Interactive
Euro zone bank stress test calculator
Use the Reuters Breakingviews stress test calculator to calculate how the Target core Tier 1 capital ratio and sovereign haircut levels affect the amount of capital banks need to pass the stress test. Full Coverage
Sponsored Links
Moody's warns France on possible negative outlook
NEW YORK |
NEW YORK (Reuters) - Moody's warned on Monday it may slap a negative outlook on France's Aaa credit rating in the next three months if the costs for helping to bail out banks and other euro zone members stretch its budget too much.
The warning comes as European Union leaders are discussing measures to protect the region's financial system from an expected Greek debt default. Those measures should include injection of capital into banks with exposure to Greek debt.
France and Germany are the two strongest economies among the 17 euro zone members, and they are spearheading a plan to be presented at an EU summit on Sunday to help resolve the region's debt crisis.
France's progress on crucial fiscal and economic reforms as well as potential adverse developments in financial markets or the economy will also be taken into account under the review, Moody's said.
A negative outlook would be a sign that Moody's could downgrade its rating on France in the next couple of years. Moody's had placed the United States's Aaa rating on negative outlook in August.
"The deterioration in debt metrics and the potential for further contingent liabilities to emerge are exerting pressure on the stable outlook of the government's Aaa debt rating," Moody's said in a statement.
France, it said, has less room now to stretch its finances than it did during the financial crisis of 2008.
France may face a number of challenges in the coming months, such as the need to provide additional support to other European countries or to its own banking system, Moody's said.
For the country to maintain a stable outlook on its rating, it will need to prove its "continued commitment to implementing the necessary economic and fiscal reform measures," the ratings agency said.
The government will also have to show "visible progress in achieving the targeted sustainability improvements" in its debt ratios, Moody's said.
France's debt metrics are now among the weakest of its Aaa peers, the agency said, but they are still supported by a favorable debt affordability, or a relatively low interest burden in relation to government revenues.
But the ability to finance very high levels of debt "rests on investors' confidence in the government's ability and in its willingness to tackle unforeseen challenges," Moody's said in the report.
(Editing by Leslie Adler)
- Tweet this
- Link this
- Share this
- Digg this
- Reprints
Every part of a potential plan has a roadblock:
Leverage the EFS
- France loses AAA rating, which means EFSF cannot sell bonds. Therefore, can’t do this. Ackerman of DB said leveraging the EFSF is against the constitution and illegal. What about insuring 20% of the bonds? Would you buy Greek or Italian bonds, if they insured 20% of it?
RBS said that ECB must shore up the system otherwise any plan is doomed
- Trichet said that ECB has “exhausted its role as lender of last resort”
Sell Eurobonds
- Germany said no.
Schauble wants private investors to increase haircut to 50%
- IIF said no and want to stick with July agreement of 21%. If the banks do this, they will get downgraded again. If the government forces this, then it is involuntary and a default may be triggered to pay CDS holders.
EU wants banks to recapitalize.
- IBF is fighting this, stating that they rather sell assets and shrink than sell shares at such low prices. If banks shrink, economy shrinks.
It’s Checkmate.
5 of the 17 countries need to be bailed out. Others such as Slovakia, Belgium, Cyprus, Estonia, Luxembourg, Malta and Slovenia are poorer or smaller than the 5. How can Germany & France bail out 5 countries?
Spain was downgraded last Friday. Germany and France have higher Debt to GDP ratios than Spain. Moody’s just warned France of a downgrade, even before the EFSF. What happens when they get downgraded? Who is going to bail out who? If either gets downgraded, you can say goodbye to EFSF.
If you’re poor, you cannot become wealthy overnight by saying you have a plan.



Follow Reuters