Olympus ex-CEO attacks Japan investors as comeback bid struggles

TOKYO Thu Dec 15, 2011 5:29pm EST

Former Olympus CEO Michael Woodford waves from a car window as he leaves at a news conference at the Japan National Press Club in Tokyo, December 15, 2011. REUTERS/Issei Kato

Former Olympus CEO Michael Woodford waves from a car window as he leaves at a news conference at the Japan National Press Club in Tokyo, December 15, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Issei Kato

TOKYO (Reuters) - The whistleblower in Japan's Olympus Corp scandal, ex-CEO Michael Woodford, blasted Japanese shareholders on Thursday for failing to stand up for him, amid signs that domestic and foreign investors are split over his campaign to be reinstated.

Woodford, an Englishman who was a rare foreign CEO in Japan, went public with his concerns over crooked accounting at Olympus after his dismissal in October, leading to the uncovering of a $1.7 billion fraud that has left the company badly weakened.

He is now lobbying shareholders of the maker of cameras and medical equipment to support his reinstatement and replace the disgraced board with a new team that he is assembling.

"We saw a shameful state of the company's finances yesterday, but not one Japanese shareholder stood up and said publicly 'Mr Woodford is right, thank you Mr Woodford', anything, a total, an utter silence," Woodford said, a day after Olympus released its restated accounts on Wednesday.

His comeback campaign has highlighted the contrasting opinions of foreign and Japanese shareholders on the future leadership of Olympus, which has been found to have carried on a $1.7 billion fraud to hide investment losses for 13 years.

At least three big foreign shareholders have backed Woodford's bid to return to the company where he spent three decades working his way up from salesman to CEO. But not one Japanese shareholder or lender has openly supported him since he blew the whistle, leaving him clearly frustrated.

Woodford also launched an emotional attack on the firm's current Japanese boss.

"Should that man be the president and custodian of one of Japan's iconic companies?" he said of Olympus President Shuichi Takayama, one of the directors who had voted unanimously to sack him after he had queried the firm's dubious book-keeping.

"How dare he!" Woodford added, calling Takayama's handling of the whole affair "Machiavellian."

Woodford also said he had discussed refinancing options for Olympus with private equity firms and investment banks, and also voiced concerns that Takayama was planning to raise money by placing new shares with a third party.

That would dilute the stakes of existing owners and weaken their hand in a proxy battle between Woodford and whoever the existing board chooses as its next CEO candidate.

"It would dilute the existing shareholders, so then I could not win a proxy fight," he said.

The existing board, led by Takayama, has said he and fellow directors will resign soon, to make way for a new board to be elected by shareholders at a meeting in March or April, and that the board wants to choose its successors before it quits.

It has set up an external panel to advise on board candidates and other management issues.

Takayama even suggested on Thursday the board would consider Woodford as a candidate for his old job, but few analysts gave the gesture any credence given the hostility between the pair.

Takayama, currently the most senior executive after several resignations since Woodford's departure, said he had no plans to meet Woodford, who some major Japanese shareholders and lenders privately oppose, according to a banking source.

"As of now, I have no plans to meet," he said.

Woodford says the board is discredited and has no right to choose its successors, and on Thursday expressed anger at signs that not all of the incumbent board would resign.

He is assembling his own team of candidates for a new board with himself at the helm.


Woodford also went public with a plea to meet the head of Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corp (SMBC), the main lender to Olympus, a possible sign that he was having trouble getting access.

"My representatives have asked for a formal meeting with SMBC. I hope they at least give me the courtesy of listening to me," he said. The bank, which is the core banking unit of Sumitomo Mitsui Financial Group, said it had not received the request and declined comment.

The next CEO and board of Olympus face major challenges, starting with a need to repair the once-proud firm's balance sheet, which was revealed on Wednesday to be $1.1 billion weaker than had been previously disclosed in its fraudulent accounts.

Olympus shares slumped 20 percent on Thursday, with investors now concerned it might need to merge, sell assets or raise fresh capital.

Takayama said on Thursday the company was considering capital and operational tie-ups, among other options, to relieve the pressure on its balance sheet, which was shown to have a very thin layer of equity remaining after the restatements.

