Europe thinks the unthinkable on Greece

BRUSSELS/LONDON Fri May 18, 2012 6:05pm EDT

Two men withdraw money from an ATM in central Athens May 16, 2012. REUTERS/Yannis Behrakis

Two men withdraw money from an ATM in central Athens May 16, 2012.

Credit: Reuters/Yannis Behrakis

Related Topics

BRUSSELS/LONDON (Reuters) - European officials are working on contingency plans in case Greece bombs out of the euro zone, the EU's trade commissioner said on Friday, as European share prices tumbled and Germany warned of continuing financial turmoil.

German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble, one of Greece's harsher critics, said market unrest fuelled by the euro zone debt crisis could last another year or two. "Regarding the crisis of confidence in the euro ... in 12 to 24 months we will see a calming of the financial markets," he said.

Germany seemed to be increasing pressure on Athens when Greece's government spokesman said that Chancellor Angela Merkel raised the idea of Greece holding a referendum on its eurozone membership -- something Berlin promptly denied.

European shares hit their lowest level since December, depressed by the prospect of a Greek euro exit spreading a wave of contagion in the currency bloc which could engulf much larger economies such as Spain's.

Policymakers insist they want Greece to remain in the euro zone but European Union trade commissioner Karel De Gucht said the European Commission and the European Central Bank were working on scenarios in case it has to leave.

"A year and a half ago there maybe was a risk of a domino effect," De Gucht told Belgium's Dutch-language newspaper De Standaard.

"But today there are in the European Central Bank, as well as in the Commission, services working on emergency scenarios if Greece shouldn't make it. A Greek exit does not mean the end of the euro, as some claim."

Speculation about such planning has been rife, but de Gucht's comments, which were confirmed by a person close to him, appeared to be the first time an EU official has acknowledged the existence of contingencies being drawn up.

A German finance ministry spokeswoman, asked about plans for a possible Greek exit, said without elaborating: "The German government naturally has the responsibility to its citizens to be prepared for any eventuality."

But the European Commission's top economics official, Olli Rehn, later dismissed De Gucht's comments.

"Karl De Gucht is responsible for trade. I am responsible for financial and economic affairs and relations with the European Central Bank." Rehn said. "We are not working on the scenario of a Greek exit. We are working on the basis of a scenario of Greece staying in."

A spokesman for the Commission, the EU's executive, also wrote on Twitter there was no active planning.

"(The) European Commission denies firmly (that it) is working on an exit scenario for Greece," Oliver Bailly wrote. "(The) Commission wants Greece to remain in the euro area."

Confusion increased when Greek government spokesman Dimitris Tsiodras said that Merkel raised with the Greek president the idea of Greece holding a referendum on its euro zone membership next month, together with national elections.

Tsiodras's statements evoked memories of a bitter row between Athens and the EU last year, when Greece's then Prime Minister George Papandreou proposed a referendum on the country's bailout deal -- an idea the EU vehemently rejected, helping accelerate the downfall of Papandreou's government.

Greek political leaders on Friday angrily rejected a referendum and a German government spokesman denied that Merkel ever proposed it. "This is false and we completely dismiss this," the spokesman told Reuters.

World shares slid and German borrowing costs hit record lows as uncertainty about Greece's future in the euro zone and a deepening Spanish banking crisis bolstered safe-haven assets.

Investors were rattled by a ratings downgrade of 16 Spanish banks by Moody's Investors Service, although the move had been expected.

Sentiment has soured to such an extent that an opinion poll showing Greeks are returning to establishment parties which support the country's bailout had little impact.

If they vote that way in June 17 elections, Greece's place in the euro zone would look more secure and the threat of contagion to countries such as Spain would diminish.

The poll, the first conducted since talks to form a government collapsed and a new election was called, showed the conservative New Democracy party in first place, several points ahead of the radical leftist SYRIZA which has pledged to tear up its 130 billion euro bailout program.

"It's up to Greek politicians to explain the reality to their people and not make false promises," Schaeuble told France's Europe 1 radio. "We want Greece to stay in the euro but meet its commitments and that's a decision that's up to the Greeks."


The biggest fear for European leaders is that a Greek meltdown, which would surely follow the stoppage of its bailout funds, triggers a domino effect among the currency bloc's weaker members.

Even aside from the contagion threat, they have huge problems of their own.

Spanish banks' bad loans rose in March to their highest level in 18 years, figures from the Bank of Spain showed on Friday, underscoring the problems facing the government as it attempts to clean up the sector.

