Idaho passes Republican bill to curb union rights

CHICAGO Wed Mar 9, 2011 8:03am EST

1 of 8. A woman grabs a picket sign outside of the Capitol building as protestors march against a proposed bill by Republican Governor Scott Walker in Madison, Wisconsin, February 21, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Darren Hauck

Related Topics

CHICAGO (Reuters) - The Idaho state legislature approved a bill on Tuesday to strip public school teachers of many of their collective bargaining rights while protesters in six states rallied against Republican efforts to curb union power.

The Idaho bill, which excludes issues like class size and workloads from negotiations for the state's 12,000 unionized teachers, was given final approval by the Republican-led House and is expected to be signed by Republican Governor Butch Otter.

The bill also eliminates teacher tenure, limits the duration of teacher labor contracts to one year and removes seniority as a factor in determining the order of layoffs.

Idaho is one of several U.S. states to take up Republican plans for sweeping restrictions on public sector unions in what has become a growing national debate over labor union power.

Republicans say the proposals are needed to rescue recession-battered budgets from deficits, but Democrats and union supporters say they are an attack on organized labor that could linger as an issue into the 2012 presidential elections.

Most national attention has focused on the stalemate in Wisconsin over Republican Governor Scott Walker's proposal to curb union rights, which sparked large protests in the capital Madison.

Wisconsin Senate Democrats have fled the state to block a vote on Walker's proposal, but e-mails released on Tuesday showed Walker has indicated he may be willing to compromise on elements of his plan.

The e-mails, released following a Freedom of Information Act request from the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel newspaper, show Senate Democrats and a senior Walker aide discussed some flexibility on issues such as his demand for annual votes to keep unions in existence.

Protests against Walker's plan continued in Madison on Tuesday. Similar Republican plans to curb public union rights and benefits sparked new protests in Indiana, Ohio, Michigan, Iowa and Florida.


In Indianapolis, where most Indiana House Democrats remain out of state to block a vote on a bill they say is anti-worker, union protesters staged a mock "funeral" for the middle class with a New Orleans-style musical procession in honor of Mardi Gras.

In Ohio, Republican Governor John Kasich touted a plan that passed the state Senate last week to curb collective bargaining rights of public employees and ban them from going on strike.

In his "State of the State" speech, Kasich said the bill, which still must be passed by the Ohio House, was necessary to give local governments more flexibility in their budgets.

"Frankly, folks, the provisions of collective bargaining reform are examples of what we want to do to allow people to control their costs," said Kasich, setting off cat-calls from the gallery in the legislative chamber.

Pro-union demonstrators packed the Capitol rotunda after the speech, shouting, "Kill the bill."

In Michigan's state capital Lansing, hundreds of pro-union protesters jammed the rotunda and gathered outside the Capitol to oppose a bill to give emergency authority to break labor contracts to revive failing schools and cities. The state's largest school district of Detroit is under emergency management.

The Michigan House approved the measure in February. A final vote in the Senate, where Republicans hold a 26-12 majority, is expected on Wednesday.

In Iowa, hundreds of union workers crowded the state House chamber to protest a bill that would prevent negotiations on healthcare benefits for government workers and forbid union workers from negotiating layoff schedules.

The measure will be debated in the Republican-led Iowa House on Wednesday. It is expected to run into trouble in the Democratic-majority state Senate.

In Florida, facing a $3.6 billion budget deficit, union supporters held events in a number of cities as lawmakers returned to state capital Tallahassee to begin the 2001 legislative session.

In Tallahassee several hundred union backers took up positions across the street from the capitol building, where a few hundred conservative Tea Party members and their supporters held a counter rally. The two factions are expected to play major roles as lawmakers deal with the deficit.

Republican Governor Rick Scott has called for significant tax cuts on businesses and property owners while asking lawmakers to require state employees to pay 5 percent of their salaries toward their retirement plan. Florida now does not require an employee contribution.

Scott also wants new employees funneled into a 401(k)-type retirement plan instead of the traditional pension now offered to members of the Florida Retirement System.

(Additional reporting by Kay Henderson, David Bailey, Andrew Stern, Jim Leckrone, Susan Guyett, Laura Zuckerman and Michael Peltier; Editing by John Whitesides)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (25)
paulflorez wrote:
Classic Republican Overreach, robbing the middle class of their right to negotiate collectively. Corporations can pour unlimited amounts of dollars into elections to get the corporate candidate to win and drain every last drop of blood from the middle class, but the middle class is not allowed to unite and negotiate for better pay.

Polls show majority of Americans oppose this, yet Republicans still push ahead.

Mar 08, 2011 8:02pm EST  --  Report as abuse
chingon wrote:
Never forget. You want to live like a republican? vote democrat. You want to live like a democrat vote republican. Republicans lured the people with trying to take the country back.
They are taking it back and more of the rights of the employees to benefit billionaires.
Shouldn’t we be flooded with jobs that coorporations were going to create with all of the tax cuts they received?
Billions in profits are staying idle. Coorporate greed.
Next election another campaign for the simple mind, abortion (again) and gay marriage (again).

Mar 08, 2011 8:13pm EST  --  Report as abuse
NobleKin wrote:
This is not an overreach, it is a deliberate power grab intended to further strengthen the dominance corporations hold in controlling US elections.

Americans may oppose this draconian governance, but there is not enough being done to stop it.

At what price? Freedom? Democracy? Civil Rights?

The Republi-con-artists have already ensured corporations can have an anonymous hand in every future election, without limit. To what end?

Now they work to take away the last ballast keeping them from controlling every future election in America by crippling unions (and union voting power) across America. Again, to what end?

Mar 08, 2011 8:25pm EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.