Controversial "Playboy Club" first victim of TV season

Cast member Amber Heard speaks as co-stars Eddie Cibrian (L), David Krumholtz (L back), Leah Renee Cudmore and Naturi Naughton watch during the NBC Universal session for ''The Playboy Club'' at the 2011 Summer Television Critics Association Cable Press Tour in Beverly Hills, California August 1, 2011. REUTERS/Mario Anzuoni

Cast member Amber Heard speaks as co-stars Eddie Cibrian (L), David Krumholtz (L back), Leah Renee Cudmore and Naturi Naughton watch during the NBC Universal session for ''The Playboy Club'' at the 2011 Summer Television Critics Association Cable Press Tour in Beverly Hills, California August 1, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Mario Anzuoni

LOS ANGELES | Tue Oct 4, 2011 7:55pm EDT

LOS ANGELES (Reuters) - Controversial new drama "The Playboy Club" was axed on Tuesday by NBC after just three episodes, making it the first victim of the new fall TV season.

NBC announced that its new, news magazine show "Rock Center with Brian Williams", will take the place of the 1960s era show on Monday evening, starting on October 31. New police drama "Prime Suspect" will fill the slot in the meantime.

"The Playboy Club", set in the early 1960s in the legendary men's nightclub, centers around the lives of Playboy Bunnies and customers, drew controversy even before it aired.

Leading U.S. feminist Gloria Steinem told Reuters in August that she hoped viewers would boycott the TV series. Steinem, who wrote an expose in the 1960s of the New York City Playboy Club, said the clubs were "the tackiest place on earth".

The Parents Television Council, which had called it a "degrading and sexualizing program", said on Tuesday it was pleased at the cancellation.

The small but vociferous TV watchdog took much of the credit for the show's demise, noting in a statement that it had called on its members and "other concerned citizens to contact local NBC affiliates, and (asked) advertisers whether the Playboy brand aligns with their corporate image."

Seven advertisers pulled commercials from the second episode although it was not clear whether it was a direct result of the PTC campaign.

But the show, which was produced in conjunction with Hugh Hefner's Playboy Enterprises, also suffered from weak ratings and generally poor reviews.

Claims in August by producers that the show was empowering for women also ruffled feathers. The Hollywood Reporter in a September review said "The Playboy Club" had "neither the ambition, writing nor acting to make such a comparison (to TV show "Mad Men") anything more than a chuckle-heavy notion."

Starring Amber Heard and Eddie Cibrian, it drew just 4.1 million viewers in its third outing on Monday, according to ratings data.

"The Playboy Club" was one of 12 new scripted shows for NBC under its new majority owner, Comcast Corp, in a bid to pull the network up from its long-time bottom place among the four leading U.S. broadcasters.

On a brighter note, NBC announced on Tuesday that it had ordered full seasons of its new comedies "Up All Night", starring Christina Applegate and Will Arnett, and "Whitney" which is written by, and stars, stand-up comic Whitney Cummings.

"We made comedy an important goal for us this season and I'm very pleased to be making full season commitments to both 'Whitney' and 'Up All Night'," said NBC entertainment chairman Bob Greenblatt.

(Reporting by Jill Serjeant, editing by Christine Kearney)

Entertainment News From the Wrap

Photo

Reveille's Chad Bennett Debuts Brand-Building Agency, Populus 3:03am EST

Company will build brands around shows and other content

Photo

AFTRA Approves Network Television Code by Huge Margin 2:14am EST

96% of union approve terms for a successor agreement to the AFTRA National Code of Fair Practice for Network Television Broadcasting

Photo

'The Voice' Is Top-Rated Show of the Season -- Can 'American Idol' Regain Lead? 3:09am EST

NBC scores with "The Voice" thanks to smart scheduling, while "American Idol" battles tough competition

Photo

Conrad Murray Wants His Freedom -- and Still Blames Michael Jackson for Death 22 Feb 2012

Financial stress in Michael Jackson's life made his mindset "inconsistent with good judgment," argues the legal team of Dr. Conrad Murray

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (5)
Entertain_me wrote:
I am very sad to see this show canceled. I found it the most entertaining new drama of the season. I am a parent of six and a grandparent of eight. Yes, parents need to oversee what children are allowed to watch. I find it hard to imagine that the plethora of reality shows or police dramas are suitable for young viewers. Let alone the comedies with such strong sexual implications. The Playboy Club was not for children. It was an entertaining show for adults. The music was superb. In my job, I regularly see groups try to “re-write” history because their viewpoint on right and wrong differ with actual events. The Playboy Club happened. It is part of our history. I felt the show was portraying the underlying stories in a tasteful and respectful manner. It was entertaining. I have been hard put trying to find a good drama. I was hooked. Signed, Sadly disappointed.

Oct 04, 2011 6:21pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
cleveindbball wrote:
I totaly agree with you Entertain_me and i can’t believe they keep all the blood and gore of all the CSI’s and Criminal Minds on tv and a garbage show with all the degrading insults to women on Two And A Half Men , yet cancel an entertaining show like The Playboy Club. They said it degraded and sexualized women…..gee, sounds like the Kennedy and Clinton presidency! Has the PTC ever watched some of the cartoons that are on tv for children? They are more offensive with sexual innuendos than The Playboy Club. What about all the controversy on DWTS and you know they only do that for the ratings not because they really care about the people they are exploiting on that show. They are all hypocrites!

Oct 04, 2011 8:51pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
CurtisW wrote:
I agree, the show was hardly PG, and the plot had potential.

TV is already dull enough, don’t let the Christian Temperance Union deaden it further.

Oct 04, 2011 10:27pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.