Israel takes gender fight to buses, billboards

1 of 4. A poster, part of a Facebook campaign called ''Uncensored'' which targets the scarcity of women's images in advertising in Jerusalem, is seen after it was ripped, on an advertising board near Jerusalem's Mea Shearim neighbourhood November 8, 2011. Segregated buses and censored billboards have become a part of Jerusalem life. Buses and billboards, where some advertisers avoid posting images of women to avoid vandalism, have become the latest battlefields in the fight for the soul of Jerusalem, a city sacred to Jews, Muslims and Christians.

Credit: Reuters/Baz Ratner

JERUSALEM | Mon Nov 14, 2011 10:00am EST

JERUSALEM (Reuters) - The women turned heads as they got on Jerusalem's number 56 bus.

Startled ultra-Orthodox Jewish men looked away as the group mounted a challenge to growing gender segregation in the holy city by boarding the public vehicle from the front door and sitting in its first rows.

As the male passengers averted their gaze, adhering to a traditional edict to avoid sexual temptation, a religious woman at the back of the bus shouted at the protesters: "Deal with the drugs, the crime and prostitution in your own communities first."

Buses and billboards, where some advertisers avoid posting images of women to avoid vandalisation, have become the latest battlefields in the fight for the soul of Jerusalem, a city sacred to Jews, Muslims and Christians.

The boarding of bus 56, one of several segregated routes crossing ultra-Orthodox neighborhoods in the city, was the latest attempt by the Israel Religious Action Center (IRAC), to end separate seating.

"The new fad is to distance one's self from women as a way to measure piety. The idea that sex is dirty is not part of Judaism. We have to plug this leak before it spills over," said Anat Hoffman, IRAC's executive director.

But a religious woman on the bus, who gave her name only as Bracha, said there was no humiliation in sitting in the rear.

"It is a response to secular extremism. Look how their women parade along the beach in a degrading way," she said.

Black-garbed ultra-Orthodox Jews, known as "Haredim," make up only about 10 percent of Israel's population of 7.7 million.

But their high birthrates and concentration in Jerusalem, where official figures show 26 percent of adult Jews consider themselves Haredim, have stoked fears among the country's secular majority of religious interference in their lifestyle.

The concerns have also spread beyond the city. A group of Israeli generals wrote to the Defense Ministry on Monday saying the military must not give in to Orthodox demands to prevent the mixing of men and women in the ranks.

Nissim Hasson, vice president of sales at Zohar Hutzot advertising company, said ads showing women in Jerusalem are routinely vandalized.

When it comes to women on posters and billboards, he said, the holy city demands a different set of rules.

"Jerusalem is a symbol, a capital, built on mutual respect, holy to Jews, Christians and Muslims. If you want to be tolerant in this city you cannot advertise women," Hasson said.

Advertising its winter collection, an Israeli fashion company cropped out a female model's head and cleavage from a posters it put up in Jerusalem. In other Israeli cities, the full image ran.

The self-censorship prompted Uri Ayalon, a rabbi who is not a member of the ultra-Orthodox community, to start a Facebook campaign called "Uncensored" in which six women had their photos taken for 150 posters that were put up on Jerusalem billboards.

"We object to the sexist use of women in ads. But it is also important to me that my two daughters grow up in a place where they are not occluded because they are women," Ayalon said.

DANCING GIRLS

Tzaphira Stern-Assal, a secular mother of two who volunteered for the photo shoot, said she once put an ad for a dance class in the window of a dance school she runs, only to see it defaced the next day, along with posters of a dance group, with graffiti that read "Blasphemy."

Whenever the school's curtains are left more than a third open, Stern-Assal said, Haredi men soon show up and start banging on the windows.

"It happens all the time," she said. "Do they want it to be everyone's city or just the Haredis'? We want to live in dignity, not to be ashamed and hide behind curtains."

A sidewalk barrier to segregate the sexes went up last month in the Mea Shearim religious neighborhood of Jerusalem during the celebration of a Jewish holiday, mirroring the separation of men and women in Orthodox synagogues.

Secular activists who came to inspect the partition said they were chased away by residents, some of whom threw stones.

Rachel Azaria, a Jerusalem councilwoman, appealed to the Supreme Court against the barrier, which ordered it dismantled.

She was subsequently fired by Jerusalem Mayor Nir Barkat, in what political commentators called a nod to the ultra-Orthodox community's powerful punch in municipal elections.

"Segregation has been happening for a while. What's new is that the pluralistic public has woken up and is fighting. We won't stand it any longer," Azaria told Reuters.

She said a social change movement that swept through Israel in the summer, when hundreds of thousands took to the streets to demand economic reform, has emboldened those battling segregation.

