Six-term Utah senator faces Republican primary challenge

SANDY, Utah Sun Apr 22, 2012 6:30am EDT

Senator Orrin Hatch talks to reporters during a series of votes in Washington December 17, 2011. REUTERS/Benjamin Myers

Senator Orrin Hatch talks to reporters during a series of votes in Washington December 17, 2011.

Credit: Reuters/Benjamin Myers

Related Topics

SANDY, Utah (Reuters) - Veteran U.S. Senator Orrin Hatch of Utah will face a Republican primary fight after delegates to a party convention on Saturday denied him the nomination, forcing him into an election with a Tea Party-backed challenger who finished second.

Hatch, 78, won the day over nine challengers, but narrowly fell short of reaching the 60 percent of the vote needed in a pairing against his number two challenger to win the nomination outright and avoid the primary.

Heavily Republican Utah last elected a Democrat to the U.S. Senate more than four decades ago, so the victor in the state's Republican party contest is usually considered the presumptive winner of the general election in November.

The nominating convention held in Sandy, Utah, marked a test for the continuing strength of Tea Party activists, who played a decisive role nationally in the 2010 mid-term elections and helped unseat then-Republican Senator Bob Bennett of Utah.

In a final delegate vote on Saturday, Hatch took 59.2 percent of the votes compared to 40.8 percent for his strongest challenger, former state Senator Dan Liljenquist, who has a Tea Party following.

Hatch was only 32 delegates short of getting the required 60 percent vote that would have allowed him to avoid a primary contest. A total of 3,908 delegates participated.

In the first delegate count, eight challengers were eliminated.

Hatch told reporters afterward he was upbeat about the results and expected to win the June 26 Republican primary.

"I consider it a tremendous victory, considering what has happened in the past, and what we've had to do," Hatch said.

Hatch, 78, is a senior stalwart of the Republican's mainstream branch and was first elected to the U.S. Senate in 1976, which is also when he last competed in a primary. He seeks a seventh term which he vows will be his last.


Liljenquist, 37, once worked as a consultant in the Dallas office of Bain & Company, the same private equity and consulting firm Mitt Romney, the leading Republican presidential candidate, once ran. Liljenquist highlighted his corporate background in remarks to reporters on Saturday.

"For a long, long time Senator Hatch has been all we've known," Liljenquist said. "People are looking for leadership, passion and change."

"My background is corporate turnaround," he added. "If there was ever a time for a corporate turnaround team to go to Washington, it's now."

Liljenquist and state Representative Chris Herrod, another leading candidate before his elimination on Saturday, gained a Tea Party following for campaign rhetoric focused on such conservative themes as lowering taxes and bringing fresh ideas to the Washington establishment.

Hatch has spent $5.7 million this election cycle, while Liljenquist's expenditures total just over $227,000, Federal Election Commission records show.

Hatch is the ranking Republican Party member of the Senate Committee on Finance.

In remarks before Republican Party delegates on Saturday, Hatch launched a hard line conservative attack against President Barack Obama. "Let me tell you: Barack Obama's only been president for about a thousand days but he's already set our country back about a hundred years," Hatch said.

In another race, Utah's Republican Governor Gary Herbert, who drew some opposition from conservatives this year for vetoing a bill to curb sex education in schools, avoided a primary challenge on Saturday when he got 63 percent of the second delegate vote at the convention.

Bennett, the former U.S. Senator, overcame some of the rejection fellow Republicans dealt him in 2010, when on Saturday he received a standing ovation at the convention as he accepted an award on stage.

The Utah Republican Party convention held on Saturday in Sandy, a Salt Lake City suburb, is part of a unique electoral system in the state.

Voters first participate in a caucus, which was held last month, to chose delegates for the convention, and a primary is held only if a runoff is needed between the two leading candidates, unlike in other states where a primary is always the means of choosing a candidate.

(Writing by Alex Dobuzinskis; editing by Todd Eastham)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (12)
nosmtrthanu wrote:
gawd, they’re eating their own now.

Apr 22, 2012 7:59am EDT  --  Report as abuse
We do not need Hatch, a 78 yr old has been, most fondly remembered for the crucifying of Anita Hill, to place Clarence Thomas, a BIGOT, unqualified, on the Unsupreme Republican, Dictatorial Court.
New progressive blood is needed, with a new resolve to legislate based on the founders principles of DEMOCRACY and equal opportunity for ALL!
With Hatch and Specter both gone the Senate can be more in tune with the desires, hopes and dreams of ALL Americans.
The USA can not afford the COMPLETELY FAILED AGENDA of the Republican Conspiracy, the Republican Depression of 2008, the Republican NATIONAL DEBT of 17 TRILLION DOLLARS, YES folks the 2008 Depression and the 17 TRILLION DOLLAR NAT’L DEBT are the RESULT of REPUBLICAN FAILURE to GOVERN for THE PEOPLE, ALL of the PEOPLE!

Apr 22, 2012 8:50am EDT  --  Report as abuse
Eideard wrote:
Nothing to discuss. It looks pretty well pre-arranged, properly manipulated.

Hatch is enough of a conservative hack to mouth appropriate 19th Century slogans. He doesn’t care about leading anything except the line to the corporate political trough.

Good enough for Utah Republicans this time around.

Apr 22, 2012 9:42am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.