cheeses as well as pasteurized ripened cheeses.

An FDA spokeswoman said on Wednesday the agency is looking at whether the aging requirements for cheese "are sufficient to minimize pathogens," including salmonella and E. coli.

The FDA's review could take until late in the year, when it would release results of its risk study, she said.

Some raw dairy proponents fear the FDA could outlaw raw milk production altogether.

"Their policy certainly is very anti-raw milk. It's always a concern," said Winton Pitcoff, raw milk network coordinator for the Massachusetts chapter of the Northeast Organic Farming Association (NOFAMass).

Some U.S. states are restricting raw milk use already.

Vermont has both deep agricultural roots and a newer local-food renaissance boosting the economy. But the state this month suspended workshops led by an advocacy group teaching people how to turn unpasteurized milk into butter and cheese.

Vermont's agriculture agency says the state's 2009 raw milk law limits farmers to selling it to customers for fluid consumption only. But the agency says it will not interfere with how people use or consume raw milk in their own homes.

In ten states, including California, Maine, Connecticut and New Hampshire, people can buy raw milk in grocery stores. But sales are banned in many other states, including dairy giant Wisconsin. Federal law also bans interstate sales of raw milk.

A few states are considering legalization or loosening regulations, among them Texas, New Jersey and Massachusetts.

Massachusetts does not allow raw milk sales in grocery stores, but it is considering a bill to let farmers deliver to customers and sell at stands away from their farms.

Raw milk producers can sell a gallon of fresh milk for $6 to $12 - about four times what processors pay dairy farmers for milk they truck to processing plants.

Farmers say the heftier price can make the difference between a farm being profitable or needing to shut down.

The number of dairy farms nationwide has dwindled. In Massachusetts, about 5,000 farms existed in 1950 but today fewer than 180 remain, NOFAMass says.

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (4)
aed939 wrote:
The FDA is already enforcing a complete prohibition of raw milk to the fullest extent of its jurisdiction via the interstate commerce clause. It can’t go any further.

Feb 23, 2011 4:53pm EST  --  Report as abuse
justsayin2011 wrote:
Only about 800 people have died from raw milk since the US started keeping records. Those of us who choose raw milk should be left alone. I like my odds with raw milk better than the odds with, lets say, the mass produced meat industry. Don’t be a sheeple, when was the last time we had to recall a batch of locally grown food?

Feb 23, 2011 5:50pm EST  --  Report as abuse
ReneeC2010 wrote:
I have been drinking raw milk for my entire youth and lately for over 3 months. I have never felt better; I don’t need probiotics anymore and have so much energy. My hair, skin and nails have improved. I don’t get sick anymore either. I can make my own butter, yogurt, and ice cream. You can’t do that with over processed milk in which all the enzymes and vitamins are killed and then chemical vitamins are put back in. You lose the precious enzymes in the pasteurization process. It is obvious that the human body can heal and prevent disease when you consume real raw foods instead of overly processed foods full of chemicals, growth hormones, antibiotics, pesticides, and fake ingredients. It is funny how the FDA rushes Pharmaceuticals on the market with limited and misconstrued safety testing and then have to pull them off the market when the human guinea pigs start dying. How many people have the FDA killed (caused chronic disease or suicide) over the last 50 years, including the poor people and their children of foreign countries they bullied to test unsafe drugs on?

Feb 24, 2011 2:15pm EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.