Top French court strikes down genocide bill

PARIS/ANKARA Tue Feb 28, 2012 2:58pm EST

France's President Nicolas Sarkozy and Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan (R) lay flowers at the Tsitsernakaberd Armenian Genocide Memorial Museum in Yerevan on October 6, 2011.   REUTERS/Eric Feferberg/Pool

France's President Nicolas Sarkozy and Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan (R) lay flowers at the Tsitsernakaberd Armenian Genocide Memorial Museum in Yerevan on October 6, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Eric Feferberg/Pool

Related Topics

PARIS/ANKARA (Reuters) - France's highest legal authority ruled Tuesday that a new law that would have made it illegal to deny the mass killing of Armenians by Ottoman Turks nearly a century ago was unconstitutional, a move quickly welcomed by Turkey.

The decision by France's Constitutional Council invalidates the law, which President Nicolas Sarkozy was due to ratify by the end of February, and appeared to set the stage for a thaw in diplomatic ties between Ankara and Paris.

Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu said his cabinet would meet to consider whether to restart economic, political and military contacts with France, which had been frozen after the French Senate passed the law on January 23.

"The correction of this grave error by the highest court in France is satisfying," Turkey's foreign ministry said in a statement.

France faces a presidential election on April 22 and May 6. Turkey had previously argued that Sarkozy's center-right government had supported the law to secure the votes of some 500,000 Armenians living in France.

Yet minutes after the ruling, Sarkozy's office said he had asked his government to draft a new version of the law which would take into account the Constitutional Council's decision - raising the prospect of further acrimony.

"The President of the Republic considers that (genocide) denial is intolerable and must therefore be punished," his office said in a statement.

Turkish officials had no immediate comment on Sarkozy's statement.

Turkey, which recognizes that many Armenians died in 1915, says "genocide" is an inaccurate term to describe the events because it argues that thousands were killed in massacres and counter-massacres led by both Turks and Armenians.

Armenians argue that 1.5 million of their people were killed deliberately by the Ottoman Turkish Empire. Sarkozy, who is lagging in opinion polls, would soon meet with representatives of France's Armenian community, his office said.

The Council ruled that the law, which would have imposed a 45,000-euro fine, a one-year prison sentence, or both, on genocide deniers, ran against the principles of freedom of expression written into France's founding documents.

French law already considers denial of Europe's Holocaust illegal. Far-right leader Jean-Marie Le Pen was famously found guilty of Holocaust denial for saying, in 1987, that the gas chambers of Nazi Germany had been a "point of detail" in the history of World War Two.

The Council said it was possible to put legal limits on freedom of expression to protect privacy and public order.

However, any such law would have to be "necessary, adapted and proportional" to the desired effect, while having the potential for creating a legal precedent.

(Reporting by Emile Picy and Nick Vinocur in Paris and Jon Hemming in; Editing by Maria Golovnina)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (9)
walfourth wrote:
I am amazed that Turkey has made such a big deal about something that happened when the Ottoman Empire was still around. Also, it is strange that France’s legal system would be so ready to pander to Turkey for no real reason.

Feb 28, 2012 12:17pm EST  --  Report as abuse
rob1990 wrote:
Oh wow, so we can’t deny about the Holocaust, but they(The Turks) can now deny the French equivalent? Why don’t they remove the ban on denying the Holocaust too, so we can finally get around to forgetting about it?

Feb 28, 2012 12:22pm EST  --  Report as abuse
geoff787 wrote:
Yes, and let’s forget the Spanish Inquisition and the Russian pogroms too! Oh and the genocide against Native Americans as well. Nanking Massacre too.

Feb 28, 2012 1:40pm EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.