Egypt recalls envoy from Israel over deaths

CAIRO Sat Aug 20, 2011 5:30pm EDT

1 of 2. The Egyptian national flag can be seen on the roof of the Egypt embassy in Tel Aviv August 20, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/ Nir Elias

Related Video

Related News

Related Topics

CAIRO (Reuters) - Egypt said Saturday it would withdraw its ambassador from Israel, insisting the killing of five Egyptian security personnel while Israeli forces pursued gunmen across the border was a breach of its 1979 peace treaty with the Jewish state.

Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak said Israel regretted the Egyptian deaths, which followed attacks in its border area that had killed eight people and sparked the most serious crisis in ties with Egypt since Hosni Mubarak's overthrow in February.

"We hope that the ambassador will not be recalled," said Yigal Palmor, an Israeli Foreign Ministry spokesman. "He's still here."

Egypt's Foreign Ministry later called in the Israeli charge d'affairs, delivered a protest and demanded a joint investigation into the deaths, the state MENA news agency said.

It said the Israeli diplomat told Egyptian officials he had been asked by his government to read Barak's statement at the Foreign Ministry. The agency said the charge d'affairs was summoned because the Israeli ambassador was not in Cairo.

The Egyptian cabinet decision followed a crisis meeting attended by army generals and intelligence chief Murad Muwafi.

Egypt "lays on Israel the political and legal responsibility for this incident, which constitutes a breach of the peace treaty between Egypt and Israel," the cabinet said in an official statement posted on its website.

"The cabinet committee has decided to withdraw the Egyptian ambassador in Israel until the result of investigations by the Israeli authorities is provided and an apology from the Israeli leadership over the hasty and regrettable statements about Egypt is given," the cabinet statement said.


The statement was later removed from the website, prompting speculation that Cairo may have retracted its decision. An Egyptian government spokesman said the cabinet stood by statements made by its information minister, but declined to make any reference to the recall of the ambassador, which was also reported by state media.

Barak expressed regret over the Egyptian deaths and said he had instructed the Israeli army to conduct a joint investigation with Egypt.

Israel pinned the blame for Thursday's border attack on a Gaza-based Palestinian faction, independent of Gaza's ruling Islamist Hamas, which it said had infiltrated Israel via Egypt's Sinai desert.

Israeli forces killed the faction's leadership in an air strike in Gaza Thursday and launched more than a dozen more raids Friday.

Palestinian militants fired at least 50 rockets at Israel from the Gaza Strip Saturday. An Israeli man was killed and at least seven other people were injured by rockets.

Egypt's Foreign Minister Mohamed Kamel Amr said Egypt was "following with deep concern the escalation by the Israeli army against the Gaza Strip, in which innocent civilian casualties had fallen," and urged Israel to stop its operations.

The Cairo-based Arab League said it would hold an urgent meeting Sunday to discuss Israeli air strikes on Gaza that killed 15 Palestinians.


Emad Gad, senior researcher at Cairo's Al-Ahram Center for Political and Strategic Studies, said neither Egypt nor Israel was keen to escalate the issue further. "Withdrawing the Egyptian ambassador is a good step but Egypt still has to insist on a formal apology from Israel," he said.

Hundreds of Egyptians protested outside the Israeli embassy in Cairo Saturday. Earlier, thousands protested overnight burning Israeli flags, tearing down metal barriers and demanding the expulsion of the Israeli envoy.

Protesters say they will continue demonstrating until Egypt expels the Israeli ambassador, saying the steps taken so far are not enough, according to state TV reports.

A senior Israeli defense official earlier said Israel was keen to maintain its peace treaty with Egypt.

"One thing is sure, there is not a single person in Israel who wants to harm an Egyptian policeman or soldiers," Amos Gilad said on Israel Radio. He said an investigation had not yet determined who killed the Egyptian security personnel.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had been consulting cabinet ministers about a response, said an official who asked not to be named, referring to relations with Egypt.

Egypt has recalled its ambassador in Tel Aviv on previous occasions, including Israel's 1982 invasion of Lebanon and heavy Israeli shelling of the Gaza Strip in 2000.


Israel has expressed concern about security in the Sinai desert despite intensified efforts by Egyptian security to root out Islamist radicals.

Cairo rejected charges it had lost control of Sinai and said

Israel was blaming Egypt for its own security failings.

Egypt will take every precaution to secure its border with Israel to deter any infiltrators, and to respond to any Israeli military activity toward the Egyptian border, it added.

Sinai forms a buffer zone between the rest of Egypt and Israel. Parts of their mountainous border remain porous.

An official in Egypt's Suez Canal authority said the waterway was operating normally.

The number of troops Egypt can deploy in the Sinai is limited under the peace treaty signed with Israel in 1979 after the two countries had fought four wars since 1948.

In 1994 Jordan became the only other Arab country to sign a peace treaty with Israel.

(Additional reporting by Yasmine Saleh and Omar Fahmy in Cairo, Yusri Mohamed in Ismailia and Allyn Fisher-Ilan in Jerusalem; Editing by Sami Aboudi and Andrew Roche)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (4)
SanPa wrote:
The US needs to show support of Egypt. No $5 billion military aid packages to Ireal this year. That will put a dent in their subsidized national healthcare plan, and encourage them to use diplomatic channels [like the US uses with its neighbors, like Canada].

Aug 20, 2011 3:36pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
EN3 wrote:
Israel is only defending itself, Egypt needs to remember that. Yes there is a new government in Egypt but america cannot and will not condone any nation supporting terrorism. Especially against a long term ally like Israel.

Aug 20, 2011 4:48pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
Eideard wrote:
“Barak expressed regret over the Egyptian deaths” Mail me a penny postcard when Barak expresses regret over all the other innocent people murdered by Israel in the quest for Lebensraum.

Aug 20, 2011 8:08pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.