Bruised "X Factor" limps toward finals

LOS ANGELES Fri Dec 16, 2011 5:17pm EST

Related News


Brangelina wed

Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt get married.   Slideshow 

LOS ANGELES (Reuters) - American viewers have chosen the three singers who will compete in the finals of "The X Factor" after a first season that underwhelmed critics and raised questions about audience fatigue ahead of returning TV contests "American Idol" and "The Voice."

Power ballad singer Melanie Amaro, 19, bluesy Josh Krajcik, 30, and troubled rapper Chris Rene, 28, will sing for a $5 million recording contract in next week's two-part finale of the Fox show.

But after major hype from creator and judge Simon Cowell -- who had initially predicted "X Factor" would replace "American Idol" as the most-watched show on U.S. television -- the program's bickering mentor-judges, big production numbers and flashing lights has left many critics scratching their heads.

"As a viewer, it is agonizing to watch and just so fake that none of it is compelling, " said Annie Barrett, who covers "X Factor" for Entertainment Weekly.

"Everything is a gimmick. It is a glossy, shiny version of a reality show that might give you a seizure because of all the lasers and lights," Barrett told Reuters.

Thursday's semi-final, in which 20-year-old hopeful Marcus Canty was eliminated, drew 9.6 million viewers -- below the audience for a repeat of CBS comedy "The Big Bang Theory" and less than half the regular audience for "American Idol" earlier this year.

Fox executives say they are happy with the viewer numbers, especially among teens, and the show has helped the network reverse its historically patchy fall ratings in the 18-49 viewer group most coveted by advertisers.

Fox has already ordered a second season for the fall of 2012, calling "X Factor" a "monumental success."


Andy Dehnart, editor of, said that for all the new tweaks in the singing contest formula, few were for the better.

"There is no real national buzz about it. I don't think 'X Factor' has broken through the zeitgeist in the same way as 'American Idol'," said Dehnart.

Indeed, it seems the first season's most memorable moment came a week ago when bubbly 13-year-old Rachel Crow collapsed in tears on being sent home, sparking viewer outrage against judge Nicole Scherzinger.

Whoever wins after public votes are announced next Thursday, Cowell's hopes of discovering a new global singing star -- who will be signed to his Sony Music-owned record label SyCo -- may be dashed.

None of the instantly downloadable songs from this week's semi-final were in the Top 50 iTunes singles charts on Friday.

"I don't see anyone here who is going to be the next Kelly Clarkson or Carrie Underwood, which is what the show claimed it was going to do," said Dehnart.

Barrett said that four months of "X Factor" twice a week had made her appreciate "American Idol".

But with NBC's surprise hit "The Voice" returning in February and "Idol's" 11th season beginning in mid-January on Fox, Americans may soon lose their appetite for lengthy singing contests.

"I do think there will be some fatigue going into next season with both 'American Idol' and 'The Voice.' Two nights a week is a huge commitment," Barrett said.

But Dehnart was more optimistic. "If we are going to see any kind of fatigue with this kind of show, it is going to show up now. But I wouldn't be surprised if they all work on their own level."

(Editing by Bob Tourtellotte)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (11)
Too much “bling”, too much bickering and back-biting among the judges, and WHAT EXACTLY IS THIS “X FACTOR” WE’RE LOOKING FOR? If Astro is considered a ‘genius’ by the judges, and Chris Rene ends up winning it as many think will happen, then I guess I prefer THE VOICE and AMERICAN IDOL. I can appreciate Melanie’s amazing ‘diva’ vocals and Josh’s bluesy, razor-blade vocals; but am not at all impressed with Chris Rene’s vocals. Many say “he writes his own stuff”: FINE – but I don’t buy CDs because the artist can WRITE — I buy CDs because the artist can SING.

Dec 16, 2011 10:54pm EST  --  Report as abuse
numcrun wrote:
The songs are not charting because no-one wants to buy half a song, which is all they are. And Amaro will be a huge star.

Dec 17, 2011 12:05am EST  --  Report as abuse
jenaj3 wrote:
I disagree that X Factor hasn’t produced a star. It has and her name is Melanie Amaro.

Dec 17, 2011 12:55am EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.