Passports... for a price

LONDON Mon Feb 13, 2012 10:57am EST

Former U.S. citizen Adam Bilzerian holds up his St. Kitts and Nevis passport, outside his home in Basseterre January 31, 2012. Bilzerian, son of former corporate raider Paul Bilzerian, renounced his U.S. citizenship in 2008 after becoming disenchanted with its politics and acquiring a St. Kitts and Nevis passport through a ''citizenship by investment'' program. This two-island nation is one of three countries offering so-called citizenship by investment, burgeoning programs that bestow on foreigners the benefits of being a citizen - namely, a passport for a price. Picture taken January 31.   REUTERS/Stanford Conway

Former U.S. citizen Adam Bilzerian holds up his St. Kitts and Nevis passport, outside his home in Basseterre January 31, 2012. Bilzerian, son of former corporate raider Paul Bilzerian, renounced his U.S. citizenship in 2008 after becoming disenchanted with its politics and acquiring a St. Kitts and Nevis passport through a ''citizenship by investment'' program. This two-island nation is one of three countries offering so-called citizenship by investment, burgeoning programs that bestow on foreigners the benefits of being a citizen - namely, a passport for a price. Picture taken January 31.

Credit: Reuters/Stanford Conway

Related News

Related Topics

LONDON (Reuters) - For decades, the two-island nation of St. Kitts and Nevis exported sugarcane to keep its economy afloat. When sugar prices fell, St. Kitts began to sell an even sweeter commodity: its citizenship.

For $250,000, a foreigner can buy full rights as a citizen there. The transaction can take as few as three months and applicants need never visit the nation's sandy shores.

The allure? St. Kitts citizens can travel without a visa to more than a hundred countries, including Canada and all of Europe. They pay no personal income taxes, and the island's remote location in the West Indies serves as a safe haven, should the need for a quick move ever arise.

Demand for a second passport is "way up," says David Lesperance, a Canadian immigration lawyer. Among his recent clients: an Egyptian pro-democracy activist who worries about instability in his country, and a Chicago businessman who is convinced that the Occupy movements will lead to riots.

On his website, Lesperance provides a questionnaire to help determine how urgently a second passport is needed. He cites higher taxes, civil lawsuits, and terrorist attacks as top expatriation factors.

St. Kitts is one of at least two countries offering so-called citizenship by investment, burgeoning programs that bestow on foreigners the benefits of being a citizen - namely, a passport - for a price.

In St. Kitts, a passport goes for a $250,000 cash donation to the country's Sugar Industry Diversification Foundation, which was set up to benefit retired sugar workers. Investors can also buy approved real estate worth at least $400,000. Not included are fees to cover a mandatory background check. For nearby Dominica, the basic cost is $75,000.

A third country, Austria, may also offer citizenship for an investment. A provision in the Austrian Citizenship Act states that citizenship can be granted to an applicant if he or she has performed, or would later perform, "extraordinary services" to benefit the Austrian state.

Henley & Partners, a firm that specializes in repatriation, maintains that investing large sums of money constitutes an "extraordinary service." And Christian Kalin, a partner at the firm, said during a November conference in London that his clients have successfully obtained Austrian passports in this manner. In Henley's brochure, Henley says Austria extends citizenship for those who invest at least $10 million.

Alice Irvin, a spokeswoman at the Austrian embassy in Washington, D.C., strongly rejects suggestions that the country's citizenship is for sale. "We are aware that these claims have been around for a while, but they are baseless," she wrote in an email. Henley's CEO, Eric Major, says otherwise.

"The candidate has to have all the right trimmings," says Major. "It's been done, it's possible, but it's fairly rare."

Other Western countries also welcome rich foreigners. The United States, Canada, the United Kingdom and New Zealand all offer immigrant visas to those who invest enough money in certain types of enterprise. These programs don't instantly result in passports, but the visas are often a fast-track to naturalization, and in some cases, large investments can expedite citizenship.

