SGX, LSE tying up for London Metal Exchange bid: source

HONG KONG Fri Sep 30, 2011 10:33am EDT

Clerks at work at the London Metal Exchange, London, July 22, 2011. REUTERS/Paul Hackett

Clerks at work at the London Metal Exchange, London, July 22, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Paul Hackett

Related Video

Related Topics

HONG KONG (Reuters) - The Singapore Exchange Ltd (SGXL.SI) is tying up with London's main bourse to make a joint bid for the London Metal Exchange, a source told Reuters on Friday, as the world's largest metal market seeks a suitor in a deal that could be worth 1 billion pounds ($1.57 billion).

The consortium has appointed a bank to advise it on the bid, said the source, who had direct knowledge of the deal, with the auction expected to attract rival offers.

The joint bid underscores the ambitions of both exchanges to diversify into the fast-growing space of metals trading, as traditional businesses of equity and derivatives trading faces increasing competition.

Both the SGX and the LSE are coming off failed merger attempts amid a flurry of exchange auctions that were prompted by loss of market share across the industry to alternative trading venues.

"This is a joint bid, so I guess SGX would have learned some lessons from the ASX bid," said Roger Tan, managing director at SIAS Research in Singapore.

SGX, led by experienced dealmaker Magnus Bocker, has been trying to raise the profile of Asia's second-largest listed bourse and compete against its larger rival in Hong Kong.

Bocker was the man who stitched together seven Nordic bourses to create OMX, later sold to NASDAQ (NDAQ.O). (For a Newsmaker on Bocker.

But his attempts to buy ASX Ltd (ASX.AX) was rejected by the Australian government five months ago.

"To a certain extent, there is some necessity for SGX to try to grow both organically and by M&A. LME has proven over the years to be a credible exchange. If anyone is able to acquire the platform, then it will be able to use the platform to expand its own business," Tan added.

SGX shares fell 1.3 percent to S$6.63, giving it a market value of about $5.6 billion. LSE (LSE.L) shares were down 1.4 percent, valuing the company at about $3.5 billion.

LME's pre-tax profit in 2010 fell 28 percent to 12.5 million pounds. Still the exchange's pre-eminent position in the world of metals trading will make it a much sought after asset.

"But since LME is already an established arena, it won't come cheap," Tan added.

SGX has been expanding its suite of commodity products, particularly industrial metals. In February, SGX launched small-size, cash-settled metal futures in partnership with the LME, hoping to carve out a niche in a market already crowded with competing and sometimes underused equivalents.

But the copper, aluminum and zinc mini-contracts, one fifth the size of the standard LME product, have been struggling to find an audience, with trading volumes thin since the launch.

OTHER SUITORS

The LME, the world's biggest market for industrial metals, said last week that it was considering a sale, with an expected price tag of around 1 billion pounds ($1.57 billion). Chief Executive Martin Abbott told Reuters on Thursday more than nine potential suitors have shown an interest in acquiring LME.

SGX and LSE declined to comment. The source declined to be named as the discussions were confidential.

LSE too had to face defeat in its pursuit of the Toronto Stock Exchange (X.TO) after a consortium of Canadian banks launched a counter offer.

But that has not deterred LSE from attempting more deals. Just this week, LSE CEO Xavier Rolet won the backing of LCH.Clearnet's board for his planned 1 billion euro ($1.3 billion) purchase of Europe's largest independent clearing house.

A reason LSE may be interested in acquiring LME is to protect the revenues it is buying through its purchase of LCH.Clearnet. The LME, a big user of LCH.Clearnet, has recently eyed setting up its own clearing system and if that happens LCH.Clearnet stands to lose a large chunk of the margins it holds, about 50 percent according to one source.

The SGX-LSE combination is expected to face competition from other LME suitors, including CME Group Inc (CME.O), the largest futures exchange in the United States, IntercontinentalExchange (ICE.N) and UK-based broker ICAP (IAP.L), according to sources.

"Joining hands with LSE gives them a good starting point in this process," the source added, referring to the SGX.

The LME, established in 1877 above a London hat shop, accounts for 80 percent of traded volume in global metal futures transactions. It saw record trading volumes last year of 120 million lots, equivalent to $11.6 trillion and 2.8 billion tonnes of metal.

Any deal would have to be accepted by 75 percent of shareholders, which include Goldman Sachs (GS.N), J.P Morgan (JPM.N) and trading firms including Amalgamated Metal Trading and Metdist.

LME's building on Leadenhall Street in the City financial district is one of the last bastions of open outcry, with futures in metals including copper, aluminum, zinc, lead, tin and nickel still changing hands in so-called ring trading as well as electronically and over the telephone.

Trading houses and banks that use the market also own it and therefore the fees are kept low.

The LME is being advised by investment bank Moelis & Co. ($1 = 0.733 Euros)

(Additional reporting by Rachel Armstrong, Saeed Azhar, Eveline Danubrata and Manolo Serapio in SINGAPORE and Pratima Desai in LONDON; Editing by Michael Flaherty, Jonathan Hopfner and Muralikumar Anantharaman)

FILED UNDER: