Egypt Christians vent fury after clashes kill 25

CAIRO Mon Oct 10, 2011 1:55pm EDT

1 of 6. Egyptian Christian women grieve before a mass funeral for victims of sectarian clashes with soldiers and riot police at a protest against an attack on a church in southern Egypt at Abassaiya Cathedral in Cairo October 10, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Amr Abdallah Dalsh

Related Video


Related Topics

CAIRO (Reuters) - Egypt's Coptic Christians turned their fury against the army on Monday after at least 25 people were killed when troops broke up a protest, deepening public doubts about the military's ability to steer the country peacefully toward democracy.

In the worst violence since Hosni Mubarak was ousted, armored vehicles sped into a crowd late on Sunday to crack down on a protest near Cairo's state television.

Online videos showed mangled bodies. Activists said some people were crushed by wheels.

Tension between Muslims and minority Coptic Christians has simmered for years but has worsened since the anti-Mubarak revolt, which gave freer rein to Salafist and other strict Islamist groups that the former president had repressed.

But much of the anger from Sunday's violence targeted the army, accused by politicians from all sides of aggravating social tensions through a clumsy response to street violence and not giving a clear timetable for handing power to civilians.

Late on Monday, thousands marched from Cairo's main cathedral to the Coptic hospital where most of the wounded were treated, calling for religious unity and the removal of the head of the ruling military council, Field Marshal Mohamed Hussein Tantawi.

"Why didn't they do this with the Salafists or the Muslim Brotherhood when they organize protests? This is not my country any more," Alfred Younan, a Copt, said near the hospital.

Church leaders called for three days of fasting "for peace to return to Egypt."

The military council told the interim government to investigate the clashes urgently and said it would take necessary measures to maintain security, state TV said.

"This is a huge crisis that could end in a civil clash. It could end in dire consequences," said presidential hopeful Amr Moussa. "An immediate investigation committee must be formed, with immediate results."

The clashes overshadow Egypt's first parliamentary poll since Mubarak fell. Voting starts on November 28.

"One big problem Egypt faces now is that, increasingly, there is no one in power with the authority and credibility to calm the situation down," said a senior Western diplomat.

"After (Sunday's) events, there is an increasing risk that the military will come into conflict with the people. The authority of the prime minister is dangerously eroded. None of the presidential candidates yet has the standing."


Christians make up 10 percent of Egypt's roughly 80 million people. They took to the streets after accusing Muslim radicals of partially demolishing a church in Aswan province last week.

They also demanded the sacking of the province's governor for failing to protect the building.

On Monday, mourners packed the Abbasiya cathedral, where Coptic Pope Shenouda prayed over candle-lit coffins of the dead. Many wept and chanted slogans calling for Tantawi to step down.

The congregation wailed as some held aloft bloodstained shirts and trousers. "With our souls and blood we sacrifice ourselves for the cross," they cried.

Some protesters said agitators, whom they described as thugs, sparked violence that prompted the heavy-handed tactics.

The Health Ministry said 25 people were killed and 329 wounded, including more than 250 who were taken to hospital.

Mina Magdy, a doctor at the hospital, said it had dealt with 17 fatalities. Fourteen of the deaths were due to bullet wounds and three were killed when vehicles ran over them, he said.

Streets near the state television building had been largely cleared of debris on Sunday, but smashed and burned vehicles lined streets in the area near the Coptic hospital, which was also the scene of violence overnight.

Prime Minister Essam Sharaf, appearing on state TV in the early hours of Monday, said the government's attempts to build a modern, democratic state were being disrupted by security concerns and talk of plots against democracy.

"We will not surrender to these malicious conspiracies and we will not accept reverting back," he said before the interim cabinet met and launched an investigation into the violence.

Justice Minister Mohamed Abdel Aziz el-Guindy said the investigation and any trials would be handled by military courts. State newspaper Al Ahram said 15 people were being investigated. State media had said dozens were detained.


