French costs rise but demand solid at debt sale

PARIS Thu Jan 5, 2012 9:38am EST

French (L) and European flags are displayed during a news conference at the Hotel Matignon in Paris June 21, 2011.   REUTERS/Charles Platiau

French (L) and European flags are displayed during a news conference at the Hotel Matignon in Paris June 21, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Charles Platiau

PARIS (Reuters) - French borrowing costs rose slightly when the euro zone's second-largest economy sold debt for the first time this year on Thursday but demand was solid despite concerns the country could lose its AAA credit rating.

With a heavy schedule of debt redemptions in the first quarter, market fears about euro states' ability to fund their debts remains high. France, which has a slowing economy and a presidential election looming in April, is seen by many to be at greater risk from ebbing investor confidence than regional powerhouse Germany.

France sold 7.96 billion euros ($10.3 billion) of 10- to 30-year bonds at the auction, at the top of its projected range, after receiving total bids for nearly 15 billion euros.

The yield on the benchmark October 2021 bond rose slightly to 3.29 percent to above the 3.18 percent fixed when it was last auctioned on December 1, but remained in line with yields in the secondary market of around 3.3 percent.

The 10-year spread over Bunds was a whisker higher after the auction at 143 basis points, remaining well below its euro-era high of more than 200 basis points reached in November.

"Overall it's a pretty solid auction," Michael Leister, strategist at DZ Bank in Frankfurt. "It should be enough to dispel concerns with regards to France's funding capacity for the time being."

The yield on the 4.5 percent 30-year OAT maturing in April 2041 rose to 3.97 percent from 3.94 percent in the December 1 auction, the Agence France Tresor debt management agency said.

The Treasury placed 4.02 billion and 2.165 billion euros respectively of the 3.25 percent and 4.5 percent OATs.

It also sold 690 million euros of its 4.25 percent OAT maturing in October 2023 and 1.088 billion euros of its 4.75 percent OAT due in April 2035. Those bonds were last auctioned in June 2011, and April 2010, respectively, so yields are not comparable.


France's top-notch credit rating is hanging by a thread due to its slowing economy, high structural deficit and banking exposure to the euro zone's most troubled debtor states.

Last month, Fitch put France's rating on a negative outlook and Standard and Poor's, which placed 15 euro zone countries under review, singled out France as the only AAA country facing a possible two-notch downgrade.

In recent days, analysts said there was decent domestic demand for French 10-year bonds from local investors, particularly insurance companies.

The solid French sale came after Germany successfully sold 4.06 billion euros of 10-year bonds at its first auction of 2012 on Thursday, with a recovery in demand supported by redemptions and coupon payments which left investors flush with cash.

That came as a relief after the upset of a November auction which drew bids worth less than the 6 billion euros on offer and sowed fears that contagion could touch the heart of the euro zone.

With a heavy schedule of euro zone debt maturing this year, particularly in the region's No. 3 economy, Italy, traders remain nervous about government finances despite an unprecedented injection of nearly half a trillion euros of cheap ECB funding for banks last month.

"Given the clear risk of an imminent ratcheting up of market tensions as Italy's February-April redemption hump looms closer, today's sales should be seen as a successful battle rather than in any way determining the outcome of the war," said Richard McGuire, senior fixed income strategist at Rabobank in London.

France plans to issue up to 178 billion euros in medium- and long-term government debt, net of buybacks, this year, down only slightly from 184 billion euros in 2011, despite the threat to its rating.

With its economy expected to enter recession in the first quarter of this year, France will need more painful austerity measures to reach a deficit target of 4.5 percent of gross domestic product this year, though the impending election may complicate that.

Adding to investors' concerns, Socialist election frontrunner Francois Hollande -- who leads Sarkozy by a wide margin in polls -- has pledged to renegotiate a fiscal compact being agreed by the European Union, potentially complicating efforts to solve the debt crisis. ($1 = 0.7747 euros)

(Additional reporting by Blaise Robinson in Paris and London government bond desk; Editing by Ruth Pitchford)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (1)
milkel wrote:
After pushing the Italian and Spanish yields to record highs, the markets r now exerting pressure on the, till now safe, French securities. This is despite nothing too adverse reported yet on French economy.
The only sensitive matter is that the French Banks holding a huge amount of Sovereign debt of the PIIGS nations. The what is causing the attack on French securities? I believe it is really the under-current of opinion about the overall European economy. That, in turn, emanates from the fact that the revival of economic growth is not an event which is foreseen in near future, leave alone, immediate future. That is then causing nervousness about 3 things, firstly, the future of the Euro zone economies that r already in trouble….’coz they seem to have exhausted almost all means within rational reasoning, to contain their problems, and have not been achieved much mileage, an indicator that they r fast running out of options, and that too without much headway.
Secondly, the well-to-do countries like Germany and France (these r the only 2 that r big enough to make an impact, if at all any)r seen as committing themselves more and more to support badly managed economies in the euro-zone. While at it, nothing much significant has occurred at the Ground level in last one and a half month, apart from the numerous meetings between Franco-German politicians and officials. One may as well blame it on X’mas and new year season, fine, but now the party being over, it’s time for some more serious work…..and indications to that r exactly what is missing over last 3-4 days.
Lastly, the market seems to be in the process of factoring in the combined effect of the above 2 factors and the possibility that the top 2 euro economies will also be facing economic slowdown for foreseeable future. This will result in spending cuts and disinvestment by the euro governments. This wud also mean lesser imports by them and resultantly “exporting” their recessionary pressures to asian economies…….what more to it than China and India showing much reduced industrial activity in last quarter?

Jan 05, 2012 7:26am EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

A tourist takes a plunge as she swims at Ngapali Beach, a popular tourist site, in the Thandwe township of the Rakhine state, October 6, 2013. Picture taken October 6, 2013. REUTERS/Soe Zeya Tun (MYANMAR - Tags: SOCIETY) - RTR3FOI0

Where do you want to go?

We look at when to take trips, budget considerations and the popularity of multigenerational family travel.   Video