Analysis: Bachmann vaccine comments toxic, doctors say

CHICAGO Thu Sep 15, 2011 5:38pm EDT

Rep. Michele Bachmann participates in the CNN/Tea Party Republican presidential candidates debate in Tampa, Florida, September 12, 2011. REUTERS/Scott Audette

Rep. Michele Bachmann participates in the CNN/Tea Party Republican presidential candidates debate in Tampa, Florida, September 12, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Scott Audette

CHICAGO (Reuters) - No matter how much the U.S. medical community repudiates the suggestion by presidential candidate Michele Bachmann that a vaccine for human papillomavirus (HPV) is dangerous, doctors fear the damage has already been done.

Physicians are bracing for more parents to refuse the HPV vaccine, which protects against the most common cause of cervical cancer, for their daughters.

They say the comments by the Republican candidate will only stoke growing and unfounded fears about a whole class of common immunizations needed to fight disease.

"There are people out there who, because of this kind of misinformation, aren't going to get their daughter immunized," said Dr. Kenneth Alexander, a pediatric infectious disease expert at the University of Chicago Medical Center.

"As a result, there will be more people who die from cervical cancer," Alexander said in a telephone interview.

Dr. Mary Anne Jackson, an infectious disease expert at Children's Mercy Hospital & Clinics in Kansas City, Missouri, said doctors are already struggling to convince parents to immunize girls against HPV, a sexually transmitted virus.

"There will be repercussions of this comment that will directly impact every provider who takes care of adolescents and young women," Jackson said in a telephone interview.

Bachmann first raised the issue during a Republican presidential debate on Monday as a swipe at Republican rival and Texas Governor Rick Perry, who issued an executive order in 2007 mandating girls get the HPV vaccine as part of a school immunization requirement. The order was later overturned.

In that forum, she questioned the state's authority to force "innocent little 12-year-old girls" to have a "government injection" that was "potentially dangerous."

The following day, she told NBC's "Today" show the story of a woman from Tampa, Florida, who approached her after the debate and said her daughter became "mentally retarded" after getting the Gardasil vaccine made by Merck.

Physician groups including the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) rushed out statements defending the safety of Merck's vaccine and Cervarix made by GlaxoSmithKline, whose most common side effects include a sore arm, a rash and fever.

As a measure of their incredulity over Bachmann's comments, two bioethicists are offering rewards, one of more than $10,000, if she can bring forward the child who suffered irreparable damage.


The AAP says there is absolutely no scientific validity to Bachmann's statement that the HPV vaccine is potentially dangerous.

"Since the vaccine has been introduced (in 2006), more than 35 million doses have been administered, and it has an excellent safety record," Dr. O. Marion Burton, president of the American Academy of Pediatrics, said in a statement.

But no amount of proof will suffice for some families, who fear that even a small percentage of children may be harmed.

"I recently had a mother who had cervical cancer who refused the HPV vaccine for her child," Jackson said. "I asked her where she got her information and she said, 'the Internet, and innuendo.'"

That may help explain the slow uptake of the HPV vaccine. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, only 32 percent of adolescent girls last year had gotten all three shots of the HPV vaccine.

"We've got 12,000 women a year in this country getting cervical cancer. The vaccine could prevent about 70 percent of that," Alexander said.

Vaccine fears have already fueled recent outbreaks of measles, mumps and whooping cough, according to the CDC.

Much of the fear stemmed from a study by Dr. Andrew Wakefield, the now-disgraced British doctor who researchers believe falsified data for a 1998 study which convinced thousands of parents that vaccines are dangerous.

Concerns that vaccines might cause autism have not only caused parents to skip vaccinating their children, but also forced costly reformulations of many vaccines.

Bachmann's suggestion that the HPV vaccine may be linked with "mental retardation" only feeds into those fears.

"What is especially disturbing is you've got organizations like the American Academy of Pediatrics, the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, the American Academy of Family Physicians and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists -- every learned medical organization in the country and indeed around the world -- in favor of immunization," Alexander of the University of Chicago said.

Jackson said when presented with information about the HPV vaccine, about 85 percent of families decide to have their child vaccinated, about 12 percent are hesitant, and the rest are "flat-out refusers."

It's the families in that 12 percent she is worried about.

"It's not going to impact the flat-out refusers. I worry it is going to impact this group of vaccine-hesitant families."

(Editing by Michele Gershberg and Xavier Briand)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (48)
jprestr wrote:
Michelle Bachmann needs to support her words with proof. She is just like a lot of Politicians in throwing out statements that have no basis and then so many people believe without investigating. I will no longer believe in what Michelle Bachmann says-she has lost my trust. I have a daughter who developed Ca of the Cervix from HPV virus. She ended up having a cone and then a hysterectomy from uncontrolled bleeding. I wish they would have had the vaccine when she was a teenager. My granddaughters will definitely get the vaccine.

Sep 15, 2011 4:45pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
RickyRiter wrote:
Lest people around the world believe that it is only fat trailer park mommas who are fundamentally ignorant, they need look no further than this prize specimen from Minnesota. Shame on the greed for power that causes people to utter such harmful rubbish.

Sep 15, 2011 4:52pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
TyroneJ wrote:
Why anyone listens to Bachmann is beyond me. She’s a fraud through and through. She & her husband take government subsidies claiming they have a farm. Her husband has taken tons of government money for his “clinic”. She went to a Law School that lost it’s accreditation it was so bad. The two years she “worked” for the IRS, she was really only working a couple of months as she took two paid maternity leaves in two years. Yet she rallies against “big government” and pretends she’s above being on the dole. And she’s so stupid about medicine that she’d condemn her own daughters to die of cervical cancer, which is caused by the virus this vaccine protects against. Only ignorant people waste their time listening to her.

Sep 15, 2011 4:58pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.