Little room seen for SAfrica to appeal Wal-Mart OK

Wed Jun 1, 2011 10:38am EDT

* Govt, unions may appeal antitrust ruling

* Massmart shares, rand point to deal going through

* Wal-Mart "100 pct" committed to sealing deal

By Tiisetso Motsoeneng and Mmathabo Tladi

JOHANNESBURG, June 1 (Reuters) - South Africa has little room to fight its own regulators over the approval of Wal-Mart's (WMT.N) $2.4 billion bid for control of local retailer Massmart (MSMJ.J), lawyers said on Wednesday.

South Africa's Competition Tribunal approved the U.S. firm's acquisition of Massmart with minimal conditions on Tuesday, prompting three government departments that opposed the deal to warn they could consider an appeal.

But such a legal move is unlikely, said Lulama Mtanga, a director at law firm Bowman Gilfillan.

"All the government departments who opposed the merger cannot take their argument any further," she said.

"It is, therefore, the end of the road for these parties."

The departments of economic development, trade and industry, and forestry and fisheries said in a joint statement they would need further study to determine whether the conditions imposed on Wal-Mart -- such as a two-year freeze on job cuts -- were sufficient to prevent widespread job losses.

"Based on the outcome of the study of the conditions and the responses of Wal-Mart/Massmart, we will decide on the next steps to take. Government reserves its legal options at this stage," the departments said.

Alexis Apostolidis, head of Competition Law at law firm Adams & Adams said the government would first have to prove to a court that it has the right to an appeal.

"If they choose to appeal ... it would be opposed on the basis that they don't have locus standi," he said, referring to the right to address a court on a matter.

UNION CHANCE

But South Africa's powerful unions, which also opposed the deal and are considering their own appeals, may have a better chance at legal action, experts said.

"Only the merging parties and trade unions or employees can take a merger on appeal to the Competition Appeal Court," Mtanga said.

Any appeal could delay the deal first announced in September last year and but it is unlikely to put off Wal-Mart's first foray in what should be a bright growth spot on the map, analysts said.

Shares in Massmart (MSMJ.J) were up 0.73 percent at 143.60 rand as of 1429 GMT, holding on to Tuesday's gains when the competition authorities gave the deal a nod and underscoring investors' optimism that deal is near completion.

"Obviously you can never be 100 percent sure about these things, but the reports that have come out are not enough to suggest that the deal is at risk," Martin Lentsoane, a trader at NEWS Trading said.

"The market is telling you that the deal will go through."

The rand currency ZAR=D3 extended recent gains to a three week high of 6.7720 against the dollar on Wednesday, partly on expectations of foreign currency inflows from the acquisition.

Wal-Mart's head of international operations Doug McMillon said on Tuesday he hoped to finalise the acquisition in the next few weeks.

The deal was a test case for major foreign investment in South Africa, which has the continent's deepest capital markets but where unions are in a coalition with the ruling African National Congress.

A government appeal could shake investor confidence in Africa's top economy, some analysts have said.

"I struggle to understand or come to terms with government. Are they anti-business?" said David Shapiro, a fund manager at Sasfin Holdings. (Editing by David Dolan and David Cowell)

Related Quotes and News

Company
Price
Related News
We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (1)
Llewellynww wrote:
This is not what South Africa needs right now. Its amazing how we can not look down the road. So i will break it down simply. Imagine your favorite Proudly south african products, Mrs Balls, Koo, All Gold, Knor, Nola…and the list goes on. You can say goodbye to all these delicious products. These companies will all go bankrupt before you realize it. Our proud history as South Africans will be lost because if a greedy few. When are we going to stand up to these bullies. When…..

Jun 01, 2011 4:55pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.