Germans warn of Greek euro exit after referendum gambit

BERLIN Tue Nov 1, 2011 4:47pm EDT

Share trader Robert Halver reacts as the German share prize index DAX reaches a six percent loss during the afternoon trading session at Frankfurt's stock exchange November 1, 2011.  REUTERS/Kai Pfaffenbach

Share trader Robert Halver reacts as the German share prize index DAX reaches a six percent loss during the afternoon trading session at Frankfurt's stock exchange November 1, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Kai Pfaffenbach

Related Topics

BERLIN (Reuters) - Germans expressed fury and frustration on Tuesday at the Greek prime minister's shock decision to call a referendum on a new financial rescue package, political leaders saying it could plunge Greece into bankruptcy and force it out of the euro zone.

George Papandreou stunned his own people and his European colleagues with the announcement on Monday evening, only days after European leaders had agreed the outlines of a second bailout for Athens at marathon summit talks in Brussels.

The move hammered markets and prompted leaders of the big euro zone countries to hastily arrange a crisis meeting with Papandreou on Wednesday in Cannes, a day before the start of a G20 summit.

"Everyone is asking why Papandreou is doing this? Why now? Is he messing with us?" the top-selling tabloid Bild said on its website.

Michael Roth, Europe spokesman for the opposition Social Democrats (SPD), told Reuters the referendum call showed courage but said Papandreou was "playing with fire."

"If the Greeks are not ready to support Papandreou's reforms, Greece faces an uncertain future in Europe," he said.

Greece has been hit by a wave of anti-austerity strikes and Papandreou has suffered defections by lawmakers in his Socialist party. He said he needed wider political backing for deep spending cuts tied to the new 130 billion euro aid deal.

A poll at the weekend showed nearly 60 percent of Greeks had a negative or partly negative view of the rescue, suggesting a majority of voters could vote 'no' in the referendum, which will probably be held early next year.

Norbert Barthle, a budget expert in Merkel's Christian Democrats (CDU), said the referendum call put a big question mark around that aid package, complicating plans to get banks to accept 50-percent losses on their Greek debt holdings.

Greece is due to receive an 8 billion euro tranche of aid in mid-November, but is likely to run out of cash again in January, around the time when the referendum takes place.

Countries like Germany, Finland and the Netherlands may find it difficult to defend funneling more cash to Athens over the coming months with the threat of the referendum looming.

The opposition Dutch Labour Party described Papandreou's gambit as a "deal breaker" that would doom parliamentary approval of the latest rescue measures.


Leading German eurosceptics welcomed Papandreou's announcement, however, saying it was high time European electorates were consulted on what some Berlin parliamentarians believe is a doomed policy of never-ending bailouts.

"I think it's good, because you can't keep carrying out policies against the will of the people, it won't work," ruling Free Democrat (FDP) lawmaker Frank Schaeffler told Reuters.

"In Greece and in Germany we are making the mistake of not consulting the population enough in this process. I fear that the Greek people will speak out against these measures because they haven't been consulted, which will mean the collapse of this debt bailout logic."

Other experts described the announcement as poorly thought-out and warned that the consequences would reverberate far beyond Greece's borders, dragging down the entire 17-member currency bloc.

"Papandreou is playing all or nothing. That's not just risky for Greece, but also for the euro zone as a whole," said Commerzbank chief economist Joerg Kraemer.

He warned of economic chaos if Greek voters rejected the bailout deal and the country was forced into bankruptcy.

"In this situation Greece could exit the euro zone and try, with a weaker currency, to get back on its feet. But this is a long and very risky path," Kraemer said.

Walking near the Brandenburg Gate in Berlin, 26-year-old student Konstanze Pilge summed up the resentment that many Germans feel toward a country that manipulated its budget figures to enter the euro zone and lived above its means, accumulating a debt mountain of nearly 360 billion euros.

"You can't help thinking that they should be grateful as Europe is trying to help," said Pilge. "Now it looks like they are going to mess things up."

(Additional reporting by Madeline Chambers, Erik Kirschbaum and Gernot Heller in Berlin, Kathrin Jones, Ed Taylor, Andreas Kroener and Vera Eckert in Frankfurt; editing by Tim Pearce)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (26)
nbywardslog wrote:
Frau Doktor Merkel has remained silent on this subject. My suspicion is she knew about it…and may even have connived at it….

Nov 01, 2011 7:47am EDT  --  Report as abuse
Lambick wrote:
That no one knew in advance about this Greek manoeuvre seems to be preposterous and unlikely. But a country that joins international organisations by lying an cheating may surprise us yet.

Nov 01, 2011 7:59am EDT  --  Report as abuse
CalDre wrote:
We are shocked, I tell you, shocked, that someone in Europe would resort to actual democracy! Don’t they know that in Europe and America we play the democracy shell game – give the people a few puppets to choose between, but Heaven Forbid!, don’t let them make a real decision!

Why should Greeks be grateful at the “bailout”? Who’s being bailed out? The Western European banks, who were foolish enough to buy Greek bonds. Not the people of Greece, who will be far better off declaring bankruptcy, returning their debt to ZERO (not 120% of GDP, but ZERO), getting their house in order (which, without the interest payments, will be FAR easier), and then striking up a cozy relationship with benefactor China.

Kiss the Euro good-bye, and let’s pray the attempts at the ESSR fails miserably. Go, Iceland, Go, Ireland, Go, Greece, tell the EU and the bankers to **** off!

Nov 01, 2011 8:46am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.