The United States urged restraint and said the rights of minorities and the universal rights of peaceful protest and religious freedom must be respected.

"These tragic events should not stand in the way of timely elections and a continued transition to democracy that is peaceful, just and inclusive," the White House said in a statement.

European Union ministers expressed alarm and said the authorities had a duty to protect religious minorities.

The clashes add to the growing frustration of pro-democracy activists with the generals who took over from Mubarak. Many Egyptians suspect the army wants to wield power from behind the scenes even as it hands day-to-day government to civilians.

The army council denies this.

It has yet to announce a date for a presidential election. A staggered parliamentary vote that lasts till March followed by drawing up a new constitution could push the vote back to the end of 2012 or early 2013, leaving presidential powers in the hands of the military council until then.

Presidential candidate Moussa and other presidential hopefuls have demanded a swifter presidential vote on April 1. Moussa told Reuters it was important that the violence did not derail the election timetable.

Christians complain of discrimination, citing rules that they say make it easier to build a mosque than a church. Tensions have often in the past flared over inter-faith romantic relationships, church building and other issues.

Protests erupted elsewhere in Egypt including its second biggest city, Alexandria. Copts say promises by the new rulers to address their concerns and protect them have been ignored.

"The new emerging faction of Islamists and Salafists has created havoc since the January revolution ... The problem is the severe reluctance of the cabinet and the authorities to enforce the rule of law and protect the Copts," said Youssef Sidhom, editor in chief of Orthodox Coptic newspaper al-Watani.

The cabinet said a fact-finding committee would probe the violence in Cairo and Aswan and laws would be changed to punish religious and other discrimination with prison terms and fines.

It said a committee would speed up the drafting of a new unified law regulating places of worship. Christians have complained that mosques are far easier to build than churches.

Investors, who Egypt is desperate to attract to plug a deep funding shortfall, sold Egyptian shares, pushing the benchmark index down. The index closed down 2.3 percent.

(Additional reporting by, Maha El Dahan, Shaimaa Fayed, Dina Zayed and Tom Pfeiffer in Cairo, David Brunnstrom in Luxembourg and Laura MacInnis in Washington; Writing by Edmund Blair; Editing by Maria Golovnina)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (58)
TGhobrial wrote:
“Christians protesting about an attack on a church set cars on fire, burned army vehicles and hurled rocks at military police ” This is not true and what a shame when Reuters twist the facts or put half fact topic just to catch up with what’s going on….Truth is that Christians were attacked by military ,and ran over by their vehicles,..about 22 out of the 24 dead were Christians…Christians had only some rocks in defense against the military vehicles running over them.

Oct 09, 2011 8:54pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
Crash866 wrote:
Huh? Tick Tock……

Oct 09, 2011 9:12pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This is the danger of popular uprisings which replace authoritarian rulers. Authoritarian rulers, while not popularly elected, do have a vested interest in keeping the peace, while mob rule seeks to install right wing Muslim agendas, including intolerance of any other belief system. From burning churches in Egypt to bombing 1000 year old Buddha statues in Afghanistan, Islam’s intolerance of other cultures is leading it into world war. While many Asian nations have been forcibly conscripted into Islam, the Chinese authorities do not look favorably on a religion which constantly seeks to overthrow governments for the purposes of wresting power. In the United States, liberals are beginning to display what looks for all the world to be a well known symptom of hostages, where they begin to form a psychological bond with their tormenters. If Islam does not moderate we will have a world war. This disrespect for other people’s beliefs is not consistent with enlightenment thinking, and nobody wants to be assimilated forcibly into someone else’s belief system. Not that there’s anything wrong with Islam innately, it is, in fact, based upon the same prophetic teachings that Christianity and Judaism are, but one cannot simply force their personal savior onto someone else; that’s not prophetic and that’s not epiphanic; that’s just dominating through brute force; just what the protesters say they are seeking restitution for.

Oct 09, 2011 9:16pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.