"The idea that someone can gain fast-tracked citizenship in a country they have no ties to based on a wire transfer of funds or cash is a far cry from the vision of equal and participatory membership in a political community that is still reflected in many citizenship and naturalization laws," says Ayelet Shachar, a professor of law, political science and global affairs at the University of Toronto's Faculty of Law.

"It is likely that we will see more of these economic citizenship programs," Shachar says, "because there are significant pressures on both the demand and the supply side."

PRICING A PASSPORT

The Henley firm is at the center of the citizenship by investment movement. Registered in Jersey, an island in the English Channel known for its off-shore tax status in the United Kingdom, Henley bills itself as a "citizenship and residence planning" firm that manages and markets parts of the citizenship programs.

As well as helping rich people obtain second, and sometimes third, passports, Henley advises governments on how to attract high-net-worth individuals.

"Today, a person of talent and means need not limit his or her life and citizenship to only one country," reads Henley's website (link.reuters.com/qep36s). "Making an active decision with regard to your citizenship gives you more personal freedom, privacy and security."

To reach would-be clients, Henley organizes events and throws parties through the jet-set social networking site, A Small World (link.reuters.com/pep36s). Kalin is on the "council of experts" of the Sovereign Society, a Florida-based newsletter that circulates a six-step guide on how to live completely tax-free and offers subscribers a discount on Henley's services. Another forum is Henley's annual Global Residence and Citizenship conference, held last November in London.

Henley boasts that it can obtain passports for individuals and families in as few as three months. It also publishes a yearly Visa Restriction Index, which ranks a passport's value based on number of countries one can visit without a visa.

Last year, St. Kitts was 28th. Dominica was 54th. A U.S. passport and an Irish passport tied for the 5th most valuable. Finland, Sweden and Denmark tied for first place, and Germany and France second and third.

But those rankings can change as quickly as world events. Kalin warned as much at the opening of last year's conference, which Reuters attended.

"It's obvious to you why a Russian or a Lebanese, a South African or maybe a Chinese would need a second passport and residence," Kalin said. "But why would a person from a stable country want one?

"Until a few years ago, you enjoyed very wide and unhindered visa-free travel as a citizen of Denmark. Until September 2005, when a Danish newspaper published some cartoons. By early 2006, Danish embassies in Damascus, Beirut, Tehran were set on fire, and as a citizen of Denmark you found yourself as a target of extremists all over the world. In some countries, you couldn't even enter."

Kalin paused.

"That is, unless you had a second passport."

EXIT STRATEGY

Such instability is driving interest from the world's wealthiest, those involved in the programs say.

Major, Henley's CEO, says that during the past three years, Henley's citizenship and residence group more than doubled its staff, clientele, and earnings. He won't discuss the particulars but a Henley brochure says nine specialists now handle citizenship matters.

"Uncertainty is a big 'push' factor," Major says. "When North Korea shoots missiles, we get a lot of South Koreans. When there's chaos in Cairo, we get lots of Egyptians on the phone."

Val Kempadoo, a real estate developer in the Caribbean nation, says as many as 30 firms or individuals, based in Moscow, Dubai, Hong Kong, and other cities, are active in referring clients to St. Kitts for a passport.

Adam Bilzerian, a professional poker player and the son of former corporate raider Paul Bilzerian, said he worked through Henley to get citizenship in Austria. But put off by the cost and exclusivity of Austria's program, he purchased property in St. Kitts, filled out some paperwork, and within a year, became a Kittitian. Then, he became one of 231 Americans to renounce his U.S. passport in 2008.

In 2011, government records show, the number of Americans renouncing their citizenship reached 1,788 - the highest number since the government began keeping track in 1997.

Many Americans give up their citizenship to escape US taxes, but Bilzerian says his desire to leave was different. As a child, he saw his father go to prison for a panoply of financial crimes. In 2001, he watched as FBI agents raided his house. Then, while studying at Vanderbilt, he says he grew more politically conscious.

