Groups threaten to sue government over bat disease

SALMON, Idaho Thu May 26, 2011 9:36am EDT

Related Topics

SALMON, Idaho (Reuters) - Conservation and organic farming groups alarmed by the spread of a disease decimating bats on Wednesday threatened to sue the U.S. government within 30 days unless it immediately closes caves and abandoned mines on public lands.

White-nose syndrome, named for the telltale fungus that appears on the muzzles of bats, has killed more than a million bats in the eastern United States since its discovery in upstate New York in 2006, according to government research.

The fungus has been detected in 19 states across the northeast and mid-Atlantic regions. Scientists say it is only a matter of time before it spreads westward to infect bats that hibernate in caves and abandoned mines.

"We're facing a number of bat species probably going extinct within a few decades if things don't change," said Mollie Matteson, advocate for the Center for Biological Diversity, the lead group behind the threatened lawsuit.

The fungus is mostly transmitted from bat to bat. But government biologists say it also can be transferred by caving enthusiasts and others whose underground explorations may bring them into contact with infected bats or with the spores left behind after white-nose syndrome killed off a colony.

Government land managers have already closed caves and abandoned mines in most states east of the Mississippi.

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has recommended cutting off access to caves in states where the fungus has been detected as well as adjacent states. But it has stopped short of advising nationwide closures.

The groups contend piecemeal closures are inadequate to address what the government itself has described as an unprecedented wildlife disease that is expected to infect colonies in the West and Pacific Northwest.

Organic farming groups behind the proposed action say the syndrome could devastate their industry along with the bats.

The pest-control benefits of insect-eating bats are estimated to save agriculture in the United States from $3.7 billion to $53 billion a year, according to a recent study by Boston University and other scientists.

Closures - including proposals now under consideration on public forest lands in Montana and northern Idaho - have been hotly contested by cavers, with 10,000 members and 250 caving clubs organized under the National Speleological Society.

Mike McEachern, head of the Northern Rocky Mountain Grotto, a caving club, said those organizations are committed to preserving caves and the bats that inhabit them. But he predicted a debate over closing caves would be contentious.

"Most of the caves in the West are on federal property and asking to close all caves is like asking the government to close the ocean," McEachern said.

Ann Froschauer, national white-nose syndrome spokeswoman for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, said the government is scrambling to gather the science that may help combat the killer bat disease.

"We're looking at potentially losing over half of our bat species; we're trying not to create a new potential epicenter out West," she said.

(Editing by Dan Whitcomb and Greg McCune)

Corrects to "abandoned" from "abandons" in first paragraph

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (4)
Botwarble wrote:
Republicans in the US have done everything they can to underfund the US Fish and Wildlife Service, and closing caves now, even those on private land, will be too late. The USFWS should have done this over a decade ago to try to save so many species of endangered bats, yet only drug their feet. They could at least admit this disease was carried from Europe by a caver (the cause of all the problems)who then infected the first cave in NY. Caves are like coral reefs and you don’t touch coral reefs without negative effects, so stay the F out of caves unless you are a qualified researcher conducting funded research. Spunks are punks that are the primary cause of all bat decline.

May 26, 2011 2:33pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
Utana wrote:
This is completely counterproductive! People don’t spread this WNS, bats do. Probably started when a contaminated bat (or more likely several bats) took a ride on a boat from Europe to New England. That’s how most of these types of things get spread over seas. Now the CBD wants to stop all cave access from humans, and in the process they will alienate cavers (cave scientists, researchers, and enthusiasts) the very people who are the most knowledgeable about how to potentially combat WNS.

May 26, 2011 4:01pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
Botwarble wrote:
Utana, put your pipe down, or maybe get out of your cave more often. 1.) Humans can and do spread WNS. In fact, it is stated in the article above that you apparently did not read. And, NY officials originally stated human caver was the likely cause when the first case was reported. This has been hushed since. 3.) Your daydream that a couple (?seriously?)bats made their way into a ship, flew around for a few weeks on board, then disembarked to make their way from the coast to a NY cave is not worthy of comment. 4.) Cavers are aliens to cave environments. That is a fact. 5.) Cave scientists, researchers and, hah, cave enthusiasts, are not even in the game when it comes to this research, which has been most successfully investigated by fungal ecologists and mathematical biologists. It’s no longer even funny that the only people that ever cry about closing caves to cavers are cavers. We think you’ve made your presence felt, even prior to WNS.

May 26, 2011 4:49pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.