Chernobyl clean-up expert slams Japan, IAEA

VIENNA Tue Mar 15, 2011 12:49pm EDT

VIENNA (Reuters) - Greed in the nuclear industry and corporate influence over the U.N. watchdog for atomic energy may doom Japan to a spreading nuclear disaster, one of the men brought in to clean up Chernobyl said on Tuesday.

Slamming the Japanese response at Fukushima, Russian nuclear accident specialist Iouli Andreev accused corporations and the United Nations' International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) of wilfully ignoring lessons from the world's worst nuclear accident 25 years ago to protect the industry's expansion.

"After Chernobyl all the force of the nuclear industry was directed to hide this event, for not creating damage to their reputation. The Chernobyl experience was not studied properly because who has money for studying? Only industry.

"But industry doesn't like it," he said in an interview in Vienna where the former director of the Soviet Spetsatom clean-up agency now teaches and advises on nuclear safety. Austria's environment ministry has used him as an adviser.

Andreev said a fire which released radiation on Tuesday involving spent fuel rods stored close to reactors at Fukushima looked like an example of putting profit before safety:

"The Japanese were very greedy and they used every square inch of the space. But when you have a dense placing of spent fuel in the basin you have a high possibility of fire if the water is removed from the basin," Andreev said.

The IAEA should share blame for standards, he said, arguing it was too close to corporations building and running plants. And he dismissed an emergency incident team set up by the Vienna-based agency as "only a think-tank not a working force":

"This is only a fake organisation because every organisation which depends on the nuclear industry -- and the IAEA depends on the nuclear industry -- cannot perform properly.

"It always will try to hide the reality.

"The IAEA ... is not interested in the concentration of attention on a possible accident in the nuclear industry. They are totally not interested in all the emergency organisations."

The IAEA had no immediate comment on Andreev's criticism.

Andreev said he understood all too well what the Japanese authorities in Fukushima were going through, and that creative solutions would be needed to contain the leaks.

"It is a situation of quiet panic. I know this situation," he said. "Discipline is the main thing in the industry but the emergency service requires creativity, requires some kind of even fantasy and improvisation."

(Editing by Alastair Macdonald)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (7)
zenduane wrote:
How ironic. We used to assume that Russians were not telling the truth. Now it appears as if Iouli Andreev is the only one who is.

Mar 15, 2011 1:27pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
bezalel99 wrote:
Forget about “dense placing of spent fuel in the basin.” Those spent fuel pools were originally intended to hold spent fuel for a short period of time, until they could be transferred off-site for permanent disposal. That could mean reprocessing, as is done in France, or burial as envisioned in the U.S. Unfortunately, the U.S. Federal government has been unable to develop a permanent burial site, as every state refuses to host it. Thus, the spent fuel remains at the nuclear plants indefinitely, waiting for a similar catastrophe.

Mar 15, 2011 1:38pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
Dan_Kolis wrote:
I said a thousand times: Even if you don’t like nuclear power, let the SOB’s move waste a few city blocks … anywhere else but in in the core work area. Here in Ontario, you can barely walk around in the reactors as there packed like a little old lady’s attic full of waste.

All these work to rule guys with there fault ladder diagrams, showing how many billion hours and million’s of years will go past without an incident. Where are those guys now?

Mar 15, 2011 1:39pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.