Militants say killed Pakistani minister for blasphemy

ISLAMABAD Wed Mar 2, 2011 11:49am EST

1 of 8. Martha Jacob (C), mother of slain Pakistani Minister for Minorities Shahbaz Bhatti, mourns with other family members at her residence in Islamabad March 2, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Stringer

Related Video

Related Topics

ISLAMABAD (Reuters) - Taliban militants on Wednesday shot dead Pakistan's only Christian government minister for challenging a law that mandates the death penalty for insulting Islam, the latest sign of instability in a country where many fear radical Islam is becoming more mainstream.

Minister for Minorities Shahbaz Bhatti is the second senior official this year to be assassinated for opposing the blasphemy law. Provincial governor Salman Taseer was shot dead by his own bodyguard in January.

These killings, along with frequent militant attacks and chronic economic problems have raised fears for the future of U.S.-ally and nuclear-armed Pakistan, where an unpopular coalition government is struggling to cope.

Bhatti was shot by men in shawls in broad daylight while he was traveling in a car near a market in the capital, Islamabad, police said. The Pakistani Taliban claimed responsibility for the killing, saying the minister had been "punished" for being a blasphemer.

The windshield of Bhatti's car had four or five bullet holes and blood covered the back seat. His driver, Gul Sher, said at least one gunman had taken part in the attack. A hospital spokesman said Bhatti, who had spoken out against the anti-blasphemy law, received several wounds.

"A white car stopped near us at a crossing," Gul, who was slightly injured, told reporters. "Four people were sitting in the car. One of them got out with a Kalashnikov... He came in front of the car and opened fire. I ducked. Minister died on the spot."

Witnesses said the attackers scattered leaflets signed by "The Qaeda and the Taliban of Punjab" at the attack scene, which read: "This is the punishment of this cursed man."

The blasphemy law has been in the spotlight since last November, when a court sentenced a Christian mother of four to death after her neighbors complained she had insulted Prophet Muhammad.

On January 4, the governor of the most populous province of Punjab, Salman Taseer, who had strongly opposed the law and sought a presidential pardon for the 45-year-old Christian farmhand, was killed by one of his bodyguards who had been angered by the governor's stand.

Taseer's killer was lionized by many in Pakistan, raising fears that mainstream society's tolerance for secularists and moderates was being eroded by a more hardline version of Islam.

"This kind of attack was expected after the government's response to governor Taseer's assassination," said Amir Rana, director at the Pakistan Institute for Peace Studies. "Because of the government's very weak response ... it has encouraged the hardliners in society."

The government of President Asif Ali Zardari has repeatedly said it would not change the blasphemy law, and officials have distanced themselves from anyone calling for amendments.

Al Qaeda-linked Pakistani Taliban militants, fighting to bring down the state, had called for Bhatti's death because of his attempts to amend the law.

"He was a blasphemer like Salman Taseer," spokesman Sajjad Mohmand said by telephone from an undisclosed location.

Prime Minister Yusuf Raza Gilani condemned the killing and ordered the Ministry of Interior to investigate.


Bhatti was traveling without security, having left two police escorts at home, Islamabad police chief Wajid Durrani said.

"There was no protection when he left the house," the police chief said. "There was just a private driver with him. We don't know about the minister's thinking, but we had provided him two escorts because he was under threat."

Last month, in an interview with the Christian Post, Bhatti said he had received threats.

"I received a call from the Taliban commander and he said, 'If you will bring any changes in the blasphemy law and speak on this issue, then you will be killed,'" Bhatti told the newspaper.

"I don't believe that bodyguards can save me after the assassination (of Salman Taseer). I believe in the protection from heaven."

The January killing of Taseer was widely praised by hardline Islamist groups such as the Jamaat-e-Islami (JI), the country's largest religious party.

But the party denounced Bhatti's murder.

"We condemn this killing. This is a conspiracy and it may be an attempt to divert attention from the case of Raymond Davis," senior JI leader Farid Paracha told Reuters.

