California still leads U.S., including in inequality

SAN FRANCISCO Thu May 19, 2011 7:23pm EDT

A man hangs California's state flag in Nevada City, California in this May 16, 2011 file photo. REUTERS/Max Whittaker

A man hangs California's state flag in Nevada City, California in this May 16, 2011 file photo.

Credit: Reuters/Max Whittaker

Related Topics

SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - Perennial trend-setter California still represents potential aspects of the future of the United States, ranging from wealth and opportunity in Silicon Valley to abject poverty in the agricultural Central Valley.

The Golden State has always seen itself as the best, and it still is for some, but a new study of federal census and state data covering longevity, education and income shows the state is also home to arguably the worst-off parts of the nation.

Its diversity, continued attraction to immigrants, and a fast-changing economy that is still the world's eighth largest make it a harbinger for the globe as well as the nation, according to the study released this week.

"Some Californians are actually enjoying the highest levels of well-being in the world, where the rest of the world won't be for another half-century," said Kristen Lewis, one of the authors of "A Portrait of California."

But the report by the American Human Development Project, which uses United Nations-based indicators of health, wealth and education rolled into a Human Development Index score, also sheds light on less fortunate parts of the state. (here)

The Los Angeles neighborhood of Watts, which exploded in riots in 1965, only now scores at levels enjoyed by the rest of the county that year, while a companion study found the nation's worst-off congressional district to be in Fresno, California -- not the Mississippi Delta or Appalachia as researchers had expected.

The reputation of the most populous U.S. state as home of the good life has been tarnished as the mortgage crisis stripped families of homes, while the state's financial problems have undermined the education system and sense of opportunity that gave California its glittering reputation.

Many of the contrasts in the state, which after all has inspired "Grapes of Wrath" Depression-era tales as well as Disneyland, are tied in some way to education and immigration.


Education and income tend to go hand in hand, but some of the longest-living Californians are Latino immigrants at the bottom of the pay and education scales -- whose native-born children die earlier.

"The longer Latinos live in the United States, the shorter they live," Lewis said.

The report breaks down the state into "Five Californias." They range from the affluent towns of Silicon Valley, such as Cupertino, home to Apple Inc, and Mountain View, where Google Inc is based, followed by well-off metropolitan coastal enclaves.

A group of mostly minority citizens in California's suburbs and exurbs make up the middle class, or about 40 percent of the population. An equally large group that also includes rural areas is labeled "Struggling California." Both are trying to fit into a state that wants highly skilled or unskilled labor, without much demand in the middle.

"All over the U.S., the labor market is diverging, and it's creating an hourglass shape," Lewis said.

A "Forsaken" 5 percent, whose life expectancy is nine years less than those at the top and who tend to live in impoverished neighborhoods in Los Angeles and the farming-dependent Central Valley, make up the bottom stratus in the state.

In the San Francisco Bay Area town of San Ramon, only 2.6 percent of adult residents did not finish high school, compared with 63.3 percent in the Vernon Central area of Los Angeles.

The top and bottom groups have one thing in common: a third of each was born outside the United States. But while the top demographic features engineers from Asia, the bottom contains mainly Latinos with a high school education or less.

Measures of state public education have dropped because of the financial crisis to the point where California in some ways now ranks 49th to 51st against other states and the District of Columbia.

"California is really losing its edge in terms of education," said Lewis.

But the statistics don't necessarily tell the whole story -- many Latino immigrants drag down the state average because they cut short their education to come to California, but their children are hitting state norms.

(Reporting by Peter Henderson; Editing by Eric Walsh)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (9)
Yakes wrote:
More like Mexico every day.

A few very rich and everybody else living in extreme poverty.

May 19, 2011 11:31pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
Ralphooo wrote:
This is a well-considered, well-written start at describing and California’s current condition. A number of points are brought into focus. It is most informative.

There is, of course, ever so much more to be written. A book-length survey, in just this style, from San Diego to Big Sur to Mt. Shasta, looking with open eyes at the very best and the very worst, without ideology or political agenda, would mean a great deal right now. Such a book could be a splendid antidote to the self-interested blather that currently passes for social analysis.

Author, please write this! Remind us, should you be game for the assignment, of who and what we have become on this long journey that is the beautiful State of California.

May 19, 2011 12:27am EDT  --  Report as abuse
crackmonkey wrote:
I was born and grew up in California. I saw the state go from a vibrate opportunity laden wonderland to the wasteland it is quickly becoming. The primary problems with California are 1) Corrupt Politicians, 2) Corrupt Unions, 3) Sanctuary cities, and 4) Entitlement minded minority and underclass population. There are too many people demanding handouts and too many liberals will to destroy the whole society in order to help a few people who are not willing to help themselves. In the past 100 years almost every major problem the state and the country have had can be traced back to government interference.

May 20, 2011 2:10am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.