India eyes Pakistan for access to Afghan mine bonanza

NEW DELHI/KABUL, March 21 Wed Mar 21, 2012 4:59am EDT

Related Topics

NEW DELHI/KABUL, March 21 (Reuters) - India will explore a route through rival Pakistan to transport iron ore from Afghanistan, the head of a consortium involved in the $11 billion project said, hoping that economic benefits will outweigh political hostility.

Despite a spike in tension in Afghanistan and uncertainty over the future once foreign combat forces leave in 2014, India was committed to developing the Hajigak mines and a 6 million tonne steel plant alongside, C. S. Verma, chairman of Steel Authority of India, told Reuters in an interview.

A contract is to be signed in two months in what will be the biggest foreign investment in Afghanistan's resources sector, larger than the $4.4 billion the Chinese are investing in the Aynak copper mine.

Mining work is expected to begin in late 2014 just when Afghan security forces take over security responsibilities and it remains a big concern whether they will be able to tackle a Taliban insurgency at its worst.

For the Indians, the challenge of transporting the ore out of the landlocked country is an additional issue given they have no direct access.

Pakistan is the obvious route and the alternative is a longer way westwards to Iran and then shipping it through the port of Chabahar that India has promoted to reduce Afghanistan's dependence on Pakistan.

But Verma told Reuters that the consortium made up of seven state and private firms was looking to move the ore along Pakistani roads crossing over to India, believing the benefits far outweighed political hostility between the two countries.

"What we have here is a gold mine, more than just an iron mine. I believe this is what everyone else will eventually realise. Ultimately the economic interests of everyone in the region including Pakistan will take precedence".

The Hajigak deposit contains an estimated 1.8 billion tonnes of ore, with an iron concentration of anything between 61 percent to 64 percent. "Where will you find such high grade ore? People have invested in mines elsewhere in the world with much less ferrous content," Verma said.

India, he said, would pursue the Pakistani option both as a way to truck the ore out and a route to build a slurry pipeline. "We are very bullish and believe that over the longer term this will be a productive investment. Not just for us, but others in the region including Pakistan. There are license fees, logistics, etc."


Pakistan and India have been at loggerheads over Afghanistan for years with Pakistan suspicious of India's extensive aid and reconstruction efforts there, and fearing a loss of influence.

But as India has powered its way into one of the world's fastest growing economies and added political heft, Pakistan's economy has slipped further back and is unable to match the scale of its investment in Afghanistan.

Pakistani businessmen have urged the country's military and political leaders to open up trade with India, arguing that they only way the economy can climb out of a low growth path is to do business with its giant neighbour to the east.

Pakistan has agreed to grant India Most Favoured Nation to promote trade and the two sides while still poles apart on political issues, are taking steps to expand the trade basket. Later this week, officials will hold talks on trade in petroleum products.

More crucially for Afghanistan, Pakistan has begun implementing a trade and transit treaty that allows Afghan exporters to send goods to the giant markets of India.

"Pakistan has been very clear that its red lines are security issues, things like training of forces etc," an Indian diplomat said in New Delhi.

"On other fronts, there is less of resistance. They are allowing goods from Afghanistan to go through, its a start."

He recalled how apples from Afghanistan's Wardak province were flown in the hold of state-carrier Air India in 2009 because Pakistan wouldn't allow the farmers to truck them to the Indian market.

Verma said seven of India's biggest companies in the steel sector were involved in the Afghan venture. "We know its difficult terrain, we have never done anything like this before, but we are bringing all our resources."

The other members of the consortium are: state-run miner NMDC Ltd and steelmaker Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd (RINL), and private sector steelmakers JSW Steel Ltd, JSW Ispat Steel Ltd, Jindal Steel & Power Ltd and Monnet Ispat & Energy Ltd.

(Editing by Michael Goergy and Robert Birsel)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (1)
Cipherman wrote:
“But as India has powered its way into one of the world’s fastest growing economies and added political heft, Pakistan’s economy has slipped further back and is unable to match the scale of its investment in Afghanistan”

Please stop comparing with India. If India was at war then it would have made sense to compare. Pakistan has been stuck in this foolish War on Terror for last 30 years. Lost over $100B in last 10 years. How it can compete in the global market.

Mar 21, 2012 11:17am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.