France calls for humanitarian zone in Syria

AMMAN/PARIS Wed Nov 23, 2011 4:12pm EST

Demonstrators march against Syria's President Bashar al-Assad in Homs November 21, 2011. The banners (C) read ''Freedom for detained students at Assad's prisons''. Picture taken November 21, 2011.    REUTERS/Handout

Demonstrators march against Syria's President Bashar al-Assad in Homs November 21, 2011. The banners (C) read ''Freedom for detained students at Assad's prisons''. Picture taken November 21, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Handout

AMMAN/PARIS (Reuters) - France called on Wednesday for a "secured zone to protect civilians" in Syria, the first time a major Western power has suggested international intervention on the ground in the eight-month uprising against President Bashar al-Assad.

Foreign Minister Alain Juppe also described Syria's exiled opposition National Council as "the legitimate partner with which we want to work," the biggest international endorsement yet for a nascent opposition body that seeks to overthrow Assad.

Asked at a news conference after meeting the SNC president if a humanitarian corridor was an option for Syria, Juppe ruled out military intervention to create a "buffer zone" in northern Syria but suggested a "secured zone" may be feasible to protect civilians and ferry in humanitarian aid.

"If it is possible to have a humanitarian dimension for a secured zone to protect civilians, that then is a question which has to be studied by the European Union on the one side and the Arab League on the other side," Juppe said.

Further details of the proposal were not immediately available. Until now, Western countries have imposed economic sanctions on Syria but have shown no appetite for intervention on the ground in the country, which sits on the fault lines of the ethnic and sectarian conflicts across the Middle East.

"The French have tried to position themselves in a position of leadership, first with Libya and now here," said Hayat Alvi, a lecturer in National Security studies, at the U.S. Naval War College. "Military intervention in Syria is a very different prospect of that in Libya, but we could well see an increase in covert action."

The Arab League has suspended Syria's membership over the conflict, one of the most important signs of Assad's isolation, but has shown little appetite for international intervention.

Britain said it welcomed the opportunity to discuss the French proposal and repeated its call for Syria to end human rights violations.

Syria's bloodshed could pitch the Muslim world into "the darkness of the Middle Ages," Turkish President Abdullah Gul said, some of the strongest language yet showing global anxiety as one of the core Mid-East countries slides toward civil war.

A day earlier, Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan criticized the "cowardice" of Assad, once a close ally, for turning guns on his own people. Erdogan spoke of the fate of defeated dictators from Adolf Hitler, Benito Mussolini to Muammar Gaddafi, and bluntly told Assad to quit.

In Brussels, an EU diplomat said European Union governments were considering a new range of sanctions against Syria that would bar investment in Syrian banks, trading its government bonds and selling insurance to state bodies.

Gul told a think-tank in London: "We exerted enormous efforts in public and behind closed doors in order to convince the Syrian leadership to lead the democratic transition."

"Violence breeds violence. Now, unfortunately, Syria has come to a point of no return," he said. "Defining this democratic struggle along sectarian, religious and ethnic lines would drag the whole region into turmoil and bloodshed."

Syrian forces killed two villagers on Wednesday in an agricultural area that has served as a supply line for defectors, and clamped down on a Damascus suburb where loyalist troops have been attacked, activists and residents said.

An armored column entered the town of Hayaleen and surrounding villages on the al-Ghab Plain. Troops fired machineguns from tanks and trucks and set fire to several houses after arresting around 100 people, they said.

"Twenty-five armored vehicles entered the village of Zor al-Kaada, which has only 700 people. Thirteen people were arrested from the al-Dinawi family alone," Adnan, a farmer, told Reuters by telephone.

The region, northwest of the city of Hama, 240 km (150 miles) north of Damascus, has been a transit route for defectors operating in the province of Idlib near Turkey, activists said.

It was not possible to confirm the events independently. The authorities, who blame the unrest on "armed terrorist groups," have barred most independent media from Syria.

Thousands of soldiers have deserted the regular army since it started cracking down on the eight-month protest movement. Some have formed rebel armed units loosely linked to an umbrella "Free Syrian Army" led by officers in Turkey.