The Bank of Spain said bad loans rose to 8.37 percent of the banks' outstanding loans, the highest since August 1994 and up from 8.3 percent in February.

Banks beset by bad property loans which could deteriorate further, along with overspending in indebted regions, are the two biggest risks for Spain's public finances.

Investors believe Spain needs to aggressively address these two issues to avoid a bailout and pushed Spanish borrowing costs to euro-era highs this week.

The fact the euro zone crisis is moving back into an acute phase will place it centre stage at a weekend summit of leaders of the G8 top industrialized nations.

President Barack Obama, the G8 host, has urged European leaders repeatedly to do more to stimulate growth, fearing contagion from the euro crisis that could hurt the U.S. economy and his chances of re-election in November.

New French President Francois Hollande is pressing for measures to boost growth rather than cut debt, Britain's David Cameron has become increasingly vocal in demanding Europe acts more decisively, Canada's Stephen Harper has been a frequent critic, and of the euro zone G8 members, Italian premier Mario Monti was calling for pro-growth policies before Hollande was.

That could leave Germany's Angela Merkel, who insists debt-cutting programs cannot be diluted, cutting a lonely figure.

(Additional reporting by Julien Toyer and Jesus Aguado in Madrid, Harry Papachristou and Peter Graff in Athens and Thomas Krumenacker in Berlin; Writing by Mike Peacock; Writing by Philippa Fletcher, Ruth Pitchford and Giles Elgood)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (11)
moweddell wrote:
What goes around comes around! Quite simply, this is true within the Euro community now that Greece is on the verge of bankruptcy. Causes: First, there is more government spending that income, however, the welfare state beneficiaries still demand their funds. Then there is a loss of confidence in the ecomomy and there is a run on the banks. Then citizens or the government decides that it is better policy not to pay their lenders, thus reducing their hugh debts, and this results in both no credit and no cash. Finally, Greece must leave the Euro, or be kicked out, and start printing their own money, just like Germany did around WWI, with their “Noteguilds”, which was worthless then as now, except for interest to “coin and currency collectors”. With the bad debts and unpaid contracts, the creditors and lending countries have more “bad” worthless paper, just like the banks had in the USA contributing to their financial crises . Now when each creditor or lending country, bank, or creditor begins to fail, like in a row of stacked dominos, each causing the other to fail, this will cause a hugh international ecomomic crisis. Then the last nails in the coffin have been hammered in too deeply for any simple solution. I certainly hope the USA isn’t stupid enough to spend our money on this spiraling lost cause. Let Greece and the European Euro states fend for themselves. They chose the welfare state and knew that sooner or later you will run out of others peoples money to spend. Is this a lession perhaps for the USA to learn? One suggestion to avoid this type of crisis: do not spend more money than you earn and seek solvency. The solialist government welfare state does not work in practice. Monty Weddell Dallas, TX

May 18, 2012 10:03am EDT  --  Report as abuse
Josorr wrote:
Well said, Monty. I describe the situation in this way:

Problem: In a democracy, too many will vote for officials that legislate social programs and promote government welfare beyond the ability of the economy to support, especially in an economic downturn. They do so because they want something for nothing and can get it by voting for it, rather than paying for it.

Solution: Deny the right to vote to anyone that receives more from the government in the form of welfare and social programs than they pay in taxes. Deny the recipients right to vote for the length of the term of the elected office. In the U.S. that would mean that if you receive, for example, food stamps, you would not be able to participate in elections to the U.S House of Representatives until 2 years after you stop receivng food stamps. For the office of U.S. President, it would be 4 years, and the Senate, 6 years.

Unfortunately, it’s too late. The majority won’t vote for officials that support such a solution because they want their welfare handout or the benefit of some social program. They don’t care about the financial strength of their nation or the future of their children. They only care about themselves.

There, I’ve said it. Now stand back and watch them scream!

Joseph M. Sorrell Green Forest AR

May 18, 2012 1:02pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
scythe wrote:
scream what?

your arguments are a general miscagenation of anti-socialist rhetoric and a fear of wealth being redistributed through taxes

europe is 27 countries, not 52 states – texans love to maximise

we all got to know one texan by the name of bush jr. – seems he was confused about some weapon of mass destruction, but that didn`t stop him spending billions of taxpayers money trying to find it

and the young lives of america’s finest

May 18, 2012 5:56pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.