Olympus forecast its troubled camera business will make a loss in the current financial year, but said unit sales had risen 15 percent in the six months to September 30 from the same period a year earlier.

The firm, whose main income earner is its very profitable endoscope business, avoided automatic delisting from the Tokyo Stock Exchange by meeting Wednesday's deadline for producing its overdue second-quarter accounts, giving some initial relief to investors.

However, the 92-year-old firm can still be delisted if the exchange believes the accounting deceit was sufficiently grave.

Woodford said he favored private equity or a rights issue over a strategic alliance, which would rob Olympus of its independence. But rights issues, where existing shareholders can buy more shares on a pro-rata basis, are rare in Japan.

Olympus has lost more than half its market value since it sacked Woodford and the scandal erupted. Two top Olympus executives have been found to have masterminded the scheme to cook the books, and both have since resigned.

Olympus has been dogged by rumors of bid interest from rivals, such as fellow endoscope makers Fujifilm and Hoya, or from private equity since the scandal broke.

The Tokyo exchange said after the announcements that it was keeping Olympus on its watchlist for possible delisting.

(Additional reporting by Linda Sieg, James Topham, Mari Saito and Tim Kelly; Editing by Mark Bendeich and Michael Watson)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (10)
JoeeBlowww wrote:
Yeah, and if you think Olympus is the only company that’s been cooking it’s books in the past 3-5 years, I’ve got some oceanfront property in Arizona that I’d like to sell you as well! At least they’ve admitted to it and done something to correct it. Who’s next? Many don’t want to admit what their balance sheet really looks like, and it’s too easy to make the corporate profits look strong, when there is a different reality. It’s all to keep the shareholders happy and try to pump up the stock price as long as possible, in hopes of some recovery that isn’t happening. I’ve seen it done first hand!

Dec 14, 2011 8:39pm EST  --  Report as abuse
LehmanBros. wrote:
Michael Woodford has no regards at all to the well being of Olympus, or it thousands of workers. This man only desire is to destroy Olympus and the culture that rule Japan. Woodford is a liar and con man. He’s saying he doesn’t want to break up Olympus, he’s a LIAR. He’ll do exactly what the foreign shareholders order him to do, which is break up Olympus and put thousands of Japanese workers out of their job, while Wodford will get his $25 million bonus package.

” I’m not begging to come back to lead Olympus again “. Woodford said. Why would anyone who say this and then lead a forceful proxy fight with the current management and try to force them to resign? Does this sound like Woodford is not begging to come back? He clearly is doing everything he can to be instated at Olympus. Not begging? Oh I think you are Woodford.

Woodford also said he would only come back to Japan if the police protect him, now he’s back to Japan again WILLINGLY 1 day before the deadline for Olympus to file their reports to the Tokyo Shock Exchange. Sounds to me like Woodford had all this calculated in his head.

Clearly Japanese investors wants nothing to do with him. Afterall, he deliberately help wipe out 80% of their investments and now he wants them to sleep with a snake? No thank you Mr. Woodford, you’re a liar and soulless beast, we want nothing to do with you.

In the last few weeks Woodford has shown nothing but scared and barbaric tactics and colluding with foreign shareholders to be reinstated as CEO. He has shown he’s nothing more than a lap dog for SouthEastern Asset Management, and other foreign shareholders.

This man has no characters or any characteristic to be a good CEO on any company. I doubt he’ll even get a job at McDonald after this.

Dec 15, 2011 5:15am EST  --  Report as abuse
VonHell wrote:
Mere “liar” is not the best term.
Woodford only came to CEO of a japanese company by being in the good grace of the same people now against him…
So he can be called the “good aprendice” who top his masters…
We can call him a “traitor” them, but we can not forget the “rotten” board of “liars”, white collar outlaws and maybe worst… i believe the FBI will have its part in this history and much will surface…
Ofc, the shareholders are not that alienated. They know he keeps appearance as every one of his good japanese masters under the avatar of japanese culture and tradition…
He is not the perfect “Hero”, but is the best we will find in the corporation world…
And i believe that absolutely zero of the shareholders, board, investors, bankers, politicians, regulators, are thinking in first, second or third place about the well being of the Olympus’ workers… If someone of them come with this talk, it is a lie or demagogy to keep the appearance…

Dec 15, 2011 7:45am EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.