In Damascus, activists said defectors from the Obaida bin al-Jarrah brigade attacked roadblocks overnight in the suburb of Harasta, where hundreds of people have been detained since an attack by deserters last week on an airforce complex.

"Eight security police may have been killed or wounded. We heard the exchange of gunfire at around 1 am. The security police resumed house-to-house arrests today and no young male can go out in the street without risking arrest," said one activist, who gave his name as Omar.


Syrian defectors say they are hopeful that Turkish troops will create a safe haven within Syria. Defectors say they could use such a zone as a staging ground to mount a rebellion.

Turkey is reluctant to take military action across the frontier but Turkish officials say they could act to set up a sanctuary on Syrian territory if huge numbers of refugees head for the border or if massacres take place in Syrian cities.

Ground forces commander Hayri Kivrikoglu inspected troops near the border on Tuesday, Turkish state television reported.

Syrian deserters and civilians in refugee camps and villages in Turkey close to the frontier say the Syrian army has reinforced its positions in border areas.

"There are tanks in the valleys, hidden among the trees, and they've dug trenches," Syrian refugee Hamid Fayzo told Reuters in the Turkish village of Guvecci, overlooking the border.

The United Nations says 3,500 people have been killed in the uprising, triggered by Arab revolts which have toppled leaders in Tunisia, Egypt and Libya.

Assad, 46, seems prepared to fight it out, playing on fears of a sectarian war if Syria's complex ethno-sectarian mosaic shatters. He may calculate that neither Western powers nor Arab neighbors will risk military intervention.

Syria appears to be on the brink of a Libya-style armed insurgency. Many experts say Assad, who can depend mainly on the loyalty of two elite Alawaite units, cannot maintain current military operations without cracks emerging in the armed forces.

The U.N. General Assembly's human rights committee overwhelmingly passed a resolution on Tuesday condemning the government crackdown. Russia and China, which vetoed a European-drafted U.N. Security Council resolution last month that would have condemned Syria, abstained. Diplomats said that could indicate a shift in their positions.

(Additional reporting by Suleiman al-Khalidi in Hatay, Turkey, Jonathon Burch in Ankara, Adrian Croft in London and Justyna Pawlak in Brussels; Writing by Peter Graff)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (3)
The French are pushing for another intervention, indicating that Sarkozy is falling again in the latest polls. The UN will not agree to a humanitarian “securitized zone” after the “no fly zone” in Libya. In addition, the logistics would be far more difficult unless Turkey or Cyprus offer air bases. Furthermore, the US and NATO don’t need to blow up computers, digital cameras, cell phones, and fertilizer – the basic components of smart munitions. They don’t need to burn millions of gallons of aviation fuel and diesel fuel. These products should be used for trade, not for regime change by the former colonial masters (France) in a former French colony (Syria). The US and NATO might not want to bomb another muslim country because boycotts might ensue, and these lands can sell all of their oil to China instead of the US and NATO. We may wish them well, but Syrians must earn their own freedom.

Nov 23, 2011 2:42pm EST  --  Report as abuse
greenspy wrote:
More international pressure must be placed on Assad and his regime. He must listen to the international community because he has lost touch with reality. He cant possibly understand why 75% of the people want him to go. Another dictator going down hard.

I would send in as many arms to the freedom fighters including the defectors, and see if that works. More sanctions, including Russia and or China changing thier position.

Last resort, lets encourage and help Turkey go in and take care of this problem.

Assad will be gone in 2012, and lets see who will catch him first.

Nov 23, 2011 5:26pm EST  --  Report as abuse
twittonpeace wrote:
World Peace & Humanity!

Turkey’s foreign policy all over the world with steady steps is a critical role in the peace process.

In any case a negative experience with the military power and war are the active state. Turkey is a country that pro-war but pro-peace.

The most reliable member of NATO and the United Nations has the most active.

Neighboring all countries by the end of all the possible ways to use the political peace.

Guarantor country in the Middle East and World Peace.

By the political support for Turkey in Nato and the United Nations have always given as positive.

“Peace at Home Peace in the World!”

Said Mustafa Kemal ATATURK Founder of Turkey


*Soul to Soul and Hand in Hand for World Peace & Humanity



Nov 24, 2011 3:34am EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.