Analysis: Troubled euro zone states most at risk from high oil

BRUSSELS Tue Apr 10, 2012 8:21am EDT

The word oil is pictured on an oil bank at a recycling yard in London March 2, 2011. REUTERS/Stefan Wermuth

The word oil is pictured on an oil bank at a recycling yard in London March 2, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Stefan Wermuth

BRUSSELS (Reuters) - Oil prices at record levels in euro terms are threatening to rock the euro zone's economy more than might be expected, with those countries least capable of riding out a shock being the worst hit.

Standard estimates of the impact of oil prices on the euro zone economy are that a 10 percent price hike dents annual growth by some 0.2 percent in the ensuing three years, with disagreement over whether the hit is greater at the start or at the end.

However, these projections do not take into account the euro/dollar exchange rate and may underestimate the impact at a time of widespread austerity. Nor do they reflect potential differences across euro zone countries.

In dollar terms, oil prices are still some 13 percent short of the $147.50 per barrel Brent peak hit in July 2008. However, in euro terms, oil prices surpassed all-time highs last month.

So far this year, the price of oil in euros has risen as much as 17 percent. The International Monetary Fund already projects euro zone GDP to shrink by 0.5 percent over 2012.

Italian bank UniCredit estimates that a 10 percent rise in the euro-denominated price of oil depresses euro zone growth by 0.3 percentage points over a single year - not 0.2 percent over three years.

Marco Valli, one of Unicredit's economists, says the impact on the euro zone could be even greater because of the high level of prices.

"Moving from 50 to 55 euros and from 150 to 165 euros. These are both 10 percent, but they are quite different," he said.

The International Energy Agency (IEA) said last week that the European Union, extending beyond the 17-nation euro zone, was the hardest-hit of industrialized regions and would pay $500 billion for oil this year, an increase of $30 billion from 2011.


For a graphic on oil prices in various currencies:



High oil prices, meanwhile, hit different countries differently.

ING Economist Carsten Brzeski said that while high oil prices were big news in Germany they had not yet filtered through into consumer confidence there but that the worry was much bigger for consumers in peripheral countries.

"Consumers in the south are already squeezed as they lost wealth in real estate and stocks. A high oil price on top of this should again be one of the factors contributing to divergence rather than convergence in the euro zone," Brzeski said.

Thomson Reuters' Datastream shows a very close negative correlation between oil prices in euros and the annual growth rate in periphery euro zone countries - those currently struggling with unwieldy public debt and scant, if any, growth - over the past 20 years.

In simple terms, growth rates tend to decline several months after oil prices rise.

For Greece, Ireland, Portugal and Spain, the correlation coefficients range from -0.7 to -0.8 with a delay of four to eight quarters.

This is close to the absolute negative correlation value of minus 1, at which point statistically growth would always decline when oil prices rise.

For Italy and France, the link is weaker, marginally more than the euro zone as a whole, with a coefficient of -0.5. For Germany, there is barely any correlation at all.

In theory, the colder northern European countries should face a higher energy bill than the weaker debt-troubled nations in the south of the continent, where less fuel needs to be burned to heat homes and work spaces.

However, energy saving efforts, more pronounced in northern Europe, offer a counterbalance to price hikes, while southern Europeans have little to shield themselves from among the highest energy prices on the continent.

Spanish and Irish households paid the highest electricity prices in the European Union last year, after Malta and Cyprus, according to Eurostat data, while only the relatively rich Swedes and Danes pay more for their gas than do the Portuguese.

Greeks and Italians have to pay 16 and 17 percent more respectively for their gasoline, according to data from Europe's Energy Portal.

All this makes its way into overall inflation baskets.

Excluding newer eastern European euro zone members, Portugal has the heaviest weighting of energy within its basket of goods used to measure inflation, an indication that Portuguese spend more on energy than their euro zone peers.

Greece has the heaviest weighting for liquid fuels and motor fuels are significant components of inflation for both Portugal and Spain.

This does not guarantee that oil prices will lead to a severe downturn. But they are hitting at just about the worst time for an economy snuggling with recession, the burden of austere fiscal consolidation and tighter bank lending.

(Additional reporting by Robert-Jan Bartunek. Editing by Jeremy Gaunt.)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (2)
JaneT3 wrote:
I read an article by the economist Shaun Richards which raised the issue of the effect of high oil prices and went on to explain why it was very strong right now in the Euro’s periphery.

“Many countries are in an anti- boom right now

For countries in weak economic circumstances a high oil price hits them when they have less flexibility to adapt to it. If we look at how the US Energy Information Agency defines this we get the idea.

When the prices of petroleum products increase, consumers use more of their income to pay for oil-derived products, and their spending on other goods and services declines.

My point is that we have countries in Europe in particular where “spending on other goods and services” is either flat or declining. For example the UK has just revised her Gross Domestic Product figures this morning and they now show an economy which only grew by 0.7% in the last year and shrank in the last quarter by 0.2%. So there is much less flexibility than one might see in a boom. There must be no flexibility at all in Greece with an economy which shrank by around 7% over the last year or Portugal which shrank at 1.5% and is accelerating downwards. Here higher fuel prices will have to mean less consumption of something else.”

I thought at the time he was likely to be right and I now see others coming to the same conclusion six weeks later!

Apr 10, 2012 8:23am EDT  --  Report as abuse
fred5407 wrote:
I think the big mistake is to think that we can control Iran by sanctions. Another Obama and friends mistake. You can try to control other nations economy, but it always comes back to biting you where the “sun don’t shine”. I think that the meddling by Congress and Obama will cause a double dip depression and will cook the Democrats goose for the elections and maybe two years from now also.

Apr 10, 2012 3:34pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.