Davis is an American CIA contractor on trial for killing two Pakistanis. The case has been taken up by religious parties which have called for Davis to be hanged.

Bhatti's killing is likely to further deter any attempt to change the blasphemy law that mandates death for anyone who speaks ill of Islam's Prophet Mohammad.

Sherry Rehman, a former government minister and member of the ruling Pakistan People's Party, of which Bhatti was also a member, tried to change the law last year but the party leadership forced her to stop in the face of opposition.

The murder is sure to reverberate with those in the West concerned about extremism in Pakistan.

John Kerry, the U.S. senator who has been an unofficial envoy for the Obama administration in Pakistan, said the attack on another advocate of moderation was "particularly chilling."

The Vatican called for more protection for religious minorities in the country. Bhatti, a Roman Catholic, met Pope Benedict in Rome last September.

The Anglican Church, the Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams, and the Archbishop of York, John Sentamu, also warned of the impact on Pakistan's religious minorities.

"This further instance of sectarian bigotry and violence will increase anxiety worldwide about the security of Christians and other religious minorities in Pakistan," they said in a statement.

The law has its roots in 19th century colonial legislation to protect places of worship, but it was during the military dictatorship of General Mohammad Zia ul-Haq in the 1980s that it acquired teeth as part of a drive to Islamize the state.

Liberal Pakistanis and rights groups believe the law to be dangerously discriminatory against tiny minority groups.

Under the law, anyone who speaks ill of Islam and the Prophet Mohammad commits a crime and faces the death penalty, but activists say the vague terminology has led to its misuse.

Christians who make up about 2 percent of the population have been especially concerned, saying the law offers them no protection. Convictions hinge on witness testimony and often these are linked to personal vendettas, critics say.

Convictions are common although the death sentence has never been carried out. Most convictions are thrown out on appeal, but mobs have killed many people accused of blasphemy.

(Additional reporting by Rebecca Conway and Zeeshan Haider is Islamabad; Faisal Aziz in Karachi; Missy Ryan in Washington; Editing by Chris Allbritton, Miral Fahmy and Eric Beech)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (11)
“He was the only Christian in the cabinet.” Not anymore.

Tell me again the one about Islam the religion of peace and respect for other.

The fact is the text such as the Quran chapter “THE COW” is the reason for this murder, delete it for clearly, and I am sure Plato would agree with me, a God has no need to vilify other and cause them grevious harm just because they are other, particularly since the same God supposedly created them in the first place.

Plato I am sure would say this text vilifying other was evil made up by humans and not derived from a good God.

Change the text change the outcome otherwise more of the same.

Mar 02, 2011 3:25am EST  --  Report as abuse
opsudrania wrote:
Pakistani Islamic mindset after the most controversial and interntionally denounced law on blasphemy has been used by the muslim majority Sunni community against even the Muslim minorities; save non-Muslim minorities. I should say, even the Sunnis do not spare the other
Sunnis; the best example was massacre of Bengali Sunni Muslim community in 1971 war in the then East Pakistan. Thanks to General Yahya. Salman Taseer murder is another glaring example.

The current turmoil in Middle East and North African Muslim states is another glaring example of Islamic benevolence unmatched with any other
concepts. It is the Muslims killing the Muslims and all of them are Sunnis involved in these fights.

Pakistan is a vassal state thriving on dole money. That is why it does not have teeth but the dubious ideology does not allow them to shade their ego of “superior class and chosen people”.

God bless
Dr. O. P. Sudrania

Mar 02, 2011 4:27am EST  --  Report as abuse
GeoffWard wrote:
Tell me, does this anti-blasphemy law apply to all religions?

And will death be meeted out by Pakistani fundimentalists to politicians that criticise the jewish God, the Christian God, the Buddhist God, the Hindu Gods?

We could end up with a country full of dead politicians.

That would allow the Talibanists to effortlessly take over Pakistan.

Mar 02, 2011 8:22am EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.