EU to punish Spain for deficits, inaction

BRUSSELS/MADRID Tue Feb 14, 2012 12:03pm EST

The Spanish flag flutters over the Colon square in central Madrid January 23, 2012.  REUTERS/Juan Medina

The Spanish flag flutters over the Colon square in central Madrid January 23, 2012.

Credit: Reuters/Juan Medina

Related Topics

BRUSSELS/MADRID (Reuters) - The European Union is likely to take action against Spain's newly installed government by May for delaying austerity measures ahead of a regional election next month, sources familiar with the situation have told Reuters.

Spanish and EU officials said in response to Reuters' story that the government in Spain was working hard to reduce its deficit and that it was premature to say the country might be punished.

Three senior EU officials told Reuters that a final decision still has to be made, but the European Commission believes the new government overstated the deficit figures for 2011 so the current year's data would look better. Spain is also not addressing quickly enough the deterioration in public finances expected in 2012, risking the country's longer-term growth, the officials said.

Asked if the European commissioner for economic and monetary affairs, Olli Rehn, would take action and recommend that the bloc's 27 finance ministers adopt sanctions against Madrid, one of the officials said: "It is very likely."

"It is not that we want to. But if there is a deviation, and it is almost inevitable, then we will have to," added the official, who spoke on condition of anonymity.

In a news conference on Tuesday Rehn denied that any decision had been taken with regard to the 2012 deficit forecast and that any report that it could lead to a sanction was "incorrect and misleading."

But asked about Spain's preliminary 2011 deficit figure, Rehn said it was too early to comment.

Any sanction of Madrid over failure to meet its deficit goals - potentially a fine - would be separate to the Commission's report released on Tuesday that named Spain among 12 EU countries with serious economic imbalances.

Spain has been under what's known as an excessive deficit procedure since April 2009 for breaching the EU's 3 percent of GDP deficit limit. Twenty-three of the EU's 27 members are under the procedure but now Madrid could face fines of up to 0.1 percent of its economic output for not cutting its deficit.

If confirmed, the sanctions would be a blow to new centre-right Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy who, Spanish officials say, had hoped to be given leeway on the country's deficit target in return for implementing ambitious economic reforms.

"It's speculation. It's misleading information," the government spokeswoman said on Tuesday. Government officials declined to comment to Reuters before the story was first published.

The story leaped to the top of Spanish language news websites on Tuesday and was widely discussed on social media including Twitter as well as domestic television news channels.


In late December, Rajoy, blaming the previous Socialist government, announced the deficit would reach 8 percent or more in 2011, mainly because of a larger-than-expected slippage in the public finances of Spain's regions.

The preliminary figure compared with the latest Commission estimate at the time of 6.6 percent.

The government spokeswoman said the government stuck by its preliminary estimate of 8 percent. The official 2011 deficit figure will be published in late March.

The Socialist party reacted to the Reuters story by demanding the government publish the 2011 deficit figure and present its budget.

"The government should quit making electoral calculations and not play with our economic credibility and solvency," the Socialist party said in a statement.

Although the Commission acknowledges that social security and unemployment payments exceeded forecasts last year, it considers the government's new figure to be exaggerated.

"We are waiting for the official figures, but we don't trust the current calculations," said one of the sources.

Another official said the Commission expected Eurostat, the EU statistics agency, to announce a figure of less than 8 percent when it releases updated forecasts on February 23.


The Commission, the EU's executive, also thinks the Spanish government's decision to delay until late March the presentation of the 2012 budget is risky, said the officials.

Rajoy and his economy minister, Luis De Guindos, have argued that they need the Commission's forecasts before they draft the new budget. But sources in Brussels and Madrid indicate they would rather delay any austerity measures until after regional elections in Andalusia on March 25.

The centre-right People's Party is expected to win the Andalusia elections for the first time since 1982, ending 30 years of socialist rule in Spain's biggest region. With more than 55 percent of people under 25 without a job, Andalusia is one of the regions most severely hit by the crisis in Europe.

"This delay is a pity. The new budget will be sent only in April and that's really unfortunate. I don't think they've realized how bad the situation is," one of the officials said, echoing the concerns of other sources.

Spain has said it will start implementing its new budget as soon as possible, but the officials believe that may not be until June - too late to change course meaningfully in 2012.


While the government maintains for now that it will reduce the deficit to 4.4 percent this year, the growth outlook makes that highly unlikely. The economy is expected to shrink 1.5 percent this year, according to the Bank of Spain, meaning the country needs to stimulate growth as well as reduce spending.

EU officials believe the Spanish prime minister has already convinced euro zone paymaster Germany and the International Monetary Fund to give him more time to reduce the deficit.

In November, the Commission forecast Spain would have a deficit of 6.6 percent of economic output for 2011 and 5.9 percent for 2012, based on an assumption of 0.7 percent GDP growth in each year.

But with the economy heading for recession, Spain's deficit commitments of 6 percent for 2011 and 4.4 percent for 2012 -- based on a 2.3 percent growth in 2012 -- look unattainable.

"Rajoy knows that necessary adjustments in the Commission's figures will have to follow these very negative forecasts," one of the officials said, adding that other countries too would expect leniency on their deficit targets amid a weakening economy. "His calculation is that the demand will be made collectively, sparing him a difficult negotiation."

(Additional reporting by Jan Strupczewski, Carlos Ruano and Fiona Ortiz; editing by Jeremy Gaunt and Patrick Graham)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (5)
SeniorMoment wrote:
The EU and Euro Zone both need to quickly force Spain to live within its budget or be expelled. In the future European government also need to spend the next 50 years building a pooled but normally unavailable reserve outside of national banks to cover expenses of the next close to Great Depression, so that Europe is not so unprepared for its future.

A good example is the Unemployment Compensation Funds of the 50 states in the USA. They have to maintain adequate reserves against future expenses and losses or face a direct federal unemployment tax on the state’s employers and mandatory increases in state unemployment taxes.

Feb 14, 2012 7:52am EST  --  Report as abuse
Stillhoping wrote:
I heard this EU battle referred to as the battle between the tight-fisted protestants (Germans) and the Club-Med Catholics (Greeks, Italians and Spanish). I’m starting to see some truth to it. Why must the budgets be so harsh that they very nearly cripple the growth of the economy in order to satisfy the banks? It doesn’t seem like any solution is good enough for the Germans unless the Mediterraneans are suitably punished for not having kept their noses to the grindstone all these years. The French and the Germans opened up a huge economic trading partner with the EU and now that the market is in debt to them for buying their exports they seem to want to hurt them for making them wealthy. This all might go a lot better if they could change the atmosphere of the discussion. It’s still going to hurt- but it doesn’t need this element of “you get what you deserve”. A spoonful of suger with the medicine, might go a long way.

Feb 14, 2012 12:37pm EST  --  Report as abuse
fred5407 wrote:
I think the USA is about to get run over by the same train that will run over the overspending countries in Europe. Like personal finances, nation finances must be on a sound footing. I think some of you commentors and writers should take note of how the finances of oil producing companies are handled. From what I have seen they have money to invest in new production, but that money must be returned within 12 to 18 months maximum. Countries in Europe, and the United States need to get their finances in order or they will be run over by the banks and investors.

Feb 14, 2012 2:00pm EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.