The dome of the Capitol is reflected in a puddle in Washington February 17, 2012.REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque

Another debt ceiling debacle could sink the economy

Last year's Congressional debt standoff hurt consumer confidence more than the collapse of Lehman Brothers, Betsey Johnson and Justin Wolfers write. This time could be worse.  Read more at Counterparties  

Indiana state House approves right-to-work bill

Related Topics

INDIANAPOLIS | Wed Jan 25, 2012 10:16pm EST

INDIANAPOLIS (Reuters) - Indiana moved one step closer to becoming the first right-to-work state in the country's old manufacturing belt on Wednesday after its Republican-controlled House of Representatives passed legislation banning unions from collecting mandatory dues from workers.

Passage of the controversial measure, one of Governor Mitch Daniels' signature issues, was the latest setback for organized labor in the industrial Midwest, long a stronghold for unions, after Wisconsin imposed curbs on public sector collective bargaining rights last year.

The Indiana House approved the right-to-work bill, which bars employers from signing contracts that require workers to pay union dues, by a 54-to-44 margin on Wednesday, even though five Republicans joined Democratic lawmakers to oppose it.

The state Senate had voted 28 to 22 in favor of the measure on Monday, with nine Republicans joining all 13 Democrats in voting against it.

Daniels, who gave the Republican response to President Barack Obama's State of the Union speech on Tuesday, has promised to quickly sign the measure once it hits desk, saying it will help Indiana attract businesses and jobs to the state.

Opponents have called it a "union busting" measure designed to weaken a key Democratic constituency in an election year.

Under the law, employees in the state cannot be forced to pay union dues -- even if they work at companies where the workforce is unionized. Such statutes are in force in 22 states, mostly in the South and West.

State House Democrats had used delay tactics to try to thwart passage of the measure, staying off the House floor for several days to deny the majority Republicans a quorum. Republicans responded by imposing $1,000-a-day fines on the missing lawmakers, which the Democrats fought in court.

Democrats also sought to introduce several amendments, including an effort to put the right-to-work measure before voters in a referendum, but Republicans defeated them.

Before heading to Daniels' desk, the measure will make a brief, procedural detour back to the Republican-controlled state Senate. That chamber passed its own version of the bill but now needs to sign off on the House version.

Measures to curb the powers of public-sector and private sector unions were introduced in several midwestern states last year after gains in the 2010 elections gave Republicans control or strengthened majorities.

The impact was notable in Wisconsin and Ohio, both potential swing states in the November election, as well as in Indiana.

In Wisconsin, Republican proposals to limit public-sector union powers sparked extended protests at the Capitol in Madison, but were ultimately adopted.

The polarizing debate in Wisconsin led to efforts to recall state senators in both parties last year, and Democrats were also seeking to force Republican Governor Scott Walker into a recall election.

In Ohio, the Republican-led legislature approved changes to the powers of public-sector unions, but voters turned back the effort in a referendum last November.

(Writing by James B. Kelleher; Editing by Greg McCune and Cynthia Johnston)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (3)
JamVee wrote:
It’s about time. More of the Rust Belt states need this same law. Maybe then, they will become the manufacturing powerhouse that they were 30 years ago (instead of a bunch of vacant, plants and buildings, rusting away).

Jan 26, 2012 9:24am EST  --  Report as abuse
Phil_EngAmer wrote:
It’s good that the state can finally implement this legislation. We know the big talking point you hear from the opposition is that this type of legislation drives down wages, and you continually hear the “right to work” for less rhetoric, but when you look closer at the issue you see that very few ever take cost of living into account. When you correct for cost of living, right to work states actually see improvement in wages, and hardly see any difference from non-right to work states (http://bit.ly/Apc1Y5).

With so few states in the rust belt being right-to-work, Indiana has a prime opportunity to really infuse some life into their economy.

Jan 26, 2012 12:37pm EST  --  Report as abuse
JLDF wrote:
I have 30 years of experience in labor relations. I worked union for 10 years, non-union and also as a manager. I have negotiated on both sides. I can give you 50 real reasons why unions kill job growth and another 50 reasons why they are no longer needed.

Here is the number one reason we need Right to Work: The union craves power over the workforce. They place themselves between Labor and Management. Good cooperative relations hurt union power. That is why they undermine the organizations they organize. This kills your ability to compete against foreign competition.

It is very hard to run a manufacturing business with good relations and close to impossible with a union planting the seeds of suspicion and oppositional conflict. Its simply not in the unions interest for factories to be smart, efficient and competitive. Good relations degrade their power over the people.

This is why companies are paying more and more to be in Right to Work states – they need the cooperation and brain power of every person in the company and they are willing to pay for it.

That is also why unions are one of the big reasons American manufacturing has suffered over the past 20 years. We have enough problems with stupid managers – we don’t need to fight our own organizations. You will never win on the world stage like that.

Jan 26, 2012 7:06pm EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.