DEALTALK-Twice shunned, US Air again sets sights on merger

Fri Feb 3, 2012 3:59pm EST

* AMR bankruptcy spurs talk of new industry mergers

* AMR Latin routes a key prize, but antitrust bar high

* Left out in previous deals, US Airways keen for merger partner

* Delta eyes new growth, United Continental on sidelines

By Kyle Peterson and Soyoung Kim

Feb 3 (Reuters) - After sitting out the mega-mergers that created the world's two largest airlines in recent years, US Airways Group is once again courting partners, this time hoping that its bankrupt rival American Airlines will deem it merger-worthy.

US Airways Chief Executive Doug Parker, a longtime advocate for industry consolidation, has confirmed his interest in making a bid for American's parent AMR Corp.

The fifth-largest U.S. carrier also is open to being acquired itself, and would consider any serious takeover offers that could improve shareholder return, according to people familiar with US Airways' thinking.

But for all the speculation on another round of airline consolidation, with Delta Air Lines Inc and private equity firm TPG Capital among those evaluating AMR, only one pairing makes sense and appears likely in this business that remains plagued by overcapacity, experts say.

"Most likely, somehow, US Airways will get involved with American," said Ray Neidl, an aerospace analyst at Maxim Group. "We've got one airline too many as far as legacy carriers go."

Another merger of major U.S. airlines - following United/Continental in 2010 and Delta/Northwest in 2007 - faces anti-trust hurdles.

But airline and investment banking sources say an alliance between US Airways and American is more likely because that has a clearer path to regulatory approval than other combinations. It also offers valuable growth opportunities.

"I think AMR is more likely to end up in combination with somebody else simply because the industry dynamics dictate that," said a senior investment banker who was not authorized to speak publicly.

"There are huge economies of scale in purchasing fuel, the route structure and the labor negotiations and the negotiations with aircraft suppliers," the banker said. "There is a reason why the industry is consolidating and will continue to."

WHERE'S THE VALUE?

Since its Chapter 11 filing in November, AMR has been at the center of consolidation scenarios, with its strong Latin American routes the envy of bigger rivals such as Delta and United Continental. Delta President Edward Bastian on Thursday reiterated the company's desire to expand its Latin operations, which represent just 5 percent of total revenue.

But the almost insurmountable antitrust obstacles make Delta or United Continental - two U.S. airline behemoths - unlikely buyers of American, experts say.

US Airways has its own headaches. The carrier, which was formed from a 2005 merger with America West Airlines, has yet to fully integrate its two labor groups. AMR also has contentious relations with its own labor force.

Nevertheless, an AMR/US Airways pairing would create the world's biggest carrier in terms of passenger traffic. The two airlines flew a total of 297 billion passenger-kilometers in 2010, the most recent year for which data is available from the International Air Transport Association.

United Airlines and Continental airlines flew 293 billion passenger-kilometers in 2010, compared with Delta's 267 billion.

US Airways has a large presence in the southeastern and southwestern United States that AMR may covet. And US Airways' hub in Philadelphia could feed American's international network.

Additionally, US Airways - now a member of the Star Alliance - could bolster the global oneworld airline alliance, of which American is an anchor member. Oneworld is one of the top three global airline alliances in which members cooperate on routes and connections, essentially expanding their networks.

US Airways is willing to move to oneworld in the event of a merger with American, according to people familiar with US Airways' thinking.

"Basically, what we think about US Airways is they're very big in the U.S. domestic markets," said Helane Becker, an analyst with Dahlman Rose & Co. "They would make a good partner for someone who would want to consolidate more domestic."

US AIRWAYS AS A TARGET

Over the years, US Airways has tried to merge with Delta and United Airlines, but was rebuffed. Industry experts still see little chance of US Airways being acquired by either airline, pointing to too much overlap in their systems.

All three carriers declined to comment on their merger prospects.

Delta, which has hired Blackstone and Goldman Sachs to review potential merger opportunities, is studying several consolidation options including AMR and US Airways, according to people familiar with the matter.

Sources close to United Continental said that while the carrier is studying internally various combinations, it has little interest in a deal at this point. The company has not hired outside advisers and remains focused on the integration of United and Continental, the sources said.

Against this backdrop, a marriage of US Airways and American stands out as a more likely scenario than any other match. But it will likely be at least several months, if not a year or more, before any merger involving AMR materializes.

For now, AMR is downplaying merger possibilities, choosing to focus on restructuring. CEO Tom Horton has said AMR aims to emerge from Chapter 11 as an independent carrier.

The company has exclusive rights to submit a reorganization plan for up to 18 months and is currently focused on shedding costs and liabilities. That makes it difficult for anyone to attempt a merger without American's consent.

AMR believes it will have different alternatives to pursue once its restructuring is complete, with US Airways, JetBlue Airways and Alaska Air Group all among potential merger candidates, people close to American said.

A tie-up between US Airways and American "wouldn't be a marriage made in heaven the way that Delta and Northwest were and, to a lesser degree, Continental and United," Maxim Group's Neidl said, referring to networks that featured little pre-merger overlap.

"There would be some synergies between the two systems, but it wouldn't be as powerful a system as Delta or United after the combination," he said.

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (1)
lazydaze wrote:
Great two of the ugliest and most hated airlines will merge……

Feb 04, 2012 2:20pm EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.