"The public dares now to say its piece. The penny has dropped," she said.

Reliant on religious parties to help form governing coalitions, Israeli leaders have largely steered clear of cutting welfare subsidies to large ultra-Orthodox families, in which many of the men engage in religious studies full time.

Critics have pointed to the burden they put on the Israeli economy, but moves to cut the payments would spell political trouble for any of the country's major parties.

Addressing the religious-secular divide, the Supreme Court ruled this year that women traveling on public buses cannot be ordered to sit in the back.

Signs in Jerusalem buses now say people have a right to sit wherever they wish and that harassing passengers could be a criminal offence.

Critics say that in practice, dozens of bus lines are still gender segregated and that women who want to sit at the front are often subjected to verbal and sometimes physical assaults.

One Haredi woman, who asked not to be identified, said she tried to buy a public transport pass in an ultra-Orthodox neighborhood in Jerusalem only to be turned away and told the ticket stand was for men only.

Her husband said they received threatening phone calls when word got out that they had lodged a complaint about the incident.

"Separation is important but in places where it makes sense, like the beach. Now there are calls for it on the light rail. There are segregated grocery shops and sidewalks. There's no basis for it in Jewish law and it's getting more extreme," he said.

Yakov Halperin, head of ultra-Orthodox Yehadut Ha Torah faction in Jerusalem's municipality, said people should stay out of the Haredi community's business.

"If that's what they want, in their neighborhoods, they have the right to ask for it," he said.

"In Sodom and Gomorrah, which were annihilated because of the corrupt generation, there were those who kept the Torah's laws and put up fences in order to protect themselves," he said.

(Editing by Jeffrey Heller and Andrew Heavens)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (15)
ShariEshet wrote:
The 23 freedon riders who rode bus #56 with you last week were National Council of Jewish Women leaders on an NCJW women’s study tour to Israel . Along with Anat Hoffman and three members of her staff we experienced first-hand what we already knew; that segregation is humiliating , anti-democractic and illegal . For more information about our experiences go to: http://www.ncjw.org/insider/client/index.cfm/2011/11/3/Riding-the-Buses-in-Jerusalem

Nov 15, 2011 1:16pm EST  --  Report as abuse
Tiu wrote:
How come “developed” countries like America, Canada, the UK, Australia etc., etc., support Israel without question? Do the leaders of the “democratic” world aspire to this kind of leadership and citizen (serf) control as well?

Nov 20, 2011 9:29am EST  --  Report as abuse
paintcan wrote:
“There’s no basis for it in Jewish law and it’s getting more extreme,” he said.”

That statement ignores historical artifacts. The segregation of women was very common in old synagogues and even in some branches of Christianity that were very influenced by Old Testament Texts. The older Quakers and the nearly extinct Shakers were an example. Roman Catholicism didn’t practice public segregation within Churches but they did and do practice severe segregation within all Monasteries and Convents and certain more obscure religious communities.

But it is ironic that this article is one of the few that states that the city of Jerusalem is recognized by many to be common to three major religions and yet the State of Israel is trying to ensure that the entire city, including and beyond the original ancient center, is controlled and demographically dominated by the “Jewish” state (and I still can’t figure out how the state defines that). The original UN approval was predicated on the idea that the old city would be either jointly or separately administered (I don’t understand from the UN record how this was supposed to be achieved as the old City was very heavily populated by the Muslim inhabitants) and would be controlled by no single religion that considered it important.

There have been numerous UN notes that criticism Israel’s heavy-handed and even ruthless low scale war to change the demographic composition of all of Jerusalem and even East Jerusalem. What was the point?

There is nothing inherently or traditionally democratic about any of the three major World Religions – Judaism, Christianity or Islam. They were all born before the modern era and don’t actually recognize the word except in the modern era. The papacy is hardly a model of democracy. The old form Quakers and Shakers aside, Christian Protestant sects were the most inherently democratic of all the major faiths and did not generally practice sexual segregation, as far as I can tell.

Religions would be wonderful if it wasn’t for the baggage train of their religious traditions. But how does one practice generic “faith” without it becoming just another “opinion”? Few religious traditions (Bahai and the Unitarians perhaps) can’t really tolerate too much relativism. Religious creeds can’t quite abandon the land mines and dragons buried within their traditions. The more progressive Protestant sects of Christianity that tried to adapt to a changing world, had a long record of endless factional and theological disputes leading to schism. Obviously – they have a big problem.

It is ironic that people often join religious traditions to maintain or forge a common understanding and yet the moment they get specific about theology or articles of a creed – they loose the commonality they looked hope for and tend to become just one more sect.

Nov 20, 2011 9:37am EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.