China state paper urges Internet rethink to gag foes

BEIJING Fri Sep 2, 2011 6:23pm EDT

Customers use computers at an internet cafe in Hefei, Anhui province, January 25, 2010. REUTERS/Stringer

Customers use computers at an internet cafe in Hefei, Anhui province, January 25, 2010.

Credit: Reuters/Stringer

Related Topics

BEIJING (Reuters) - China's Communist Party control is at risk unless the government takes firmer steps to stop Internet opinion being shaped by increasingly organized political foes, a team of party writers warned in a commentary published on Friday.

The long commentary in the overseas edition of the People's Daily, the main newspaper of China's ruling Communist Party, added to signs that Beijing, jolted by the growing audience and influence of Twitter-like microblogging websites, is weighing fresh ways to tame and channel online opinion.

Chinese officials and media have recently complained about the spread of damaging and unfounded "rumors" on the Internet. [ID:nL4E7JU152] But this commentary raised the political stakes by arguing that organized, subversive opponents are exploiting tardy regulation to inflame opinion and spread their views.

The commentary urged changes in how China controls Internet innovations.

"Internet opinion is spontaneous, but increasingly shows signs of becoming organized," said the commentary, written by a team of writers for the Communist Party's top theoretical journal, "Qiushi," which means "Seeking Truth."

"Among the many controversies stirred up on the Internet, many are organized, with goals and meticulous planning and direction, and some clearly have commercial interests or political intentions in the background," said the commentary.

"Unless administration is vigorous, criminal forces, hostile forces, terrorist organizations and others could manipulate public sentiment by manufacturing bogus opinion on the Internet, damaging social stability and national security."

A commentary in the People's Daily does not amount to a government policy pronouncement, and indeed this one may reflect a more conservative current in official debate. But it adds to signals that Beijing is leaning to tougher controls.

China already heavily filters the Internet, and blocks popular foreign sites such as Facebook, YouTube and Twitter.

The People's Daily commentary did not single out the explosive growth of microblog, or "weibo," users, who reached 195 million by the end of June, an increase of 209 percent on the number at the end of 2010.

But a preface to the newspaper commentary singled out a recent string of public uproars that have spread through microblogs, especially the "Weibo" site of Sina Corp, which dominates the sector in China.

Those uproars included a bullet train crash in July that drew outrage aimed at government officials over evasive statements, safety failures and the feverish expansion of high-speed rail.


That sort of growth is a key reason why investors remain cautiously optimistic -- for the long term -- on Internet and social-media players such as Sina, Tencent and RenRen Inc, billed as a Chinese version of Facebook.

Wall Street hopes that rapid growth in mobile and social-media adoption in -- the world's second-largest Internet market and already the biggest social-media playground by users -- will offset persistent fears about a widespread crackdown on Weibo or other rapidly expanding media.

Sina's shares on the Nasdaq slid more than 3 percent to $100.95 in afternoon trading, while RenRen was off 1 percent.

"The concern is valid, but the probability is low. The social media market has grown to such a size that it is almost impossible for government to shut down all the platforms," CLSA's head of telecoms and Internet research Asia, Elinor Leung, argued in a Thursday report on the industry.

Various government agencies in fact employ Weibo, she said, much like Twitter is used as a communications tool in the United States.

"The government is likely to continue to rely on Internet companies to curtail rumors and sensitive information, rather than suppress them."

Sina and other Chinese microblog operators already deploy technicians and software to monitor content, and block and remove comments deemed unacceptable, especially about protests, scandals and party leaders. But the torrent of information and combative views can be hard to tame.

"In Internet battles, usually negative views crush positive ones," said the People's Daily, adding that extreme online opinion abounded with "unvarying suspicion of government policies, official statements, mainstream viewpoints, the social elite and the well-off."

Officially, at least, Sina's Weibo and other Chinese microblog sites are still in "trial" mode.

In comment's that appeared aimed at such microblogs, the People's Daily commentary said the Chinese government had shot itself in the foot by letting Internet technologies take off and win huge followings before effective control was in place.

That must change, it said.

"We have failed to take into sufficient account just how much the Internet is a double-edged sword, and have a problem of allowing technology to advance while administration and regulation lag," said the commentary.

Once the government tries to control an Internet technology that has already become popular, it faces "fierce resistance and a backlash" from users, and also international criticism, said the newspaper.

"Clearly, in the future when developing and applying new Internet technologies, there must first be a thorough assessment, adopting even more prudent policies and enhancing foresight and forward thinking in administration," it said.

(Editing by Nick Macfie)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (12)
Less1leg wrote:
The greatest thing a government can do is tolerate its own peoples opposition to its leadership. A one party lead country can no more represent its people than a tyrant. China would be better served adjusting to a new world where an Opposition Party is inevitably going to happen. For China to actually grow up and be a successful managed country in a new world. It has to evolve, including Opposition election parties or party to discuss grievances. Its healthy and productive for a nation and a world to see opposition from within a country. Without confrontational government we outside of China or One Party countries only speculate that Generals of militaristic intent rule over the masses and might use force to gain dominance over its surounding areas.

Sep 02, 2011 9:07pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
Al123 wrote:
Chicom dudes: your real enemy is time. Try stopping it, or rolling back societal changes – good luck. Every day, your population gets richer, more educated, and more tech. Soon enough they will be uncontrollable because you no longer control the information to any real extent. You can’t pair autocracy and economic freedom, which is a lesson you will find out very, very soon.

Sep 02, 2011 9:20pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
Panmumu wrote:
As a person living behind the “great firewall”, I feel I must remind you that what is good for one people is not good for the rest of the world’s countries. I also know that Americans or any one else does not like other people sticking their noses into their business, however much one might agree with the comment. America has some 333,000,000+or- people China has close to five times that. Can you picture this many people? Can you picture them polarized like America is right now. A person once said be careful of what you wish for you may get it. Obama certainly keep one promise, he fundamentally changed America. An Expat.

Sep 03, 2011 6:48am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.