Babies fed soy formula develop as well as others

NEW YORK Fri Jun 1, 2012 4:21pm EDT

Related Topics

NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - One-year-olds raised on breast milk, regular formula or soy formula seem to fare equally well in brain development, a new study suggests.

Past studies have found that, as far as growth, babies given soy formula develop the same as their peers fed breast milk or traditional formula made from cow's milk. But not much was known about signs of brain development, like an infant's early language skills.

The new study, reported in the journal Pediatrics, suggests that brain development is similar, whether babies get breast milk, standard formula or the soy variety.

"I think parents who feed their children formulas, whether soy or milk, should not worry about any adverse effects," senior researcher Thomas M. Badger, a professor at the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences in Little Rock, said in an email.

In general, experts recommend breast milk as the best source of nutrition for babies.

Groups like the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) say that ideally, babies should be fed breast milk alone for six months, then keep getting breast milk along with solid foods for at least their first year.

But that's not always possible for moms to manage. In fact, studies in the U.S. show that while close to two-thirds of infants start on breast milk, most parents switch to formula within their babies' first six months.

And Badger, who also directs the Arkansas Children's Nutrition Center, said that parents "should not feel guilty for using formula."

For their study, Badger and his colleagues followed 131 infants who were breastfed exclusively for at least six months; 131 who were started on milk-based formula within their first two months of life; and 129 who were given soy formula.

The researchers gave the babies standard tests of language skills and other developmental milestones every three months during their first year.

In the end, the study found, the average scores were similar in all three groups -- and all were within normal range.

The breastfed babies did show a "slight potential advantage" in scores, the researchers say. But it's not clear whether that numerical edge would make a difference in real life.

Right now, the AAP ranks cow's milk formulas as the second choice to breast milk, with soy formulas coming in third.

That is partly because milk formulas have been around much longer and have not been linked to any adverse effects, Badger explained.

With soy formulas, there has been a theoretical concern that certain plant compounds in soy could be harmful to children's development. But that, Badger said, is mainly based on lab studies where animals were given large doses of those compounds, purified from soybeans.

Badger is on the science advisory board to the Soy Nutrition Institute, an industry-funded group. The study itself was funded by the U.S. Department of Agriculture.

He said his team will continue to follow the children in this study, until at least age 6, to see if there are any long-range effects linked to soy formula.

"In five years, our study will be complete and we will know much more about the longer-term effects," Badger said.

SOURCE: Pediatrics, online May 28, 2012.

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (1)
umojaresearch wrote:
Comparing Soymilk, or formula to Breast Milk is like comparing real butter to yellow dyed grease, which is called almost like butter.

What the Public never hears is how many infant deaths are attributed to soy formulas and other canned and powdered infant formula products.

It’s a known fact, Breast Milk has been and will always be better than artificial infant formulas. The Breast Milk is superior because it contains live enzymes, natural antibiotics, vitamins, minerals and trace minerals needed to properly develop and protect the infant.

An article in the Internet suggested, Never give soymilk to an infant, cautions the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s National Agriculture Library. Babies younger than 12 months cannot digest soymilk properly like cow’s milk or breast milk. Feeding baby soy milk in place of infant formula or breast milk poses a great, even fatal danger, warns the Organic Consumers Association. Because soymilk lacks sufficient nutrients, a baby could die of malnutrition caused by consuming only soymilk.

Another story suggests, Because medical examiners also found no evidence of choking as a result of consuming the food, or any signs of foul play, the police instead began focusing on what the infants had eaten. The police cleaned out two nearby supermarkets of Soy milk and cornmeal for testing.
New York Times October 21, 2005

1. U.S. Department of Agriculture: Feeding Your Baby from Birth to 4 Months
2 Organic Consumers Association: Warning to Parents About the Dangers of Soy Milk for Babies
3. National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences: Soy Infant Formula
4. Kids Health: About Milk Allergy
5. American Academy of Pediatrics: Use of Soy Protein-Based Formulas in Infant Feeding

Jun 01, 2012 4:57pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.