"When (George W.) Bush was elected for the second time, I felt that the country was going to be in such a downward spiral," Bilzerian said. "They were eliminating freedoms, restricting the bill of rights. It's so hard to keep yourself out of trouble. If the IRS thinks you're doing something wrong and audit you, they make your life a nightmare ... they run you to the ground."

That doesn't mean criminals necessarily find safe haven with a new passport. St. Kitts and Nevis, Dominica and Austria all have extradition treaties with the United States. But even though countries carry out backround checks, some question the thoroughness of the process.

Kim Dotcom, the founder of file-sharing website Megaupload, obtained a New Zealand residence permit by investing 10 million New Zealand dollars - or about 8.35 million U.S. dollars - in New Zealand government bonds through the country's investor visa program in 2010.

Dotcom, a German-Finnish dual national formerly known as Kim Schmitz, is in custody in New Zealand after denying charges of internet piracy and money laundering.

In Dominica, debate rages over the propriety of citizenship by investment.

"I am not a fan of the economic citizenship program," says Crispin Gregoire, Dominica's former ambassador to the United Nations. Gregoire says he wants greater transparency and better screening in the citizenship process.

"As it stands, it encourages people with something to hide. I understand that it must be a big source of income for the state, but they're not doing a good job of regulating it."

BUCCANEERS

Some Kittitians criticize the extent to which citizenship by investment is changing the political - and physical - landscape of their island. Dwyer Astaphan, a former Kittitian minister of national security, justice, and legal affairs, complains that former sugar industry workers, intended to be the beneficiaries of the sugar fund, have no way of knowing where the money goes.

"There's no transparency," he says. "Imagine making a contribution to a foundation to get citizenship of a country, but the inside information of the foundation is kept secret!"

Astaphan also questions where Henley's responsibility ends and the government's begins.

Wendell Lawrence, a partner at Henley, is also St. Kitts' ambassador to CARICOM, the Caribbean Community and Common Market economic organization. SIDF.org, the sugar program's website, is registered under the name of Henley's chairman and to its office address in Jersey.

The St. Kitts official in charge of the citizenship by investment unit, Cheryleann Pemberton, says the sugar program is "an independent charitable foundation" registered privately.

Kempadoo, who is developing a new resort called Kittitian Hill, worries that public-private partnerships such as Henley's compromise the island's sovereignty.

"They're pirates of the Caribbean," he says of companies handling the citizenship business. "The situation of the country predicates that they are open to citizenship by investment. St. Kitts' debt is 180 percent of its GDP. How can the government say no?"

GLOBAL BUSINESS

Henley has advised Canada and the United Kingdom on how best to attract wealthy individuals through their investor visa programs. "They're an obvious way to raise capital in trying times," says Major, of the expedited visas.

Henley is also advising several other countries that want to adopt citizenship by investment, Major says. Among them: Malta and Croatia.

All the countries that offer or hope to offer citizenship by investment have very low income tax rates, which make them particularly attractive to Americans, who face lifelong tax reporting requirements regardless of their residence.

The only way to escape U.S. taxes is by renouncing U.S. citizenship - and finding a new one.

Marshall Langer, an offshore tax and repatriation attorney who spoke at the November conference, talks about the benefits of the program in crasser terms.

"It's not enough to just move your assets anymore," Langer says. "Today, you have to move your ass."

(Editing by Blake Morrison)

(Reporting By Atossa Araxia Abrahamian)

FILED UNDER:
We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (1)
Great coverage of this subtle movement of capital happening globally.

Capital always flows to the optimum location. Optimum in terms of the risks and reward. Ask any FDI development heads whose team puts attracts foreign investment by highlighting their own nations as the best place to invest.

As individuals we like to live where the lifestyle and weather conditions match their expectations.

Individuals moving across borders (with their capital) to a more favorable destination is a natural combination of the two above.
Most likely, a lot more of this will happen in the coming years.

Retirees looking to fully leverage their not so large nest eggs will be at the forefront of this movement.

Some destinations that were not covered in this news item, can be found on the Investor Visa Network site and blog.

Feb 18, 2012 12:27am EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.